IELTS Task 2: Minority languages — Band 6.5 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people believe that minority languages should be taught in schools to keep them alive. Others think it is a waste of resources. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people believe that minority languages should be taught in schools to keep them alive. Others think…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: Some people believe that minority languages should be taught in schools to keep them alive. Others think it is a waste of resources. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Many languages in the world are disappearing today. Some people think that schools should teach minority languages to save them, while others say it is a waste of resources. In this essay, I will look at both views and explain my opinion.

Those who support teaching minority languages have some strong arguments. Firstly, a language is not only a way of communication but also a part of culture. When the language die, the songs, stories and traditions connected with it usually disappear too. Schools are the best place to prevent it, because many children today speak only the majority language at home and they will never learn their grandparents' language if nobody teaches them. For example, in Wales the government introduced Welsh lessons in all schools, and now the number of young speakers is growing.

However, other people think that this is not a good use of money. Teachers, textbooks and special programs are expensive, and the government could spend this money on more important subjects like maths, science or English. Also, minority languages are not useful for finding a job, so students and parents may see them as a lost of time. If a child has to study three languages, he can have less time for other lessons and his results can be worse.

In my opinion, schools should teach minority languages, but the programs must be realistic. It is not necessary to teach the whole curriculum in this language; a few lessons per week is enough to keep the interest. Moreover, technology can help to reduce the cost, for instance with online courses and apps.

In conclusion, I believe that protecting minority languages is worth the cost because it keeps the cultural diversity of the world. Governments should support schools to do this in a reasonable way.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The vocabulary is sufficient for the topic (cultural diversity, curriculum, majority language), with an attempt at expressions such as a part of culture. Errors in word form, such as a lost of time, and some imprecise phrasing, such as keep the interest, reduce the precision.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 Both views are discussed and the writer's opinion, that schools should teach minority languages in a realistic way, is clearly stated and supported with a few lessons per week and online apps. The Welsh example is relevant, but the claim that the number of young speakers is growing is stated without detail.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The essay is logically organised (support, opposition, opinion, conclusion), and linkers such as Firstly, However, Also and Moreover are appropriate. The paragraph about costs ends with a fairly weak statement and the transition into the writer's view is abrupt.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The vocabulary is sufficient for the topic (cultural diversity, curriculum, majority language), with an attempt at expressions such as a part of culture. Errors in word form, such as a lost of time, and some imprecise phrasing, such as keep the interest, reduce the precision.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 Complex sentences with when- and because-clauses are used, but errors reduce accuracy: When the language die, a lost of time and he can have less time for other lessons. The semicolon in the fourth paragraph is used correctly.

Marked mistakes

  1. When the language die
    When the language dies (GA)
    Language is singular, so the verb needs -s.
  2. a lost of time
    a waste of time (LR)
    Lost is a verb form; the noun is loss, and waste of time is the standard collocation.
  3. a few lessons per week is enough to keep the interest
    a few lessons per week is enough to maintain interest (LR)
    Maintain interest is the natural collocation; is is acceptable because a few lessons per week is treated as one amount.
  4. he can have less time for other lessons
    he will have less time for other lessons (GA)
    A logical consequence in the conditional needs will.

What would raise the band

Revise your subject-verb agreement and word-form errors such as lost and loss, because they hold GA and LR at 6. Support the Welsh claim with a specific figure or time period.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Some people believe that minority languages should be taught in schools to keep them alive. Others think it is a waste of resources. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Thousands of minority languages are at risk of extinction, and one proposed remedy is to teach them in schools. Critics argue that scarce education budgets should be spent elsewhere. I believe that school programmes are worthwhile, though only if they are designed realistically.

The main argument for teaching minority languages is that schools are often the last place where a language can be passed on. In many communities, children grow up hearing the national language on television and in the playground, so the home language gradually becomes something they understand but do not speak. Once a generation fails to learn it, recovery is extremely difficult. The revival of Welsh illustrates what is possible: after it became a compulsory subject in schools, the share of young people who speak it rose markedly. Language also carries local knowledge, such as place names, oral history and expertise about the environment, which cannot be fully translated.

Those who see such programmes as a waste of resources are not entirely wrong. Training teachers and producing materials for a language spoken by a few thousand people is expensive per student, and the economic return is hard to measure because the language rarely helps in finding work. Parents may also worry that time spent on it comes at the expense of subjects that influence exam results and career prospects.

Even so, these objections can largely be addressed. Minority-language teaching does not have to replace core subjects; a few hours each week, delivered partly through online materials and community volunteers, can maintain basic fluency at modest cost. Research on bilingual children also suggests that learning an additional language does not harm academic performance and may even improve concentration and problem-solving.

In conclusion, the cost of teaching minority languages is small compared with the cultural loss when they disappear, so schools should include them, provided programmes remain flexible and affordable.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource at 8: The writer's position is clear: school programmes are worthwhile if designed realistically, and the objections are acknowledged and answered in the fourth paragraph. Evidence is well chosen (Welsh becoming compulsory, local knowledge such as place names, a few hours per week with volunteers), but the claim about bilingual children is stated as research without a source.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The writer's position is clear: school programmes are worthwhile if designed realistically, and the objections are acknowledged and answered in the fourth paragraph. Evidence is well chosen (Welsh becoming compulsory, local knowledge such as place names, a few hours per week with volunteers), but the claim about bilingual children is stated as research without a source.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Paragraphs are tightly organised, and the structure presents the case for, the case against, and then a rebuttal under Even so. Cohesion is natural, with phrases such as Once a generation fails to learn it, but the point about economic return contains an illogical link.
Lexical Resource Band 8 The lexis is varied and appropriate: extinction, scarce education budgets, oral history, fluency at modest cost, problem-solving. Collocation is largely accurate.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 A wide range of structures, including participle clauses, relative clauses and a semicolon construction, is handled with very few errors. Punctuation is excellent throughout.

Marked mistakes

  1. the economic return is hard to measure because the language rarely helps in finding work
    the economic return is low because the language rarely helps in finding work (CC)
    The reason given supports a low return, not a return that is hard to measure.

What would raise the band

Name or hedge the research on bilingual children to make the claim firmer, and check each because-clause for logic. This is the step from 8 to 8.5 on TR and CC.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 essay deals with the 'waste of resources' side in a developed way, conceding what is true and then answering it with specific solutions (limited hours, online materials, research on bilingual children), while the 6.5 essay mostly lists points on each side. The 8.0 text also has more accurate and varied language ('last place where a language can be passed on', 'can maintain basic fluency at modest cost'), whereas the 6.5 text includes errors such as 'the language die' and 'a lost of time'.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people believe that minority languages should be taught in schools to keep them alive. Others think it is a waste of resources. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →