Some people prefer to live in a city centre, while others prefer to live in the suburbs. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Some people prefer to live in a city centre, while others prefer to live in the suburbs. Discuss both…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: Some people prefer to live in a city centre, while others prefer to live in the suburbs. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Where to live is an important decision for many people. Some people prefer to live in the city centre, while others prefer the suburbs. In this essay I will discuss both views and say which one I prefer.
On the one hand, living in the city centre has many advantages. Firstly, everything is near: shops, restaurants, cinemas, hospitals and the workplace. People who live in the centre do not need a car because they can walk or use public transport, so they save time and money. Moreover, the centre is usually more lively and interesting, there are always events, museums and different people. This is especially good for young people and singles who like active social life. However, the apartments in the city centre are very expensive and small, and it is often noisy and crowded.
On the other hand, the suburbs offer a quiet and peaceful life. The air is cleaner, there are more green areas and the people have more space for their house and garden. That is why many families with children prefer the suburbs, because it is safer for children to play outside and the schools are often good. Another advantage is that the houses are cheaper than in the centre, so people can buy a bigger house with the same money. The main disadvantage is the long way to work. People spend hours in the traffic every day, and they must have a car to go anywhere.
In my opinion, the choice depends on the age and the lifestyle of a person. I personally would prefer to live in the centre when I am young and single, but when I will have children I would move to the suburbs.
To conclude, both the city centre and the suburbs have positive and negative sides, and everyone should choose the place which is more suitable for his needs.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: Useful topic words appear ('lively', 'crowded', 'green areas', 'lifestyle'), but the language is plain and repeats 'people', 'advantage' and 'prefer'. Slips like 'the long way to work' and 'people spend hours in the traffic' reduce precision.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | Both views get a paragraph each and the personal answer is clear: centre when young and single, suburbs with children. The advantages and disadvantages are listed sensibly, but they are quite general and the opinion paragraph is short and offers no reason beyond lifestyle. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | Each paragraph has a clear focus and moves from advantages to disadvantages, with 'Firstly', 'Moreover', 'Another advantage' and 'That is why'. The comma splice in 'the centre is usually more lively and interesting, there are always events' and the abrupt inclusion of disadvantages at the end of paragraphs weaken flow. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | Useful topic words appear ('lively', 'crowded', 'green areas', 'lifestyle'), but the language is plain and repeats 'people', 'advantage' and 'prefer'. Slips like 'the long way to work' and 'people spend hours in the traffic' reduce precision. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | The essay uses a range of clause types, including 'so' results and 'because it is safer for children', with generally secure tenses. Notable errors include 'when I will have children' and a comma splice, and article usage is inconsistent ('in the traffic'). |
Marked mistakes
-
when I will have children
when I have children (GA)
After 'when' in a future time clause, the present simple is used. -
the centre is usually more lively and interesting, there are always events
the centre is usually more lively and interesting, as there are always events (GA)
Two independent clauses cannot be joined by a comma alone. -
People spend hours in the traffic every day
People spend hours in traffic every day (LR)
'Traffic' is uncountable and used without 'the' here.
What would raise the band
Build your opinion paragraph into a full, supported argument rather than a quick statement, and review verb forms after time conjunctions such as 'when'.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Some people prefer to live in a city centre, while others prefer to live in the suburbs. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Housing choices often reveal what people want from daily life. Some are drawn to the energy and convenience of a city centre, while others value the space and calm of the suburbs. Both have merits, but I believe the best option varies with a person's stage of life, and for most families the suburbs are the more practical choice.
City-centre living offers unmatched convenience. Work, shops, medical services and entertainment are within walking distance, and frequent public transport removes the need to own a car, saving thousands each year in fuel, insurance and parking. Dense neighbourhoods also tend to have a lively cultural scene, from theatres to street markets, which appeals to young professionals who are building networks and enjoy spontaneity. The drawbacks are equally clear, however: rent per square metre is high, flats are cramped, and noise and air pollution can make it hard to rest.
Suburban areas, by contrast, trade accessibility for quality of life. A family can afford a house with a garden for the price of a small central flat, children can play outdoors in relative safety, and local schools are often less crowded. Residents typically report lower stress and a stronger sense of community, because neighbours see each other regularly. The cost is the commute. Long journeys by car or train can consume two hours a day, and in areas poorly served by public transport, households may need two vehicles, which erodes the savings made on housing.
In my view, young singles and couples without children benefit most from central locations, where their time is more valuable than extra space. Once they start a family, the priorities shift towards room, safety and affordability, and the suburbs make more sense. Improvements in remote working may further tip the balance, since fewer commutes reduce the main disadvantage of living outside the centre.
In conclusion, neither location is superior in every circumstance. The centre rewards those who value convenience and culture, whereas the suburbs suit those who want space and tranquillity, and many people will live in both at different times.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource at 8: The thesis is clear: the best option depends on life stage, with the suburbs more practical for most families. Both areas are developed through costs, culture and commuting, and the point about remote work tipping the balance adds an original extension, although 'Residents typically report lower stress' goes unsupported.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The thesis is clear: the best option depends on life stage, with the suburbs more practical for most families. Both areas are developed through costs, culture and commuting, and the point about remote work tipping the balance adds an original extension, although 'Residents typically report lower stress' goes unsupported. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | The essay moves smoothly from centre to suburbs to the writer's view, with transitions such as 'however', 'by contrast' and 'Once they start a family'. Each paragraph opens on a strong topic sentence, and 'The cost is the commute' is a neat bridge into the drawback. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | Precise, varied vocabulary is used: 'rent per square metre', 'cramped', 'erodes the savings', 'spontaneity' and 'trade accessibility for quality of life'. A couple of phrases are slightly vague ('saving thousands each year'), but there are no real errors. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | The grammar is flexible and controlled: fronted adverbials ('Once they start a family'), conditionals, relative clauses and a colon-introduced list. Punctuation is accurate and errors are almost nonexistent. |
Marked mistakes
-
Residents typically report lower stress and a stronger sense of community
Surveys often suggest that residents report lower stress and a stronger sense of community (TR)
A generalisation about what residents report is stronger with a source or hedge. -
saving thousands each year in fuel, insurance and parking
saving a considerable sum each year in fuel, insurance and parking (LR)
'Thousands' is an unspecified figure and could be unrealistic in some cities, so a general phrase is safer.
What would raise the band
To reach the top band, support the remaining generalisations about stress and savings with a short example or a hedged phrase.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay quantifies and explains the trade-offs (car ownership costs saved in the centre versus a possible second vehicle and two-hour commutes in the suburbs) and links its opinion to life stage and the effect of remote working. The 6.5 essay covers the same stages-of-life idea but with simpler, less developed reasons and a personal 'I would move' statement. The 8.5 text also has more varied sentence structures and accurate collocations, while the 6.5 text includes slips like 'when I will have children', 'the long way to work' and 'in the traffic'.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people prefer to live in a city centre, while others prefer to live in the suburbs. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.