IELTS Task 2: The death penalty — Band 6.5 vs 8.5 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

The death penalty should be abolished in all countries. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “The death penalty should be abolished in all countries. To what extent do you agree or disagree?” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: The death penalty should be abolished in all countries. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

The death penalty is a very serious issue and people have different opinions about it. I agree that it should be abolished in all countries, for several reasons.

The first reason is that mistakes can happen in the courts. Judges, police and witnesses are human and they can make errors, so sometimes innocent people are sentenced to death. If the person is executed, it is impossible to correct the mistake later. There were many cases in the United States when prisoners waited many years on death row and then new evidence, such as DNA tests, proved that they didn't commit the crime. It is better to keep a guilty person in prison than to kill one innocent.

The second reason is that the death penalty does not really reduce crime. Some people say that it frightens criminals, but many murders are committed in anger or in a moment, and the criminals do not think about the punishment. For example, the countries which have abolished the death penalty, like Canada, did not have a rise in the murders. So there is no clear proof that it works.

Moreover, taking a life is morally wrong, even if the state do it. Every person has a right to live, and the government should not behave like a murderer.

However, I understand why some people want this punishment. The families of victims often want revenge, and they feel that life in prison is too easy for terrible criminals like terrorists. Also, keeping prisoners for life costs a lot of money.

Despite this, I believe that the arguments against the death penalty are stronger, and all countries should abolish it.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: Suitable vocabulary appears ('death row', 'abolished', 'sentenced to death', 'innocent'), but the range is narrow and repeats 'death penalty' and 'crime'. 'Kill one innocent' and 'a rise in the murders' show imprecision in word form and collocation.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The position 'I agree that it should be abolished in all countries' is clear and the three reasons (irreversible mistakes, weak deterrence, moral objection) are relevant. The DNA and Canada examples help, but 'Moreover, taking a life is morally wrong' is only a single assertion, and the paragraph on opponents is not answered.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 Reasons are signposted with 'The first reason' and 'The second reason', and the conclusion with 'Despite this' links back to the opposing view. Some paragraphs are very short ('Moreover...' has only two sentences), and linkers like 'So' and 'Also' are basic.
Lexical Resource Band 6 Suitable vocabulary appears ('death row', 'abolished', 'sentenced to death', 'innocent'), but the range is narrow and repeats 'death penalty' and 'crime'. 'Kill one innocent' and 'a rise in the murders' show imprecision in word form and collocation.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 The writer uses relative clauses, conditionals and passives, such as 'are sentenced to death', with some accuracy. There are errors, for instance 'even if the state do it', plus a contraction ('didn't') in formal writing.

Marked mistakes

  1. than to kill one innocent
    than to execute an innocent person (LR)
    'Innocent' needs a noun such as 'person', and 'execute' is the precise verb for the death penalty.
  2. even if the state do it
    even if the state does it (GA)
    'The state' is singular, so the verb takes -s.
  3. that they didn't commit the crime
    that they had not committed the crime (LR)
    Formal essays avoid contractions, and the past perfect shows the earlier time.
  4. did not have a rise in the murders
    did not see a rise in murders (LR)
    'See a rise in' is the natural collocation, and 'murders' is used without an article in general statements.
  5. in a moment
    on the spur of the moment (LR)
    'In a moment' means 'very soon'; the intended idea is an impulsive act.

What would raise the band

Develop the moral argument and respond directly to the revenge point, and re-read for agreement errors such as 'the state do it'.

Band 8.5

Prompt: The death penalty should be abolished in all countries. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

I agree that capital punishment should be abolished everywhere, mainly because it is irreversible, it has not been shown to deter crime and it is applied unevenly.

Irreversibility is the most serious objection. No legal system is free of error, and in the United States alone, well over a hundred people sentenced to death have been exonerated after new evidence emerged, in some cases decades later. Had they been executed, the state would have taken innocent lives with no possibility of apology or compensation. A prison sentence, however unjust, can at least be ended and its harm partly repaired.

Supporters often claim that the threat of execution deters would-be killers, but the evidence is unconvincing. Crimes of this kind are frequently committed in anger or under the influence of drugs, when offenders are not calculating the penalty, and those who plan them usually assume they will not be caught. A review by the US National Research Council concluded that existing studies provided no reliable basis for judging whether capital punishment affects homicide rates. Regions that have abolished it, including most of Western Europe, have not seen a rise in murders.

Furthermore, the penalty is not applied evenly. Whether a defendant is sentenced to death often depends on the quality of their lawyer, the area in which the trial takes place and their ethnicity, which undermines the principle that justice should treat like cases alike.

The strongest argument on the other side is that some crimes, such as terrorist massacres or the murder of children, deserve the ultimate punishment, and that victims' families are entitled to a sense of justice. I sympathise with this view, but a life sentence without parole removes the offender from society permanently while leaving open the possibility of correcting a mistake.

For these reasons, I believe all countries should abolish the death penalty.

Why Band 8.5, not 9

TR 8.5 · CC 8.5 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8.5: The opening sentence announces three clear grounds (irreversibility, deterrence, uneven application) and each receives its own developed paragraph. Evidence about exonerations in the United States and the National Research Council review is convincing, and the counter-argument on terrorist massacres is considered, although the rebuttal does not answer the retributive point fully.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8.5 The opening sentence announces three clear grounds (irreversibility, deterrence, uneven application) and each receives its own developed paragraph. Evidence about exonerations in the United States and the National Research Council review is convincing, and the counter-argument on terrorist massacres is considered, although the rebuttal does not answer the retributive point fully.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8.5 The sequencing mirrors the thesis sentence, so the reader always knows where the argument is, and 'Furthermore' and 'The strongest argument on the other side' mark each shift neatly. Reference words ('Had they been executed', 'this view') are precise and the paragraphing is skilful.
Lexical Resource Band 8.5 Wide, accurate vocabulary: 'irreversible', 'exonerated', 'would-be killers', 'calculating the penalty', 'undermines the principle'. Collocations are natural throughout.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 There is a full range of structures, including inversion in 'Had they been executed', reduced relative clauses and nominal 'that' clauses, and almost all sentences are accurate. Punctuation supports the long sentences, which occasionally stack several subordinate clauses.

Marked mistakes

  1. I sympathise with this view, but a life sentence without parole removes the offender from society permanently
    I sympathise with this view, but justice for victims can be served by a life sentence without parole, which removes the offender from society permanently (TR)
    The concession needs to answer the retributive argument directly, not only the safety point.

What would raise the band

To reach the top band, expand the rebuttal of the retributive argument.

What separates the higher band

The 8.5 answer states three clear grounds in its introduction (irreversibility, deterrence, unequal application) and develops each in its own paragraph with specific support, including the National Research Council review. The 6.5 answer covers two similar points, adds a general moral claim ("taking a life is morally wrong") and ends with a minor concession that is not answered. The 6.5 text also has errors such as "the state do it", "in the murders" and "kill one innocent".

Check your essay on this task

Task: The death penalty should be abolished in all countries. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →