IELTS Task 2: Police surveillance — Band 6 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Police should be given more powers to monitor ordinary citizens in order to prevent crime. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Police should be given more powers to monitor ordinary citizens in order to prevent crime. To what extent…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Police should be given more powers to monitor ordinary citizens in order to prevent crime. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Nowadays, technology such as CCTV cameras and phone tracking gives the police a big chance to watch people. Some people think the police should have more powers to monitor ordinary citizens to prevent crime. I partly disagree with this idea.

On the one hand, more surveillance can really help to reduce crime. If there are cameras in the streets, criminals will be afraid to steal or attack because they know that they can be caught. Also, when a crime happens, the police can find the criminal faster using the video records. For example, in London there are thousands of cameras and they helped to catch the terrorists after the attack in 2005. Monitoring the internet can also help to stop dangerous groups before they do something.

On the other hand, I think that giving too much power to the police is dangerous. The first problem is the privacy. Every person has the right to live without being watched all the time, and it is not comfortable when the state read your messages or know where you go. The second problem is that the information can be misused. The police officers or hackers could sell personal data, or the government may use the surveillance to control the opposition and punish people who criticise it. In some countries this already happens.

Moreover, monitoring ordinary citizens is not very effective, because most of them are not criminals. The police will waste time and money on watching innocent people, instead of concentrating on real suspects.

In my opinion, the police should be allowed to monitor only people who are suspected of crime, with a permission from a court. Cameras in public places are acceptable, but private communication should be protected.

In conclusion, I do not agree that police need more powers to watch ordinary citizens, because the risks are greater than the benefits.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The position 'I partly disagree' is stated at once and the final paragraph holds it (court permission, cameras acceptable, private communication protected). However, the pro-surveillance paragraph relies on a single London 2005 example and the vague claim that monitoring the internet 'can also help to stop dangerous groups before they do something', so support is thin and uneven compared with the privacy argument.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6 The position 'I partly disagree' is stated at once and the final paragraph holds it (court permission, cameras acceptable, private communication protected). However, the pro-surveillance paragraph relies on a single London 2005 example and the vague claim that monitoring the internet 'can also help to stop dangerous groups before they do something', so support is thin and uneven compared with the privacy argument.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 Paragraphs follow a clear on-the-one-hand / on-the-other-hand plan, with 'The first problem... The second problem...' guiding the reader through the privacy and misuse points. The short 'Moreover' paragraph about effectiveness is isolated and the opinion paragraph partly repeats the conclusion, which makes progression slightly mechanical.
Lexical Resource Band 6 Vocabulary is adequate and sometimes topic-specific ('surveillance', 'misused', 'the opposition', 'suspects'), but there are imprecise choices such as 'a big chance to watch people' and 'it is not comfortable when the state read your messages'. Article slips ('the privacy') and repeated 'people'/'police' show a limited range of paraphrase.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 A mix of simple and complex sentences is used, including conditionals ('If there are cameras... criminals will be afraid') and relative clauses ('people who are suspected of crime'). Errors recur, mainly subject-verb agreement ('the state read... or know') and article use ('the privacy', 'a permission'), but they rarely block meaning.

Marked mistakes

  1. it is not comfortable when the state read your messages or know where you go
    it is uncomfortable when the state reads your messages or knows where you go (GA)
    'The state' is singular, so both verbs need the -s ending, and 'uncomfortable' is the natural adjective.
  2. The first problem is the privacy.
    The first problem is privacy. (GA)
    'Privacy' is used here as a general uncountable noun and takes no article.
  3. with a permission from a court
    with permission from a court (GA)
    'Permission' is uncountable and cannot take 'a'.
  4. gives the police a big chance to watch people
    gives the police an unprecedented ability to observe the public (LR)
    'Chance' means opportunity; 'ability' or 'capacity' with 'observe' is more precise and formal.
  5. Monitoring the internet can also help to stop dangerous groups before they do something.
    Monitoring online communication can help the authorities to intercept plots by extremist groups before an attack takes place. (TR)
    The idea is stated but not explained or exemplified, and 'do something' is too vague for this level.

What would raise the band

Develop the pro-surveillance paragraph with one explained example instead of the vague internet-monitoring sentence, and then proofread specifically for singular verbs and articles ('the state reads', 'privacy', 'permission').

Band 8.0

Prompt: Police should be given more powers to monitor ordinary citizens in order to prevent crime. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

I disagree with the idea that the police should be given wider powers to monitor ordinary citizens. Surveillance can help with specific investigations, but the case for extending it to the general population is weak, and the costs to freedom are high.

Supporters point out that monitoring helps solve crimes. Footage from cameras identified the suspects after the 2005 London bombings, and tracing a suspect's phone can place him near a crime scene. These are real benefits, but they come from the targeted use of surveillance against people who are already under suspicion. They do not demonstrate that watching everyone prevents crime. Reviews of research on CCTV have found that its effect on crime is modest, concentrated mainly in car parks, and that it does little to deter violent offences, which are often impulsive. Collecting the messages and movements of millions of law-abiding citizens also produces a huge volume of data, much of it useless, which can divert resources from conventional police work.

More importantly, mass monitoring changes the relationship between citizens and the state. When people know they may be observed, they tend to avoid joining protests, reading controversial material or contacting journalists, even if nothing they do is illegal. This chilling effect weakens the freedoms on which democratic societies depend. Large databases are also targets for hackers and can be misused by officials, as several scandals involving police officers looking up the records of acquaintances have shown.

A more balanced approach would allow the police to monitor individuals only when a court has approved a warrant on the basis of evidence, and would limit how long data is kept and who can see it. Visible cameras in places such as stations and car parks, with clear public notices, could remain.

In short, extending police powers over ordinary citizens risks more than it gains, and surveillance should stay targeted and subject to independent oversight.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 7.5 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8

The weakest criterion is Task Response at 7.5: The opening commits to disagreement and the essay maintains it while genuinely engaging the other side (2005 London footage, phone tracing) before explaining why those benefits come from targeted rather than mass surveillance. The 'chilling effect' argument is well extended; a few claims, such as the findings on CCTV in car parks, are asserted without a clear source.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 7.5 The opening commits to disagreement and the essay maintains it while genuinely engaging the other side (2005 London footage, phone tracing) before explaining why those benefits come from targeted rather than mass surveillance. The 'chilling effect' argument is well extended; a few claims, such as the findings on CCTV in car parks, are asserted without a clear source.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Each paragraph has one clear job: benefits conceded, then the harm to citizen-state relations, then a regulated alternative. Phrases such as 'These are real benefits, but...' and 'More importantly,' link the argument skilfully, and 'They do not demonstrate' refers back accurately. The cohesion is mostly invisible, with only slight over-reliance on additive sentence openings.
Lexical Resource Band 8 Precise topic vocabulary is used naturally: 'chilling effect', 'law-abiding citizens', 'divert resources', 'warrant', 'independent oversight'. Collocations are accurate and there are no spelling or word-form errors, though a couple of phrases ('a huge volume of data') are slightly less sophisticated than the surrounding language.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8 The essay uses a wide variety of structures: concession ('Surveillance can help... but the case... is weak'), reduced relative clauses ('involving police officers looking up the records'), and embedded clauses after 'would limit' ('how long data is kept and who can see it'). Almost all sentences are error-free and punctuation is controlled.

Marked mistakes

  1. Reviews of research on CCTV have found that its effect on crime is modest, concentrated mainly in car parks
    Some reviews of research on CCTV, such as a widely cited Campbell Collaboration study, have found that its effect on crime is modest and concentrated mainly in car parks (TR)
    Naming or hedging the evidence would make a key empirical claim more convincing than a general reference to 'reviews'.

What would raise the band

To reach the top of the scale, support the CCTV research claim with a named source or hedge it, and vary the sentence openings in the second paragraph so the concessions and counter-arguments read less like a list.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 answer separates targeted surveillance (which works) from mass monitoring (which has not been shown to prevent crime) and uses the idea of a "chilling effect" to explain the harm to democratic freedoms. The 6.0 answer lists privacy and misuse as general problems and claims cameras make criminals afraid without evidence. It also has errors such as "the state read your messages or know", "the privacy" and "a permission from a court".

Check your essay on this task

Task: Police should be given more powers to monitor ordinary citizens in order to prevent crime. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →