Eating less meat is the most effective thing an individual can do to protect the environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Eating less meat is the most effective thing an individual can do to protect the environment. To what…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Eating less meat is the most effective thing an individual can do to protect the environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Some people believe that eating less meat is the most effective way for an individual to protect the environment. I partly disagree with this statement, because there are other actions which can have a bigger effect.
It is true that meat production damages the environment. Raising cows needs a lot of land and water, and they produce methane which is a greenhouse gas. Also, many forests in South America are cut down to make farms for animals. So if people eat less meat, the demand will decrease and the environment will be less damaged. For instance, if a family have vegetarian meals two days in a week, they can reduce their carbon footprint significantly.
However, I do not think it is the most effective thing. Transport is another big source of pollution, and a person who give up his car or flies less can save more carbon than a person who stops eating meat. Using a bicycle or public transport instead of a private car is a very simple action which everybody can do. In addition, saving energy at home, for example by turning off lights and using solar panels, also help to reduce the pollution.
Furthermore, in some countries it is difficult to eat less meat because of culture and tradition. In Uzbekistan, for example, plov and shashlik are the main dishes and people will not stop eating them easily. Meat is also an important source of protein for poor people who cannot afford other food, so it is not realistic to ask everyone to reduce it.
In conclusion, eating less meat is a good way to help the environment, but I do not agree that it is the most effective one. People should do many things together, such as recycling, saving energy and using public transport, and the governments need to take bigger responsibility than individuals.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: Complex sentences are attempted (relative clauses, conditionals, 'because of'), but agreement errors occur in the body paragraphs: 'a person who give', 'also help'. These slips are frequent but do not obscure meaning.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6 | The writer takes a clear partial-disagreement position but the argument is mostly assertion. The claim that giving up a car 'can save more carbon' than eating less meat is never supported with figures, and the Uzbek plov and shashlik point is relevant but is used to explain culture rather than to compare effectiveness. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | The essay concedes the meat point first and then moves to alternatives, with clear signals such as 'However', 'In addition' and 'Furthermore'. The conclusion introduces recycling as a new idea, and its list repeats the saving-energy and public-transport points of the third paragraph. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | Vocabulary such as 'carbon footprint', 'greenhouse gas' and 'solar panels' is suitable for the topic. Range is otherwise limited, with 'big', 'simple' and 'bigger effect' recurring, and 'give up his car' is an odd choice of gender-specific phrase. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | Complex sentences are attempted (relative clauses, conditionals, 'because of'), but agreement errors occur in the body paragraphs: 'a person who give', 'also help'. These slips are frequent but do not obscure meaning. |
Marked mistakes
-
if a family have vegetarian meals two days in a week
if a family has vegetarian meals two days a week (GA)
'Two days a week' is the normal frequency phrase; 'has' is also more usual with 'a family', although British English allows 'have'. -
a person who give up his car or flies less
a person who gives up their car or flies less (GA)
The relative clause verb must agree with the singular 'person'. -
using solar panels, also help to reduce the pollution
using solar panels, also helps to reduce pollution (GA)
The subject is the gerund phrase 'saving energy', which takes a singular verb. -
they produce methane which is a greenhouse gas
they produce methane, which is a greenhouse gas (GA)
A non-defining relative clause requires a comma. -
the governments need to take bigger responsibility
governments need to take greater responsibility (LR)
'Greater responsibility' is the natural collocation, and the article is unnecessary.
What would raise the band
The central claim that transport saves 'more carbon' needs one concrete comparison, such as the emissions of a long-haul flight against a year of vegetarian meals. Then proof-read all verbs for subject agreement.
Band 8.0
Prompt: Eating less meat is the most effective thing an individual can do to protect the environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
I agree with this statement to a large extent, although it is more accurate to say that diet is one of a small number of high-impact choices than the only one.
