Some people think that the government should provide free public transport. Others believe that people should pay for it. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that the government should provide free public transport. Others believe that people…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Some people think that the government should provide free public transport. Others believe that people should pay for it. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Public transport is very important for people who live in cities. Some people think that the government should make it free, but other people believe that passengers should pay for it. In this essay I will discuss both views.
On the one hand, free public transport would have many benefits. First of all, it would help poor people, students and old people, who often can not afford the tickets. They would be able to travel to work, university or hospital without any problem. Moreover, if buses and trains are free, more people will use them instead of private cars. This will reduce traffic jams and air pollution, what is a big problem in many big cities. For example, the city of Tallinn in Estonia has introduced free transport for its residents and the number of passengers have increased.
On the other hand, providing free transport is very expensive. The government must pay for the fuel, the salaries of drivers and the maintenance of vehicles, and the money will come from taxes. So people who never use the buses will also pay for them, which is not fair. In addition, when the transport is free, people may use it without reason and the buses will be overcrowded, so the quality of service will go down. If passengers pay, the companies will have money to buy new vehicles and improve the service.
In my opinion, public transport should not be completely free, but the tickets must be cheap, and some groups of people, such as the pensioners and the students, should travel for free. This way the government will not lose too much money and the service will stay good.
In conclusion, free public transport has both advantages and disadvantages. I think the best solution is a low price with discounts for people with low income.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The essay has clear paragraphs and signposting with 'On the one hand', 'First of all', 'Moreover' and 'In addition'. Cohesion is mechanical in places and the relative pronoun in 'air pollution, what is a big problem' breaks the link between the clauses.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | Both views are discussed with relevant points (access for the poor and less pollution against cost, tax unfairness and overcrowding), and the position in favour of cheap fares with free travel for pensioners and students is clear. The Tallinn example is stated without detail, and 'the quality of service will go down' is not explained. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6 | The essay has clear paragraphs and signposting with 'On the one hand', 'First of all', 'Moreover' and 'In addition'. Cohesion is mechanical in places and the relative pronoun in 'air pollution, what is a big problem' breaks the link between the clauses. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The writer uses topic words like 'maintenance', 'overcrowded' and 'afford' appropriately, but relies on common words ('big', 'very expensive', 'many'). 'Can not' should be written as one word, 'cannot'. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | A mix of simple and complex sentences appears, including conditionals ('If passengers pay, the companies will have money'). Agreement and relative-pronoun errors, such as 'the number of passengers have increased', recur but meaning is clear. |
Marked mistakes
-
what is a big problem in many big cities
which is a big problem in many large cities (GA)
'What' cannot introduce a relative clause after a noun; use 'which'. Also avoid repeating 'big'. -
the number of passengers have increased
the number of passengers has increased (GA)
The subject is 'the number', which is singular. -
can not afford the tickets
cannot afford the tickets (LR)
'Cannot' is written as one word in standard English.
What would raise the band
Develop each example with detail (for instance what happened in Tallinn) and check agreement and relative pronouns before submitting.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Some people think that the government should provide free public transport. Others believe that people should pay for it. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Many cities struggle with congestion, pollution and unequal access to mobility, and some campaigners believe that making public transport free would address all three. Others argue that passengers should continue to pay fares. While free travel has real attractions, I believe a heavily subsidised but not entirely free system is the more sustainable choice.
The argument for free transport begins with fairness and access. For low-income households, fares can take a significant share of the monthly budget, and removing them would allow people to reach jobs, colleges and clinics that would otherwise be out of reach. There is an environmental logic too. If bus and metro journeys cost nothing, some drivers might leave their cars at home, reducing traffic and emissions. Tallinn, which made travel free for residents in 2013, is often cited, although studies there suggest that most of the new passengers were people who previously walked or cycled rather than drivers.
That finding points to the main weakness of the proposal. Fares typically cover a substantial part of operating costs, so abolishing them would require governments to find the money elsewhere, either by raising taxes or by cutting services, and the latter would harm those who most depend on transport. Free travel can also encourage unnecessary short journeys that crowd vehicles during peak hours. Charging a modest fare gives operators a stable income to invest in new vehicles and extra routes, which are what actually persuade motorists to switch.
In my opinion, the sensible approach is a low, simple fare structure accompanied by free or heavily discounted travel for children, pensioners, students and the unemployed. This protects those in greatest need while preserving funding for better frequency and reliability, which research shows matter more to commuters than price.
In conclusion, completely free public transport sounds appealing, but its costs and limited effect on car use suggest that targeted subsidies are a wiser use of public money.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8.5 · CC 8.5 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8.5: Both sides are developed with strong support: fairness for low-income households, the Tallinn finding that new passengers were walkers or cyclists, and the argument that fares fund investment. The position, a subsidised but not entirely free system with targeted concessions, is clear throughout. The claim 'which research shows' is unspecified.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8.5 | Both sides are developed with strong support: fairness for low-income households, the Tallinn finding that new passengers were walkers or cyclists, and the argument that fares fund investment. The position, a subsidised but not entirely free system with targeted concessions, is clear throughout. The claim 'which research shows' is unspecified. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | 'That finding points to the main weakness of the proposal' links paragraphs 2 and 3 smoothly, and the paragraph openers 'The argument for free transport begins with fairness and access' and 'In my opinion, the sensible approach' make a logical sequence. Cohesion is natural and rarely mechanical. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8.5 | Precise, flexible vocabulary appears throughout ('congestion', 'unequal access to mobility', 'operating costs', 'frequency and reliability', 'sustainable'). Collocation is mostly sophisticated, with only minor stylistic slips. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | Complex sentences such as 'Tallinn, which made travel free for residents in 2013, is often cited, although studies there suggest...' are accurate. The essay is essentially free of grammatical errors. |
Marked mistakes
-
which research shows matter more to commuters than price
which surveys of commuters often indicate matter as much as price (TR)
The cited research is not identified and the claim is stated more strongly than the evidence supports.
What would raise the band
Name your sources or soften references to 'research' to remove the last remaining weakness.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay engages critically with the evidence (Tallinn's new passengers were mostly former walkers and cyclists, fares as a funding source, reliability mattering more than price) instead of just citing it as support. The 6.0 essay uses the same Tallinn example only as a positive claim and offers less analysis of costs. The 8.5 text is also grammatically more accurate, while the 6.0 text has errors like 'what is a big problem', 'the number of passengers have increased' and 'can not afford', plus straightforward sequencing with 'Firstly/Moreover/In addition'.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people think that the government should provide free public transport. Others believe that people should pay for it. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.