IELTS Task 2: Celebrity pay — Band 6 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Celebrities and sports stars are paid too much compared with people in jobs that are more useful to society. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Celebrities and sports stars are paid too much compared with people in jobs that are more useful to…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Celebrities and sports stars are paid too much compared with people in jobs that are more useful to society. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

In many countries, football players, actors and singers earn millions of dollars while nurses, teachers and firefighters receive a small salary. I agree that celebrities are paid too much compared with the people whose jobs are more useful for the society.

Firstly, jobs like doctors, teachers and policemen are very important for everyone. Doctors save people's lives, and teachers educate the next generation. Without them, the society can not function normally. However, their salary is often not enough to live comfortable, and many of them have to work extra hours. On the other hand, a footballer can earn more in one week than a nurse earns in ten years, only for playing a game. This is not fair because the footballer does not give so much benefit to the community.

Secondly, the high salaries of celebrities make a bad influence on young people. Many teenagers dream to become famous and rich, so they do not want to study hard or choose useful professions. As a result, there may be a lack of qualified specialists, such as engineers or scientists, in future.

However, there are some arguments on the other side. Celebrities bring entertainment to millions of people and their salary comes from the tickets, advertising and sponsors, not from the government. Also, a sports career is short and only a few people become really successful, so it is understandable that they get a lot of money at that time.

Despite this, I think the salary of celebrities is still too high. The government can introduce higher taxes for very rich people and use this money to raise the pay for teachers, nurses and other public workers.

To sum up, I agree with the statement, because the difference in pay is too big and not fair for the people with important jobs.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The position 'I agree' is clear from the start and the contrast between a footballer's weekly earnings and a nurse's ten years is vivid. However, the argument that high celebrity pay discourages teenagers from studying is assumed rather than shown, and the counter-argument about sponsors and short careers is acknowledged but dismissed with a single 'Despite this'.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6 The position 'I agree' is clear from the start and the contrast between a footballer's weekly earnings and a nurse's ten years is vivid. However, the argument that high celebrity pay discourages teenagers from studying is assumed rather than shown, and the counter-argument about sponsors and short careers is acknowledged but dismissed with a single 'Despite this'.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The structure is clear: reasons with 'Firstly' and 'Secondly', a counter-argument paragraph beginning 'However', then a solution with higher taxes. Linking is functional but formulaic, and the transition from the opposing arguments back to the writer's view ('Despite this') is abrupt.
Lexical Resource Band 6 Reasonable range is shown in 'qualified specialists', 'sponsors' and 'higher taxes for very rich people', but there are errors in word form and collocation: 'live comfortable', 'make a bad influence', 'dream to become famous'. These do not impede understanding but show limited control of less common items.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 The essay mixes simple sentences with relative clauses ('whose jobs are more useful') and an 'As a result' construction. Article errors ('the society', 'in future') and the adverb/adjective error 'to live comfortable' recur, but most sentences are understandable and many are accurate.

Marked mistakes

  1. their salary is often not enough to live comfortable
    their salary is often not enough to live comfortably (LR)
    An adverb is needed to modify the verb 'live'.
  2. whose jobs are more useful for the society
    whose jobs are more useful to society (GA)
    'Society' used in a general sense takes no article, and 'useful to' is the usual collocation.
  3. make a bad influence on young people
    have a bad influence on young people (LR)
    The fixed collocation is 'have an influence on'.
  4. Many teenagers dream to become famous and rich
    Many teenagers dream of becoming famous and rich (GA)
    'Dream' is followed by 'of' plus a gerund, not by an infinitive.
  5. the society can not function normally
    society cannot function normally (GA)
    'Cannot' is written as one word, and 'society' needs no article here.

What would raise the band

Replace the generalisation about teenagers with one explained example or consequence, and spend a few lines rebutting the sponsors argument properly rather than moving on with 'Despite this'.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Celebrities and sports stars are paid too much compared with people in jobs that are more useful to society. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

I agree only in part. The pay of top entertainers can be explained by the way markets work, but the low rewards of socially vital jobs are a genuine problem, and the contrast between the two is hard to defend.

