Some people think that museums should focus on a country's own history and culture. Others believe they should include objects from around the world. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that museums should focus on a country's own history and culture. Others believe they…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Some people think that museums should focus on a country's own history and culture. Others believe they should include objects from around the world. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Museums are important places where people can learn about the past. Some people think that museums should show only the history and culture of their own country, but others believe they should also have objects from other parts of the world. I will discuss both sides in this essay.
On the one hand, there are good reasons to focus on national culture. Firstly, museums help people to understand where they come from and this make them proud of their identity. For example, a child who visit a national museum can see traditional clothes and tools from his ancestors, and it is more interesting for him than reading in a book. Moreover, a country has a big amount of historical objects and a small museum cannot show everything. If it includes foreign objects, there is less space for local heritage, and this heritage may be forgotten.
On the other hand, I think international collections have a lot of benefits too. People who cannot travel abroad can learn about other civilisations without leaving their city. For instance, the British Museum in London has Egyptian mummies and Chinese vases, so the visitors can see the whole world in one place. Also, this helps to build tolerance, because when people see how other nations lived, they respect them more. In addition, foreign exhibits attract many tourists and bring money to the museum.
In my opinion, the best museums are those that mix both. The main part should be about the own country, because it is the most important for the local people, but there should be also some sections about other cultures. Museums can also organise temporary exhibitions from other countries, so they don't need to spend a lot of space.
To sum up, I believe museums should not be limited to local history. A balance between national and international objects makes museums more interesting and educational for everybody.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: Conditionals (If it includes foreign objects, there is less space...) and relative clauses show some range, but agreement errors recur: this make them proud and a child who visit. Word-order slips like there should be also also remain.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6 | Both views are covered and the writer says museums should mix both, with a main national part. The argument is relevant, but some points are thin, such as the claim that the heritage may be forgotten and the bringing money to the museum point, and the national-focus side relies on a generic child example. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | The structure is orderly with clear paragraphs (On the one hand, On the other hand, In my opinion, To sum up) and devices like Firstly, Moreover and Also are used appropriately. The progression within paragraphs is sometimes a list, and the tourist-income point at the end of the third paragraph is simply added with In addition rather than developed. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The vocabulary suits the topic (heritage, civilisations, tolerance, temporary exhibitions), but there are some unnatural collocations. a big amount of historical objects and bring money to the museum show limited precision. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | Conditionals (If it includes foreign objects, there is less space...) and relative clauses show some range, but agreement errors recur: this make them proud and a child who visit. Word-order slips like there should be also also remain. |
Marked mistakes
-
this make them proud of their identity
this makes them proud of their identity (GA)
This is singular, so the verb needs -s. -
a child who visit a national museum
a child who visits a national museum (GA)
Child is singular, so the relative clause verb takes -s. -
a big amount of historical objects
a large number of historical objects (LR)
Objects are countable, so number is used rather than amount. -
about the own country
about their own country (GA)
Own must follow a possessive determiner, not the. -
there should be also some sections
there should also be some sections (GA)
Also normally comes before the main verb.
What would raise the band
Check every singular subject for -s on the verb and replace general phrases with exact quantifiers to lift GA and LR. Develop the tolerance point with one more sentence on how seeing other cultures changes attitudes.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Some people think that museums should focus on a country's own history and culture. Others believe they should include objects from around the world. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Museums can be organised around a nation's own heritage or around the achievements of cultures everywhere. While both approaches have merit, I believe the strongest museums anchor their collections in local history and use selected international material to give it context.
Those who favour a national focus see museums as guardians of collective memory. A museum that explains how a country's cities, industries and traditions developed helps citizens understand how they arrived at the present, and it gives visitors from elsewhere an authentic introduction to the place they are in. There is also a practical argument: most museums have limited space and funding, and a small regional museum that tries to cover world history is likely to do so superficially while neglecting the local stories that nobody else will preserve.
However, an exclusively national outlook can become inward-looking. Objects from other cultures allow visitors to see their own history in comparison with others, which often makes it more meaningful. A display showing how different civilisations developed writing or metalworking, for example, reveals both what is shared and what is distinctive. For people who cannot afford to travel, a large museum may also be the only chance they ever have to see an Egyptian burial mask or a Japanese woodblock print at first hand. Such encounters can encourage curiosity and reduce prejudice.
Balancing these considerations, I think that the permanent core of a museum should be local, with outside material introduced through loans and temporary exhibitions. This allows institutions to keep their identity while still offering variety, and it avoids the difficult questions that arise when large permanent collections have been removed from their countries of origin, an issue that many European museums now face.
In conclusion, national museums should put their own heritage first, but connecting it with the wider world makes that heritage easier to understand and appreciate.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion at 8: The thesis that museums should anchor collections in local history and use selected international material is clear and consistent. Reasons are well developed (limited space and funding, superficial coverage, comparison giving meaning, access for those who cannot travel), but the closing reference to European museums raises a restitution issue that is not explored.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The thesis that museums should anchor collections in local history and use selected international material is clear and consistent. Reasons are well developed (limited space and funding, superficial coverage, comparison giving meaning, access for those who cannot travel), but the closing reference to European museums raises a restitution issue that is not explored. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | The essay is logically ordered, with a fair presentation of the national view, a However turn to the international view, and a balancing paragraph. Linking phrases such as Balancing these considerations and There is also a practical argument are used naturally and not mechanically. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8.5 | The lexis is sophisticated and accurate: guardians of collective memory, inward-looking, metalworking, loans and temporary exhibitions. Collocations are strong, and any imprecision is slight. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | A wide range of structures (relative clauses, participle phrases, gerunds) is used almost without error, and punctuation, including the colon in a practical argument, is accurate. Errors are very rare. |
What would raise the band
Either develop the repatriation point with a short example or drop it, because it enters at the end without support.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay gives a reasoned answer that museums should keep a local core and borrow international material, and it supports this with specific details (limited space, comparative displays on writing, loans and the origin-of-objects issue). The 6.0 essay reaches a similar balance but with mostly general statements and a very common example, and its grammar slips ('this make them proud', 'a child who visit', 'the own country') show weaker control. The 8.5 essay also uses more precise vocabulary and more flexible linking.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people think that museums should focus on a country's own history and culture. Others believe they should include objects from around the world. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.