The evidence for the environmental cost of meat, particularly beef, is hard to dismiss. Livestock farming is responsible for roughly 14 per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions, and producing a kilogram of beef generates many times more emissions than the same weight of lentils or tofu. It also requires far more land, which is the main driver of deforestation in the Amazon. An individual who replaces red meat with plant-based protein several days a week therefore makes a difference that few other everyday changes can match.
Compare this with the actions people usually associate with green living. Recycling paper and plastic, switching off lights or using a cloth shopping bag are worthwhile habits, but their combined effect is small next to the emissions embedded in food. In practice, many people feel virtuous about sorting their rubbish while continuing to eat meat at every meal.
There are, nonetheless, areas where an individual's impact may be as large or larger. Giving up a car, or avoiding a single long-haul return flight, can save over a tonne of carbon dioxide, and heating a home with renewable energy is also significant. The difference is that these choices are not available to everyone. Many people cannot live without a car because of where they work, whereas almost everyone chooses what to eat three times a day. Diet is therefore the lever most readily within reach, and one that need not cost anything, since beans and vegetables are often cheaper than meat.
In short, eating less meat may not always top the list, but for most people it is the most practical and consistently effective step, and it should be encouraged alongside changes to transport and energy use.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 7.5 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response at 7.5: The stance, agreement 'to a large extent' while treating diet as 'one of a small number of high-impact choices', is clear and well supported by the beef, land-use and deforestation evidence. The argument that diet is most 'readily within reach' is an insightful comparison with flights and cars. The 14 per cent figure and the tonne of CO2 are given without a source, which limits full development.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 7.5 | The stance, agreement 'to a large extent' while treating diet as 'one of a small number of high-impact choices', is clear and well supported by the beef, land-use and deforestation evidence. The argument that diet is most 'readily within reach' is an insightful comparison with flights and cars. The 14 per cent figure and the tonne of CO2 are given without a source, which limits full development. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | The essay moves from evidence, to contrast with recycling, to concession, to conclusion in a clearly sequenced way, with signposts like 'Compare this with', 'nonetheless' and 'In short'. The first sentence is slightly convoluted and it is only in paragraph four that the position is fully clarified. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | Wording is varied and exact: 'hard to dismiss', 'embedded in food', 'feel virtuous about sorting their rubbish' and 'the lever most readily within reach'. Collocations are natural and spelling is flawless. 'Many times more emissions' is a little imprecise. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | Contrast clauses ('whereas'), gerund subjects ('Giving up a car, or avoiding...') and 'since' clauses are used without difficulty. The only awkward sentence is the opening comparison, 'more accurate to say that diet is one of... than the only one'. |
Marked mistakes
-
it is more accurate to say that diet is one of a small number of high-impact choices than the only one
it is more accurate to describe diet as one of a small number of high-impact choices than as the only one (GA)
After 'than' the ellipsis does not parallel 'to say that...'; recasting with 'describe diet as... than as...' keeps both halves of the comparison parallel. -
generates many times more emissions than the same weight of lentils or tofu
generates around fifty times the emissions of the same weight of lentils (LR)
'Many times more' is imprecise where a figure would strengthen the claim. -
roughly 14 per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions
roughly 14 per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions, according to UN estimates (TR)
A statistic should be attributed to a source type to sound credible.
What would raise the band
State your position in the first sentence in one straightforward clause, then keep the nuance for the body. Attributing your statistics to a source type would bring Task Response to 8.5.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 answer takes a clear, qualified position and justifies it with figures (14 per cent of emissions, beef compared with lentils) and a direct comparison with recycling, while the 6.0 answer lists general points on both sides and ends with a safe "many things together". The 8.0 text also explains why diet is the most accessible lever, which engages the word "most" in the task directly. The 6.0 text has agreement and article errors ("a person who give up his car", "also help to reduce", "reduce the pollution") and a weaker, more generalised argument about culture.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Eating less meat is the most effective thing an individual can do to protect the environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.