Celebrity earnings are high because of scale. A footballer or singer can be watched by hundreds of millions of people at once, so even a small payment per viewer produces enormous revenue, and clubs and studios compete to secure the few individuals who attract such audiences. In that sense the stars are paid not by society as a whole but by consumers who choose to spend money on tickets, subscriptions and merchandise, and the salary reflects what they bring in rather than a judgement of their worth. A teacher cannot teach a million pupils simultaneously, so the same logic does not apply.

The difficulty arises when we ask whether the market's valuation matches real contribution. A nurse who looks after patients on a night shift, or a teacher who inspires children to study, contributes more to the stability of society than most people would argue a pop singer does, yet the former may struggle to afford housing near their workplace. Such pay gaps encourage young people to chase fame rather than careers in education or healthcare, where many countries already face shortages.

For this reason, I would not favour reducing celebrity pay directly, because it would be hard to enforce and unfair to people whose income is generated by their own audience. The better remedy is to raise the pay of essential public sector roles, funded in part by progressive taxation on very high incomes. Such measures would address the imbalance from both directions.

In summary, celebrities are not so much overpaid as essential workers are underpaid, and governments should focus on correcting the latter.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 7.5 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8

The weakest criterion is Task Response at 7.5: The opening 'I agree only in part' sets a nuanced position that is explained rather than hedged: celebrities are 'not so much overpaid as essential workers are underpaid'. The scale-of-audience argument is well developed, but the paragraph on social contribution relies on the unsupported assertion about 'shortages' in education and healthcare.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 7.5 The opening 'I agree only in part' sets a nuanced position that is explained rather than hedged: celebrities are 'not so much overpaid as essential workers are underpaid'. The scale-of-audience argument is well developed, but the paragraph on social contribution relies on the unsupported assertion about 'shortages' in education and healthcare.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 The essay moves logically from why stars earn so much, to whether that matches real contribution, to a recommended remedy. Signposts such as 'In that sense' and 'The difficulty arises when...' guide the reader smoothly. A reference problem appears where 'the former' is separated from its noun by a long relative clause.
Lexical Resource Band 8 The lexis is flexible and precise: 'scale', 'merchandise', 'socially vital', 'progressive taxation', 'chase fame'. Word choice is accurate throughout; a few phrases such as 'contributes more... than most people would argue a pop singer does' are slightly awkward but the meaning is clear.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8 A wide range of structures is used with control, including long relative clauses ('A nurse who looks after patients on a night shift'), the 'not so much... as' comparison, and a reduced passive participle phrase ('funded in part by'). Errors are very rare, though the comparison in the third paragraph is grammatically heavy.

Marked mistakes

  1. contributes more to the stability of society than most people would argue a pop singer does
    arguably contributes more to the stability of society than a pop singer does (LR)
    The embedded 'most people would argue' is clumsy and weakens the comparison.
  2. yet the former may struggle to afford housing near their workplace
    yet the nurse or teacher may struggle to afford housing near their workplace (CC)
    After such a long sentence, 'the former' is hard to trace back to 'A nurse ... or a teacher', so naming the referent is clearer.

What would raise the band

Back up the claim about shortages in education and healthcare with a concrete example, and check long sentences for unclear reference words such as 'the former'.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 answer explains why celebrities earn so much (a huge audience, revenue per viewer) before judging whether that is fair, and then reframes the problem as underpayment of essential workers, which leads to a more precise remedy. The 6.0 answer simply agrees, using general contrasts such as a footballer versus a nurse, and covers the counter-argument briefly before reasserting its view. The 6.0 text has errors such as "live comfortable", "make a bad influence", "dream to become" and "in future".

Check your essay on this task

Task: Celebrities and sports stars are paid too much compared with people in jobs that are more useful to society. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →