Many children now learn a foreign language from the age of five or six. Do the advantages of this development outweigh the disadvantages?
Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Many children now learn a foreign language from the age of five or six. Do the advantages of this…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Many children now learn a foreign language from the age of five or six. Do the advantages of this development outweigh the disadvantages?
Nowadays, many parents want their children to study a foreign language from the age of five or six. In my opinion the advantages of this trend are bigger than the disadvantages, but some problems exist.
The main advantage is that young children learn languages easier than adults. Scientists say that the brain of a small child is very flexible, so he can copy the pronunciation of native speakers and he will not have a strong accent. For example, children who start English at six often speak much better than people who start at fifteen. Also, language learning at an early age gives long term benefits. A person who knows two or more languages have more opportunities in the future, for instance to study abroad or to find a well-paid job in an international company. Moreover, some studies show that bilingual children are better at solving problems and have a good memory.
However, there are some disadvantages. Firstly, young children have a short attention and a lot of lessons can make them tired. If the teaching method is boring, the child can lose interest and hate the language for the rest of his life. Secondly, there is a problem with quality. In many schools there are not enough teachers who speak the language well, so children may learn mistakes from the teacher and it's hard to correct them later. Another problem is that the extra lessons take time from other important subjects, such as mother tongue, reading and maths. Parents who push their children too much can create stress for them.
In my opinion, early language learning is useful if it is organised in a playful way, with songs, games and stories, not with homework and tests. Schools should also employ qualified teachers.
To conclude, starting a foreign language early has more positive effects than negative ones, but the teaching must be adapted to the age of the children.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: Sentence variety is acceptable, with 'if' clauses and 'so' result clauses, but basic agreement errors recur: 'A person who knows two or more languages have'. The contraction in 'it's hard to correct them later' is informal, and adverb forms are wrong.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The writer addresses both parts and gives an opinion that advantages are 'bigger than the disadvantages', but with a conditional on playful teaching. The claims that children 'will not have a strong accent' and that bilingual children have a good memory are stated as facts rather than explained. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | Clear paragraphs and sequencing ('The main advantage', 'Firstly', 'Secondly', 'Another problem') make the essay easy to follow. The cohesion relies on listing devices, and the penultimate paragraph repeats the 'in my opinion' stance of the introduction. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | There is adequate vocabulary with some less common items: 'flexible', 'native speakers', 'bilingual' and 'well-paid job'. Word form and collocation slips such as 'a short attention' and 'learn languages easier' show limited control. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | Sentence variety is acceptable, with 'if' clauses and 'so' result clauses, but basic agreement errors recur: 'A person who knows two or more languages have'. The contraction in 'it's hard to correct them later' is informal, and adverb forms are wrong. |
Marked mistakes
-
learn languages easier than adults
learn languages more easily than adults (GA)
An adverb is needed to modify the verb 'learn'. -
A person who knows two or more languages have more opportunities
A person who knows two or more languages has more opportunities (GA)
The subject is 'a person', which is singular. -
young children have a short attention
young children have a short attention span (LR)
'Attention span' is the correct noun phrase. -
the advantages of this trend are bigger than the disadvantages
the advantages of this trend outweigh the disadvantages (LR)
'Outweigh' is the standard academic verb for this comparison. -
it's hard to correct them later
it is hard to correct them later (GA)
Contractions are best avoided in formal writing.
What would raise the band
Revise subject-verb agreement and fixed noun phrases such as 'attention span' and 'more easily', then explain one claim, like the flexible child brain, instead of just asserting it.
Band 8.0
Prompt: Many children now learn a foreign language from the age of five or six. Do the advantages of this development outweigh the disadvantages?
Foreign language lessons now begin at five or six in many school systems, a considerable change from the situation a generation ago. I believe that the advantages of this trend outweigh the disadvantages, provided that lessons are suited to the age of the children.
The most persuasive advantage is that young children are naturally good at absorbing the sounds of a language. Before puberty, they are better than adults at acquiring native-like pronunciation, and they learn through play and repetition without the self-consciousness that makes many teenagers reluctant to speak. A child who has been exposed to a second language for several years before secondary school is therefore likely to reach a higher level of fluency than one who begins later. There are broader cognitive benefits as well. Bilingual children tend to be more adept at switching between tasks and at ignoring distractions, and learning another language early may increase tolerance for other cultures, which is valuable in a globalised society.
Nevertheless, the trend carries risks. Early lessons are only effective if the teaching is good, and many primary schools lack teachers with a high level of proficiency, so pupils may internalise incorrect pronunciation or grammar that is difficult to unlearn. Timetables are also limited: time given to a foreign language reduces the hours available for reading, mathematics or play, and children who are still developing literacy in their mother tongue could become confused by learning two writing systems at once. Finally, parents who demand rapid results may put young learners under unnecessary pressure, leading to anxiety and a lasting dislike of the subject.
These problems are not inevitable. If lessons consist of songs, stories and games rather than formal grammar and tests, and if schools invest in teacher training, children can enjoy the process and benefit from it.
In conclusion, introducing foreign languages at an early age offers real linguistic and cognitive advantages, and these outweigh the drawbacks as long as teaching is of high quality and developmentally appropriate.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 7.5 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8
The weakest criterion is Task Response at 7.5: The position that advantages outweigh disadvantages 'provided that lessons are suited to the age of the children' is clear and held throughout, and the cognitive, quality and timetable points are well developed. A few statements, such as children being 'better than adults at acquiring native-like pronunciation', are stated as universal without any hedging.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 7.5 | The position that advantages outweigh disadvantages 'provided that lessons are suited to the age of the children' is clear and held throughout, and the cognitive, quality and timetable points are well developed. A few statements, such as children being 'better than adults at acquiring native-like pronunciation', are stated as universal without any hedging. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | Paragraphs are well organised, with 'The most persuasive advantage', 'Nevertheless' and 'Finally' guiding the reader. The short fourth paragraph beginning 'These problems are not inevitable' shows skilled use of a concession-then-solution structure. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | The writer uses wide and precise vocabulary: 'acquiring native-like pronunciation', 'self-consciousness', 'internalise incorrect pronunciation' and 'developmentally appropriate'. Errors are rare, and only 'language' and 'children' are slightly repeated. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8 | Structures are varied and mostly accurate, including 'provided that', 'if ... and if ...' conditionals and 'the self-consciousness that makes many teenagers reluctant to speak'. The occasional overlong sentence in the third paragraph is the only real weakness. |
Marked mistakes
-
they are better than adults at acquiring native-like pronunciation
they are generally better than adults at acquiring native-like pronunciation (TR)
Hedging is needed because this is a tendency, not an absolute rule. -
could become confused by learning two writing systems at once
could become confused if the second language uses a different writing system (TR)
The claim only applies in some language pairs, so the condition should be stated.
What would raise the band
Qualify sweeping claims with hedging words such as 'generally' or 'tend to' and add a short example to support the cognitive benefits to reach the top of Band 8.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 essay explains why early learning works (sounds, play, lack of self-consciousness) and identifies specific risks such as incorrect input from under-qualified teachers and literacy confusion, then shows how to avoid them. The 6.0 essay offers similar but more basic points and has errors such as 'A person who knows two or more languages have', 'a short attention' and 'learn languages easier'. The 8.0 text is also more precise in expression, for instance 'internalise incorrect pronunciation' and 'developmentally appropriate'.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Many children now learn a foreign language from the age of five or six. Do the advantages of this development outweigh the disadvantages?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.