IELTS Task 2: Independent children — Band 6 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people say that children should be taught to be independent as early as possible. Others think they should stay dependent on their parents for longer. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people say that children should be taught to be independent as early as possible. Others think they…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Some people say that children should be taught to be independent as early as possible. Others think they should stay dependent on their parents for longer. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

People have different opinions about the age when children should become independent. Some people think it must start very early, while others believe that children should depend on their parents for a longer time. I will discuss both views in this essay.

Firstly, there are several advantages if children learn independence early. When a child can dress himself, prepare simple food or do homework alone, he become more confident and responsible. Furthermore, parents today are very busy with work, so independent children are easier for them. Another point is that these children will be better prepared when they go to university or start working, because they already know how to solve their own problems. For example, in Japan small children often go to school by themselves, and this teaches them to be careful.

However, other people argue that children should stay dependent for longer. A child is not mature enough to take care about himself, and too early independence can be dangerous. If a seven-year-old stays at home alone, an accident can happen easily. In addition, children need emotional support from their parents, and if they are pushed too early, they may feel lonely and not loved. Psychologists say that a strong bond with parents in the early years make a child more stable when he grows up.

In my opinion, both approaches have good sides, but I agree more with the first one if it is done step by step. Parents should give small tasks to the children at the beginning, for instance to clean their room, and then give more responsibilities when the child is getting older. It is important that the parents still stay near and help when it is needed.

To conclude, independence is very essential for children, however it should not be forced too fast. A balance between freedom and care is the best way.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6.5 · CC 6 · LR 5.5 · GRA 5.5

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: The range is adequate for the topic (responsible, mature, emotional support), but there are word-choice and collocation problems. take care about himself, very essential and the vague easier for them show limited precision.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 Both views are discussed and the writer says they agree more with early independence if it is done step by step, which is a clear and balanced position. Ideas such as dressing himself and the example of children in Japan going to school alone are relevant, though the seven-year-old and psychologists points are generic.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6 The essay moves clearly from advantages to risks to opinion, and each paragraph begins with a signpost (Firstly, However, In my opinion). Devices such as Furthermore, Another point is and In addition are used correctly but in a rather listing way.
Lexical Resource Band 5.5 The range is adequate for the topic (responsible, mature, emotional support), but there are word-choice and collocation problems. take care about himself, very essential and the vague easier for them show limited precision.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 5.5 There is a mix of simple and complex sentences, including when- and if-clauses, but accuracy is frequently the problem. Third-person agreement fails in he become more confident and a strong bond... make a child.

Marked mistakes

  1. he become more confident and responsible
    he becomes more confident and responsible (GA)
    The subject he needs a verb with -s.
  2. take care about himself
    take care of himself (LR)
    The set expression is take care of.
  3. in the early years make a child more stable
    in the early years makes a child more stable (GA)
    The subject is bond, which is singular.
  4. independence is very essential for children
    independence is essential for children (LR)
    Essential is already absolute and cannot be modified by very.

What would raise the band

Third-person -s errors appear twice in the essay, so check every singular subject before submitting. Replace the vague easier for them with a specific benefit.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Some people say that children should be taught to be independent as early as possible. Others think they should stay dependent on their parents for longer. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Whether children should learn to look after themselves as early as possible or remain reliant on their parents for longer is a question that divides parents and educators. I believe that early independence is beneficial, provided it is introduced in small steps and under supervision.

Supporters of early independence argue that responsibility is a skill, and like any skill it improves with practice. A child who is asked to pack her own school bag at six or to manage a small weekly allowance at ten will make mistakes, such as forgetting a book or spending everything on sweets, but these mistakes are cheap and instructive. By contrast, a young adult who encounters these problems for the first time at university faces much higher stakes. There is also evidence that children given age-appropriate tasks tend to develop greater confidence in their own abilities.

On the other hand, those who prefer prolonged dependence emphasise that childhood should be protected. Children who are expected to cope alone too soon may feel anxious or neglected, and some tasks, such as travelling across a busy city or deciding how to handle conflict with peers, are simply beyond their level of maturity. Parents who stay closely involved can also detect problems like bullying or learning difficulties before they become serious.

In my view, these positions are less opposed than they seem. The real issue is not the age at which independence begins, but how it is matched to each child's development. Parents can start with low-risk responsibilities and gradually extend them, remaining available to step in when something goes wrong. This approach lets a child experience the satisfaction of achievement while knowing that support is close by.

In conclusion, children should be encouraged to become independent early, but at a pace that reflects their age and temperament, and always with a parent in the background.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 7.5 · GRA 8

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 7.5: The wording is flexible and precise (age-appropriate tasks, prolonged dependence, step in). A few expressions are plain for this level, such as goes wrong and close by.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The position that early independence is good if introduced in small steps and under supervision is clear in the introduction and developed throughout. The school bag and weekly allowance examples are specific, and the point that the real issue is how independence is matched to each child's development gives the argument depth.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 The paragraphs are logically ordered, with each topic sentence signalling its role (Supporters..., On the other hand, In my view...). Referencing is controlled, as in these positions are less opposed than they seem, and By contrast ties the six-year-old to the young adult well.
Lexical Resource Band 7.5 The wording is flexible and precise (age-appropriate tasks, prolonged dependence, step in). A few expressions are plain for this level, such as goes wrong and close by.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8 Participle phrases, relative clauses and inserted examples such as forgetting a book or spending everything on sweets show a wide range and are used accurately across nearly all sentences. Punctuation is handled well, with commas around the inserted examples.

What would raise the band

To reach 8.5 or above, tie at least one claim to named evidence such as the evidence on age-appropriate tasks. Add one more specific consequence in the second body paragraph.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 essay resolves the debate with a clear, reasoned position (independence as a skill practised in low-risk steps) and supports it with concrete, believable examples such as the school bag and the pocket money. The 6.0 essay uses general points and a single loosely related example about Japan, and its conclusion repeats earlier ideas. Vocabulary and grammar also differ: the 6.0 text contains slips such as 'become', 'take care about' and 'very essential', whereas the 8.0 text is precise and nearly error-free.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people say that children should be taught to be independent as early as possible. Others think they should stay dependent on their parents for longer. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →