Many schools are now asking students to wear a uniform every day. Do you think the benefits of this trend outweigh the drawbacks?
Band 6 and Band 7.5 answers to the IELTS task “Many schools are now asking students to wear a uniform every day. Do you think the benefits of this trend…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Many schools are now asking students to wear a uniform every day. Do you think the benefits of this trend outweigh the drawbacks?
In many countries, schools require students to wear uniform every day, and this trend is becoming more popular. Personally, I think the benefits are bigger than the drawbacks, although uniform is not perfect.
The first benefit of school uniform is equality. When all students wear the same clothes, nobody can see who is rich and who is poor. Because of this, children from poor families don't feel ashamed, and there is less bullying about fashion and brands. For example, in my school there was a girl whose parents couldn't buy her expensive shoes, and other kids laughed at her. Uniform could solve this problem. Another advantage is that it save time and money for the parents. They don't need to buy a lot of clothes and the students don't need to decide every morning what to wear. Also, uniform makes the students feel as a part of one community, and it can improve discipline. In addition, it is easier for teachers to recognise strangers who enter the school.
On the other hand, there are some disadvantages. Firstly, uniform limits the students' freedom to express their personality. Teenagers like to show their style and individuality, and they may feel that school is like army or prison. Secondly, uniform can be uncomfortable, especially in hot weather, and some schools have very strict rules about the colour of socks or the length of hair, which is unnecessary. Moreover, parents must still buy the uniform and sometimes it is quite expensive, because it can be bought only in special shops.
In conclusion, I believe that the advantages of the school uniform outweigh the disadvantages. Schools should choose simple and comfortable uniform and not make too strict rules, then students will be happy to wear it.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: Complex sentences with 'because', 'when' and 'which' are attempted, but there are frequent slips with articles and agreement: 'it save time', 'like army or prison'. Errors do not obscure meaning but appear in many sentences.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The writer answers the question directly, arguing benefits outweigh drawbacks, and includes useful points on equality, time and money, and loss of individuality. The personal example about the girl whose parents 'couldn't buy her expensive shoes' helps, but several ideas such as discipline and recognising strangers are listed without explanation. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6 | The structure of benefits, drawbacks and conclusion is clear with sequencers such as 'Firstly', 'Secondly' and 'Moreover'. In the benefits paragraph, however, ideas are strung together with 'Another advantage', 'Also' and 'In addition' without any development, which feels mechanical. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | Vocabulary is sufficient and suited to the topic: 'ashamed', 'bullying', 'individuality' and 'discipline'. The range is limited by repetition of 'uniform' and 'students', and the expression 'feel as a part of one community' is not idiomatic. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | Complex sentences with 'because', 'when' and 'which' are attempted, but there are frequent slips with articles and agreement: 'it save time', 'like army or prison'. Errors do not obscure meaning but appear in many sentences. |
Marked mistakes
-
it save time and money for the parents
it saves time and money for parents (GA)
A singular subject 'it' needs a verb ending in -s. -
feel as a part of one community
feel part of one community (LR)
'Feel part of' is the natural phrase, without 'as a'. -
like army or prison
like an army or a prison (GA)
Singular countable nouns here need an article.
What would raise the band
Pick two benefits and develop each with explanation and consequence, instead of adding a third and fourth in one line, and proofread for articles, as in 'like army or prison'.
Band 7.5
Prompt: Many schools are now asking students to wear a uniform every day. Do you think the benefits of this trend outweigh the drawbacks?
Compulsory school uniform, once associated mainly with a few countries, is now spreading to many more. Supporters believe it improves behaviour and reduces inequality, while opponents see it as a limit on self-expression. On balance, I think the benefits are greater, provided that the uniform is practical and the rules are reasonable.
The strongest argument in favour of uniform concerns social pressure. Teenagers are acutely aware of brands and fashion, and when ordinary clothes are allowed, those who cannot afford the latest trainers or jackets can be singled out and teased. A common uniform removes this visible marker of income, which can create a more inclusive atmosphere. It also simplifies family life: parents do not need to buy a large school wardrobe, and mornings involve fewer arguments over what to wear. Some schools report that uniform reinforces a sense of belonging and pride in the institution, and teachers can identify outsiders on school premises more easily, which has safety benefits.
Against this, critics argue that clothing is a form of self-expression and that forcing every student into identical outfits discourages individuality at an age when young people are forming their identities. This concern has some merit, especially where rules extend to hairstyles or jewellery. Uniforms can also be costly. In schools that require items from a single supplier, they may cost more than ordinary clothes, and many are uncomfortable in hot climates, which could affect concentration in class.
However, these drawbacks can be limited by sensible policy. Schools can allow some personal choice within a basic dress code, such as a colour palette rather than a rigid design, permit comfortable fabrics, and enable families to buy from several suppliers or through second-hand exchanges. Students can still express themselves through hobbies, speech and out-of-school clothing.
In conclusion, school uniform helps to reduce social divisions and simplifies daily life, and its disadvantages can be reduced by flexible, affordable regulations.
Why Band 7.5, not 8
TR 8 · CC 7.5 · LR 7.5 · GRA 7.5
The weakest criterion is Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 7.5: Paragraphs follow a logical order from benefits to criticisms to solutions, signposted by 'Against this' and 'However, these drawbacks can be limited'. The unclear subject 'many' in 'many are uncomfortable in hot climates' interrupts otherwise smooth referencing.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The essay weighs both sides and takes a clear stand ('the benefits are greater, provided that the uniform is practical'), then adds a paragraph suggesting policy fixes such as colour palettes and several suppliers. The claim that 'Some schools report' belonging and pride is unsupported by detail, but overall development is strong. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 7.5 | Paragraphs follow a logical order from benefits to criticisms to solutions, signposted by 'Against this' and 'However, these drawbacks can be limited'. The unclear subject 'many' in 'many are uncomfortable in hot climates' interrupts otherwise smooth referencing. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 7.5 | Precise and varied vocabulary appears throughout, e.g. 'singled out and teased', 'visible marker of income', 'inclusive atmosphere' and 'colour palette'. A few phrases are vague ('has safety benefits') and 'once associated mainly with a few countries' is slightly loose. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 7.5 | A wide variety of structures is used accurately, including 'provided that', participial and relative clauses, and a colon sentence. The flaws are minor, such as the plural 'many' with an unclear referent, and the text is largely error-free. |
Marked mistakes
-
and many are uncomfortable in hot climates
and many designs are uncomfortable in hot climates (CC)
'Many' lacks a clear noun, so the reader cannot tell whether it means schools, suppliers or uniforms. -
Some schools report that uniform reinforces a sense of belonging
Surveys in some schools suggest that uniform reinforces a sense of belonging (TR)
Naming the source type makes the claim more credible than a vague report.
What would raise the band
Make referencing airtight by naming the noun after 'many' and 'they', and back up claims such as 'some schools report' with a clear example.
What separates the higher band
The 7.5 essay discusses uniform with more developed reasoning, for example how a common uniform removes a visible marker of income, and it offers practical ways to reduce the drawbacks (colour palettes, several suppliers, second-hand exchanges). The 6.0 essay relies on a personal anecdote and general statements, and it has repeated errors ('it save time', 'feel as a part', 'like army or prison') and sometimes unnatural wording. The 7.5 text keeps a balanced, well-linked argument and a wider range of grammar.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Many schools are now asking students to wear a uniform every day. Do you think the benefits of this trend outweigh the drawbacks?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.