Some students choose to take a year off between school and university to travel or work. What are the advantages and disadvantages of this?
Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some students choose to take a year off between school and university to travel or work. What are the…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Some students choose to take a year off between school and university to travel or work. What are the advantages and disadvantages of this?
Nowadays more and more students decide to take a gap year after finishing school, and they use this time to travel or to work. This essay will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of this practice.
There are several benefits of a gap year. Firstly, students can gain life experience. If a young person travels to other countries, he learns how to be independent, how to manage money and how to communicate with people from different cultures. For example, a student who works as a volunteer in Africa for six months will understand real life problems, and this experience can help him later. Secondly, a gap year allows students to rest after the stress of exams. Many teenagers are tired after years of study, so a break can give them a new motivation and they will study better at university. Moreover, working in a job can help them to save money for tuition fees, and it also give them some skills for their CV.
However, there are also disadvantages. The main one is that some students lose the habit of studying during the year off. After a long break it can be difficult to return to the lessons and the discipline, and some of them even never go to university. Another problem is cost. Travelling is expensive, and if the family is not rich, they cannot afford to support the child for a year. In addition, when students start university one year later, they will also finish and start working later, so they lose one year of salary. Their friends who went to university directly will be ahead of them.
In my opinion, the advantages are stronger than the disadvantages, if the student has a clear plan. A gap year which is spent only on sleeping at home is a waste of time, but a year of working or volunteering is very useful.
To conclude, a year off can be a good decision for many students, but they should plan it carefully.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: The writer mixes simple sentences with 'if', 'because' and relative clauses, but errors recur in agreement and pronouns: 'it also give them some skills' and the shift from 'a young person' to 'he'. Meaning is always clear, but accurate complex sentences are in the minority.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | Both sides are covered (life experience, rest and savings versus lost study habits, cost and a delayed salary) and the writer gives a clear verdict that a gap year is worthwhile 'if the student has a clear plan'. Support is mostly general, such as the volunteer in Africa who 'will understand real life problems', and the disadvantages are less developed than the advantages. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | The progression from advantages to disadvantages to opinion is clear, with workable markers such as 'Firstly', 'Secondly', 'Another problem' and 'In addition'. The opening 'This essay will discuss...' is formulaic and the 'Their friends who went to university directly' sentence is left hanging as a final point. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The vocabulary is adequate and understandable, with useful items like 'discipline', 'tuition fees' and 'support the child'. The range is plain and repeats 'students' and 'gap year', and 'some of them even never go to university' shows an awkward word order. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | The writer mixes simple sentences with 'if', 'because' and relative clauses, but errors recur in agreement and pronouns: 'it also give them some skills' and the shift from 'a young person' to 'he'. Meaning is always clear, but accurate complex sentences are in the minority. |
Marked mistakes
-
it also give them some skills
it also gives them some skills (GA)
The subject 'it' is third-person singular, so the verb needs -s. -
some of them even never go to university
some of them never even go to university (LR)
'Never' should come before 'even' in this common collocation. -
he learns how to be independent
they learn how to be independent (GA)
Generic 'he' for 'a young person' sounds dated; the neutral 'they' is now the standard choice in formal writing.
What would raise the band
Develop each disadvantage with one concrete consequence, for example what 'lose the habit of studying' means in first-year exams, and fix present-tense agreement ('it also gives').
Band 8.0
Prompt: Some students choose to take a year off between school and university to travel or work. What are the advantages and disadvantages of this?
An increasing number of school leavers postpone university for a year in order to travel or earn money. This practice offers genuine benefits, but it also carries risks that students and parents should weigh up before deciding.
The principal advantage is personal development. Spending months in an unfamiliar environment, whether on a farm in New Zealand or in a hostel in South America, requires a young person to budget, solve problems and adapt to unfamiliar situations without the support of family. Employers and admissions tutors often value such experiences, as they suggest maturity and initiative. A gap year can also help students to make a better choice of course. Many eighteen-year-olds choose a degree under pressure from parents or teachers, and a period of work can show them what they enjoy and what they do not, which reduces the likelihood of dropping out later. For those from low-income families, a year of paid work may also be the only way to fund their studies without taking on heavy debt.
On the other hand, there are drawbacks. Travelling is expensive, and students without financial support may find the experience out of reach, which means gap years can reinforce existing inequalities. There is also the risk that students lose momentum. After a year away from academic work, some find it hard to readjust to deadlines and independent study, and a minority never begin their course at all. A delayed start also pushes back the date on which graduates begin earning, which may matter to students in expensive degrees.
Overall, I believe the advantages outweigh the disadvantages for students who have a purpose, such as a paid job, a volunteering placement or a language-learning programme, and who have a confirmed university place waiting for them. A year spent without direction, by contrast, is unlikely to be beneficial.
In conclusion, a gap year can build maturity and clarify goals, but it is best taken by students who plan it carefully and have the means to do so.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 7.5 · GRA 8
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 7.5: There is a precise, natural range: 'school leavers', 'admissions tutors', 'reinforce existing inequalities' and 'lose momentum'. Some repetition ('unfamiliar environment' and 'unfamiliar situations' in one sentence) and the vague 'expensive degrees' keep it just below fully flexible.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | Both sides are developed with specific reasoning, from maturity and better course choice reducing dropout, to inequality and delayed earnings. The position that advantages outweigh disadvantages 'for students who have a purpose' and a place waiting is precise and consistently held. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | Each paragraph has one clear job and moves smoothly with 'On the other hand', 'There is also the risk' and 'by contrast'. The pronoun 'they' in 'as they suggest maturity and initiative' is slightly ambiguous between employers and experiences. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 7.5 | There is a precise, natural range: 'school leavers', 'admissions tutors', 'reinforce existing inequalities' and 'lose momentum'. Some repetition ('unfamiliar environment' and 'unfamiliar situations' in one sentence) and the vague 'expensive degrees' keep it just below fully flexible. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8 | Most sentences are error-free and well varied, including 'whether on a farm in New Zealand or in a hostel...', relative clauses and a 'which reduces the likelihood of dropping out later' result clause. The few weaknesses are stylistic rather than grammatical. |
Marked mistakes
-
adapt to unfamiliar situations
cope with new challenges (LR)
'Unfamiliar' has just been used in the same sentence, so a different word avoids repetition. -
as they suggest maturity and initiative
as such experiences suggest maturity and initiative (CC)
'They' could refer to the employers rather than the experiences. -
which may matter to students in expensive degrees
which may matter most to students on long, costly courses such as medicine (TR)
A concrete example would extend this last disadvantage as fully as the others.
What would raise the band
Add one concrete example or statistic to the shortest point (delayed earnings) and vary repeated words like 'unfamiliar' to push precision toward band 8.5.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 essay develops each point with a reason and a consequence (choosing a degree under pressure, a work year funding studies without debt, gap years reinforcing inequality) and sets a clear condition for when a gap year works. The 6.0 essay has the same overall structure but is more general, with a typical volunteering example. It also contains errors ('it also give them', 'some of them even never go'), and the 8.0 essay shows more precise, natural vocabulary.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some students choose to take a year off between school and university to travel or work. What are the advantages and disadvantages of this?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.