Cities should ban private cars from their centres to reduce pollution. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Cities should ban private cars from their centres to reduce pollution. To what extent do you agree or…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: Cities should ban private cars from their centres to reduce pollution. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
In many big cities, the centres are crowded with cars and the air is dirty. Some people suggest that private cars should be banned from city centres. I agree with this idea because it can reduce pollution and make the city more pleasant, although there are some difficulties.
The main reason is that cars produce harmful gases which cause health problems like asthma and heart disease. In my city, Tashkent, the air in the centre is very bad in winter and many people have to wear masks. If cars are not allowed, the air quality will be improved quickly. Also, there will be less noise and traffic jams, so people can walk or ride bicycles safely.
Another advantage is that the city centre will become more attractive for tourists and shops. For example, in some European cities where the cars are banned, the streets are full of people, cafes and street musicians. This is good for the local economy.
On the other hand, a ban can cause problems for some people. The elderly and disabled persons cannot always use public transport easily, and they need cars to go to the hospital or the shops. Moreover, the people who work in the centre may have to travel from far and it will take them much more time if the public transport is not good enough.
To solve these problems, the government should build a good system of buses, metro and parking places outside the centre before the ban start. Disabled people should be given special permission.
In conclusion, I believe that banning private cars from city centres is a good solution to reduce pollution, but it should be done carefully with a good public transport system.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The vocabulary is sufficient and mostly accurate, with 'harmful gases', 'asthma' and 'public transport' well chosen. There is a tendency to rely on simple words ('good', 'bad', 'problems'), and 'travel from far' is not a natural collocation.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The writer agrees with a ban in the introduction and sustains this view, balancing it with problems for the elderly and commuters and with solutions such as buses, a metro and special permission for disabled people. The Tashkent winter air example is a personal and relevant touch, but the European cafes example is generic and the claim about the local economy is not explained. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | Each paragraph has one job: health, attractiveness, drawbacks, solutions. Links like 'Also', 'Another advantage' and 'On the other hand' are suitable, though they are quite mechanical. 'To solve these problems' neatly connects the last body paragraph to the one before. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The vocabulary is sufficient and mostly accurate, with 'harmful gases', 'asthma' and 'public transport' well chosen. There is a tendency to rely on simple words ('good', 'bad', 'problems'), and 'travel from far' is not a natural collocation. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | Passive forms ('will be improved'), relative clauses and conditionals show reasonable range. Errors recur in articles and verb forms ('where the cars are banned', 'before the ban start'), but they rarely affect understanding. |
Marked mistakes
-
before the ban start
before the ban starts (GA)
'Ban' is singular and needs a third-person -s, or the passive 'is introduced'. -
in some European cities where the cars are banned
in some European cities where cars are banned (GA)
Plural nouns used in a general sense take no article. -
have to travel from far
have to travel a long way (LR)
'From far' is not idiomatic; use 'from far away' or 'a long distance'.
What would raise the band
Replace the general European cafes example with one named city and a specific result, and proof-read for third-person -s and articles. Both changes would lift Task Response and Grammar by half a band.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Cities should ban private cars from their centres to reduce pollution. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
I agree that city centres should be closed to private cars, though I would argue that a ban works only when it is introduced as part of a wider change in how people move around.
The case for restriction rests mainly on health. Traffic is the largest source of nitrogen dioxide in most urban areas, and the densest concentration of it occurs in precisely those centres where pedestrians, office workers and children spend the most time. Cities that have acted have seen measurable results: after Madrid restricted traffic in its central district in 2018, nitrogen dioxide levels there fell noticeably, and similar schemes in Oslo and parts of Paris have been followed by reductions in noise and road accidents. Space matters too. A car carrying one commuter takes up as much road as a dozen bus passengers, so removing cars frees room for wider pavements, cycle lanes and trees.
The most common objection is that a ban penalises people who have no practical alternative. Residents with mobility problems, tradespeople carrying equipment and delivery drivers all have legitimate reasons to be in the centre. A sensible policy would therefore allow exemptions for these groups and permit deliveries at restricted hours, rather than apply a blanket prohibition. Small shopkeepers also worry about losing customers, although studies of pedestrianised streets in several European cities suggest that footfall and takings tend to rise once the traffic has gone.
The ban will fail, however, if it is imposed before reliable public transport exists. Commuters who live on the outskirts will not leave their cars at home if buses are infrequent or if no park-and-ride sites are available. For that reason I would favour a phased approach, with investment in trams, metro lines and cycle networks first and restrictions tightened afterwards.
Overall, I believe city centres are better served by people than by vehicles, and a carefully prepared ban is an effective way to reduce pollution.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource at 8: The thesis, that a ban works 'only when it is introduced as part of a wider change', is clear and fully argued through health, space, exemptions and phasing. The Madrid, Oslo and Paris references add credibility, although 'fell noticeably' gives no figure and the pedestrianised-streets claim is not backed by a named study.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The thesis, that a ban works 'only when it is introduced as part of a wider change', is clear and fully argued through health, space, exemptions and phasing. The Madrid, Oslo and Paris references add credibility, although 'fell noticeably' gives no figure and the pedestrianised-streets claim is not backed by a named study. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | Paragraphs are tightly organised around benefits, objections, preconditions and conclusion, and the link 'For that reason I would favour a phased approach' follows logically from the preceding paragraph. Cohesion is unobtrusive and 'however' is placed skilfully within the sentence. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | Phrases such as 'penalises people who have no practical alternative', 'footfall and takings' and 'park-and-ride sites' show precision and control of collocation. A few expressions remain slightly vague, for instance 'measurable results' or 'a dozen bus passengers'. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | There is a wide variety of structures: concessive 'though', 'although', fronted adverbials, and the parallel bare infinitive in 'rather than apply'. Almost all sentences are error-free and punctuation is controlled. |
Marked mistakes
-
nitrogen dioxide levels there fell noticeably
nitrogen dioxide levels there fell by roughly a quarter (TR)
A figure or a sourced percentage makes the example more convincing than 'noticeably'. -
A car carrying one commuter takes up as much road as a dozen bus passengers
A car carrying one commuter takes up far more road space per person than a bus does (LR)
The comparison as worded is unclear and cannot be verified.
What would raise the band
Back at least one case with a number or a source-type reference, as the weakest moments are the unquantified 'fell noticeably' and 'tend to rise'. That precision is what separates Band 8 from 9 on Task Response.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 answer supports its case with specific evidence (Madrid, Oslo, the road-space cost of one commuter per car) where the 6.5 answer relies on general statements and one personal example. It also treats the disadvantages in more depth, proposing exemptions, restricted delivery hours and a phased approach, while the 6.5 answer only suggests building public transport and permits. The 6.5 text has article and agreement errors ("before the ban start", "where the cars are banned") and mechanical linking, whereas the 8.5 text links ideas flexibly and is almost error-free.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Cities should ban private cars from their centres to reduce pollution. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.