IELTS Speaking Part 1: How can some people — Band 5.5 sample

IELTS Speaking Part 1 — sample answers

How can some people be so much brutal and cruel?

1 real Speaking answer to “How can some people be so much brutal and cruel?” (Band 5.5), graded on the official criteria — see what separates the bands, then get yours graded free.

Band 5.5 · real student answer

Prompt: How can some people be so much brutal and cruel?

Actually, I recently have read a book named [name] Wall's Post Infamous Murders by Russell Moore and Miguel Gandel. Actually, it's English dating killer genre, and I'm so much into this type of genres. I like in fact, I also like this type of movies and series, etcetera. And it was about murders, how the murders brutally murdered innocent people, and they are almost like psychopath, psycho killer type. And I really like these type of books. That's why as soon as I saw it at my university campus library, I just took it and decided to read it. And, yes, I would recommend it to the others, especially for, like, investigating psychopath, philodroners like me. They will get goosebumps literally. And this book is good, I think. And I I was very shocked while I was reading this book. I mean, how can some people be so much brutal and cruel? This is terrifying totally, but I would recommend it to the others.

Why Band 5.5, not 6

FC 5.5 · LR 4.5 · GRA 5 · PR 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 4.5: Vocabulary is limited and repetitive ('type', 'like', 'murders/murdered' used repeatedly). There is one clear invented/non-existent word ('philodroners') which suggests a breakdown in lexical control. Topic-specific vocabulary is attempted ('psychopath', 'goosebumps', 'brutal') but collocations are often awkward ('English dating killer genre', 'so much brutal'). Paraphrase is minimal and the range is insufficient for the topic.

How the examiner scored this answer

Fluency & Coherence Band 5.5 The candidate is willing to speak at length and maintains a general thread throughout the response, but the delivery is noticeably slow (~108 wpm) with 8 significant pauses totalling ~11 seconds. There is frequent repetition ('I really like these type of books', 'I would recommend it to the others' appears twice) and some self-correction ('psychopath, psycho killer type'). Discourse markers are limited and basic ('And', 'Actually', 'I mean'), which weakens overall coherence.
Lexical Resource Band 4.5 Vocabulary is limited and repetitive ('type', 'like', 'murders/murdered' used repeatedly). There is one clear invented/non-existent word ('philodroners') which suggests a breakdown in lexical control. Topic-specific vocabulary is attempted ('psychopath', 'goosebumps', 'brutal') but collocations are often awkward ('English dating killer genre', 'so much brutal'). Paraphrase is minimal and the range is insufficient for the topic.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 5 Basic sentence structures are used with reasonable accuracy, but complex structures are rare and often erroneous. There are tense inconsistencies ('they are almost like psychopath' instead of 'they were'), subject-verb agreement errors ('how the murders brutally murdered'), and non-standard constructions ('I recently have read', 'so much brutal'). The range of grammatical forms is narrow, anchoring the response at Band 5.
Pronunciation Band 6 Based on the acoustic pronunciation assessment provided, the candidate demonstrates good control over individual sounds. Note: the full acoustic assessment was truncated, so this band is assigned cautiously. Transcript-level signals (no unusual phonetic misspellings, generally intelligible output) are consistent with a Band 6 rating. Pronunciation was assessed primarily from the acoustic data, not the transcript alone.

Marked mistakes

  1. I recently have read a book
    I have recently read a book (GA)
    The adverb 'recently' should be placed between the auxiliary 'have' and the past participle 'read', not before the auxiliary.
  2. how the murders brutally murdered innocent people
    how the murderers brutally killed innocent people (GA)
    'Murders' refers to the acts, not the people; the correct noun is 'murderers', and repeating 'murder/murdered' is redundant — 'killed' is clearer.
  3. they are almost like psychopath, psycho killer type
    they were almost like psychopathic, serial-killer types (GA)
    Since the book describes past events, the past tense 'were' is required; 'psychopath' should be used as an adjective ('psychopathic') modifying 'killer types'.
  4. philodroners like me
    true-crime enthusiasts like me (LR)
    'Philodroners' is not a recognised English word; the intended meaning is best expressed as 'true-crime enthusiasts' or 'crime fiction fans'.
  5. English dating killer genre
    English-language crime thriller genre (LR)
    'Dating killer' is not a recognised genre label; the correct term for this type of book is 'crime thriller' or 'true crime'.

What would raise the band

Focus on building a wider, more precise vocabulary for your chosen topics — learn set phrases and collocations for the crime/thriller genre (e.g., 'true crime', 'serial killer', 'gripping narrative', 'chilling account') so you can express ideas accurately without inventing words or repeating the same terms.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →