Some people think that holidays abroad are better than holidays in one's own country. Others disagree. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that holidays abroad are better than holidays in one's own country. Others disagree.…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Some people think that holidays abroad are better than holidays in one's own country. Others disagree. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Today many people travel for holiday, and some of them choose to go abroad while others prefer to stay in their own country. In my opinion, both options are good, but holidays abroad are slightly better for most people.
There are some reasons why people think domestic holidays are better. First of all, they are usually cheaper because you don't need to buy an expensive plane ticket or a visa. Also, there is no language problem, and you know the culture and the rules, so you feel relaxed and safe. For example, a family with small children can easily go to the seaside by car, and if something happens, they can come back home quickly. Moreover, tourism inside the country helps the local economy, especially small villages.
On the other hand, a holiday abroad give people a chance to see something completely new. When you visit a different country, you try the new food, meet people with another culture and learn about their history. This experience makes a person more open-minded and it can be also useful for his education. In addition, many countries have a better weather or more beautiful nature than ours, for instance the beaches in Thailand or the mountains in Switzerland. A lot of people dream about this their whole life and it is a great memory.
Personally, I think that holidays abroad are better because they give a real change from the everyday life. Of course, they cost more money, but people can save during the year or choose cheaper countries. However, I also believe that it is a good idea to know your own country first, so the best choice is to do both.
In conclusion, domestic holidays are cheaper and more comfortable, but foreign holidays bring more new experiences. I think the second option is more interesting for the majority of travellers.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6 · CC 6 · LR 5.5 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: The vocabulary is adequate and understandable ('open-minded', 'local economy', 'everyday life') but plain and repeated, with 'good' and 'better' recurring. Some phrases are unnatural, for instance 'a better weather' and 'a real change from the everyday life'.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6 | Both views are covered and the opinion that holidays abroad are 'slightly better' is stated early and repeated in the conclusion. However, the support stays general: 'it is a great memory' and 'many countries have a better weather' are not developed, and the final paragraph's 'the best choice is to do both' blurs the stated position. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6 | The essay moves clearly from the domestic view to the foreign view and then to the writer's opinion, and 'First of all', 'Also', 'Moreover' and 'On the other hand' are all present. They are rather mechanical, and referencing relies on simple 'this' and 'it'. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5.5 | The vocabulary is adequate and understandable ('open-minded', 'local economy', 'everyday life') but plain and repeated, with 'good' and 'better' recurring. Some phrases are unnatural, for instance 'a better weather' and 'a real change from the everyday life'. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | There is a mix of simple and complex sentences, including 'if something happens, they can come back home quickly', but errors are frequent: 'a holiday abroad give people', 'it can be also useful for his education'. Meaning is rarely lost, though the errors recur in most paragraphs. |
Marked mistakes
-
a holiday abroad give people
a holiday abroad gives people (GA)
The singular subject 'a holiday abroad' needs the verb 'gives'. -
it can be also useful for his education
it can also be useful for their education (GA)
'Also' goes after the modal verb 'can', and a gender-neutral 'their' fits 'a person'. -
many countries have a better weather
many countries have better weather (LR)
'Weather' is uncountable, so it takes no article.
What would raise the band
Develop each reason with a consequence instead of stopping at a general claim, for example explain exactly why 'a real change from the everyday life' improves people's wellbeing. Then proofread for third-person -s and article errors, which appear in almost every paragraph.
Band 8.0
Prompt: Some people think that holidays abroad are better than holidays in one's own country. Others disagree. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Some people regard a holiday abroad as the ideal break, while others are just as happy to explore their own country. Both choices are defensible, but I believe the better option depends mainly on what a traveller wants to get out of the trip, and for most people a mixture works best.
Those who prefer travelling abroad generally value novelty. Unfamiliar languages, food and landscapes force visitors out of their routines, and that sense of difference is often what makes a holiday feel like a real escape. Travelling overseas can also be educational: spending a week in Istanbul or Kyoto gives a far more vivid impression of another culture than any documentary. Moreover, for people living in a small country or in a place with a cold climate, going abroad may be the only way to reach warm beaches or high mountains.
However, domestic holidays have advantages that are often underestimated. They are usually cheaper and require less planning, as there are no visas, currency exchange or long flights to worry about. This means that people can take shorter breaks more frequently, which is better for stress levels than a single annual trip. Many people also know surprisingly little about their own region, and visiting local castles, national parks or small towns can be just as rewarding as a foreign destination. In addition, domestic tourism supports local businesses and avoids the carbon emissions of air travel, which is increasingly important to younger travellers.
Taking these points together, I do not think either type of holiday is better in absolute terms. Someone who works in a stressful job and has only a few days off may benefit most from a short trip nearby, while a person who has the time and money for a longer holiday might choose to visit a country he has never seen.
In conclusion, foreign holidays offer novelty and cultural learning, whereas domestic ones are cheaper, simpler and more sustainable, so the choice should depend on personal circumstances.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 7.5 · CC 8 · LR 7.5 · GRA 8
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource at 7.5: Both views are discussed with real depth, and the position that 'the better option depends mainly on what a traveller wants' is clear from the introduction to the conclusion. The support is specific, such as Istanbul or Kyoto against 'any documentary' and the carbon emissions of air travel, though the claim about shorter breaks reducing stress is asserted rather than evidenced.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 7.5 | Both views are discussed with real depth, and the position that 'the better option depends mainly on what a traveller wants' is clear from the introduction to the conclusion. The support is specific, such as Istanbul or Kyoto against 'any documentary' and the carbon emissions of air travel, though the claim about shorter breaks reducing stress is asserted rather than evidenced. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | Each paragraph has one controlling idea, from 'novelty' to 'advantages that are often underestimated' to the personal-circumstances conclusion. Linkers such as 'Moreover', 'However' and 'Taking these points together' are varied, and 'This means that' links cause and effect smoothly. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 7.5 | The range is wide and precise: 'force visitors out of their routines', 'a real escape', 'defensible' and 'underestimated'. There are a few vague spots such as 'better for stress levels', but spelling and word forms are accurate throughout. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8 | The essay uses relative clauses, participial phrases and a conditional-style construction ('Someone who works in a stressful job... may benefit most'), and nearly every sentence is error-free. Only small lapses such as 'a country he has never seen' reduce the accuracy slightly. |
Marked mistakes
-
a country he has never seen
a country they have never seen (LR)
'He' excludes female travellers, so a plural or neutral pronoun is more natural.
What would raise the band
To reach the top bands, back one of your key claims with evidence, for example a statistic or study showing that frequent short breaks reduce stress. Also choose neutral pronouns instead of 'he'.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 essay refuses a simple winner and explains how the choice depends on circumstances, supporting each side with concrete points (shorter and more frequent breaks, carbon emissions, people knowing little about their own region). The 6.0 essay does state a position but leans on general claims and a stereotype-type example (Thailand and Switzerland). The 6.0 text has errors such as 'a holiday abroad give' and 'a better weather', while the 8.0 text is accurate and more varied.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people think that holidays abroad are better than holidays in one's own country. Others disagree. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.