Some people think that parents should teach children how to be good members of society. Others believe that school is the place to learn this. Discuss both views and give your opinion.
Band 5.5
A real IELTS practice essay scored Band 5.5 by AI on the topic: Some people think that parents should teach children how to be good members of society. Others believe that sc. Read it, then get your own essay graded.
Band 5.5
Prompt: Some people think that parents should teach children how to be good members of society. Others believe that school is the place to learn this. Discuss both views and give your opinion.
Good morals is one vital aspect of the life of the child. In our indigenous societies, people believe it is the duty of parents to instill these morals in their children. On the other hand, others also believe, it is the responsibility of the schools the children find themselves in to teach these good morals. Both beliefs or assertions may have their own reasons. I will tackle both and decide my stance.
To begin with, people believe it is the duty of parents to teach children how to be good members of the society because they were brought into that society by them. It is parents who brought forth their own children and as a matter of fact, it’s important they teach them these good morals. This will mean that they’re taking responsibility for their own actions. Also, people believe parents should take it upon themselves to teach their own children good morals because they’re the first people the children come into contact with, and due to that they have the immediate advantage of instilling in them what is right.
On the contrary, some people also believe that it is the responsibility of the schools the children are placed in to instill good moral living in them because that is primarily the duty of the school. It is believed to be a place of knowledge acquision and transition. In this regard, it is believed by some people in the society that they’re responsible for teaching children how to live right morally and ethically. People also believe that it’s the responsibility of schools because of the huge sums of fees and other financial commitments paid by parents. They believe parents must not pay all those amounts of monies just for nothing, and that the evidence of it must be seen in the way the children are taught. Both sides may be valid due to one reason or the other. However, in my personal opinion, I believe since parents make the own choices and decisions to bring forth children into our societies, then they must be responsible for their standards of living. Therefore, I agree that it is the duty of parents to teach children how to be good members of the society.
Why Band 5.5, not 6
TR 6 · CC 5 · LR 5 · GRA 5
The weakest criterion is Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5: There is a basic organisational structure with an introduction, two body paragraphs, and a conclusion embedded in the second body paragraph. However, there is no clear progression of ideas — the essay circles back on itself repeatedly. Cohesive devices are overused and mechanical ('Also', 'On the contrary', 'In this regard', 'However'). The opinion is awkwardly inserted at the end of the second body paragraph rather than in a separate concluding paragraph, which disrupts the overall structure. Paragraphing is present but unbalanced.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6 | The essay addresses both views and provides a personal opinion, which meets the basic requirements of a 'discuss both views and give your opinion' task. However, the development of ideas is weak and repetitive. The argument for parents is essentially restated twice (they brought children into the world; they are the first contact), and the argument for schools is poorly developed — the point about school fees is irrelevant and unconvincing. The opinion is stated but not well supported. The position is present but conclusions are not clearly reasoned. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 5 | There is a basic organisational structure with an introduction, two body paragraphs, and a conclusion embedded in the second body paragraph. However, there is no clear progression of ideas — the essay circles back on itself repeatedly. Cohesive devices are overused and mechanical ('Also', 'On the contrary', 'In this regard', 'However'). The opinion is awkwardly inserted at the end of the second body paragraph rather than in a separate concluding paragraph, which disrupts the overall structure. Paragraphing is present but unbalanced. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5 | The vocabulary range is limited and repetitive. Key phrases such as 'good morals', 'instill', 'responsibility', and 'believe' are repeated excessively throughout the essay. There are attempts at less common vocabulary ('indigenous societies', 'acquision', 'assertions') but these are either used imprecisely or misspelled. The phrase 'amounts of monies' is an incorrect word form. Collocations are often awkward ('moral living', 'standards of living' used in the wrong context). |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5 | The essay uses a limited range of grammatical structures, relying heavily on simple and compound sentences. There are frequent errors in subject-verb agreement ('Good morals is'), incorrect use of articles ('members of the society'), and awkward constructions ('the schools the children find themselves in', 'the schools the children are placed in'). Complex structures are attempted but are often clumsy or inaccurate. Errors are frequent enough to cause some difficulty for the reader. |
Marked mistakes
-
Good morals is one vital aspect of the life of the child.
Good morals are one vital aspect of a child's life. (GA)
'Morals' is a plural noun and requires the plural verb 'are', not 'is'. Also, 'the life of the child' is overly wordy and unnatural. -
People also believe that it's the responsibility of schools because of the huge sums of fees and other financial commitments paid by parents.
Furthermore, schools employ trained educators who are equipped with the pedagogical skills to teach social values systematically. (TR)
The school fees argument is irrelevant to the question of who is best placed to teach good values, and it weakens the essay's credibility. A relevant argument about trained teachers or structured curricula would be far more effective. -
It is believed to be a place of knowledge acquision and transition.
It is believed to be a place of knowledge acquisition and transition. (LR)
'Acquision' is a misspelling of 'acquisition'. Additionally, 'transition' is vague here — a more precise word like 'moral development' or 'character formation' would be more appropriate. -
they must not pay all those amounts of monies just for nothing
they should not pay such large sums of money for nothing (LR)
'Monies' is a very formal legal term and is used incorrectly here; the natural word is 'money' (uncountable). 'Amounts of monies' is grammatically and lexically incorrect. -
good members of the society
good members of society (GA)
The word 'society' in this general, abstract sense does not take the definite article 'the'. This error is repeated multiple times throughout the essay.
What would raise the band
Focus on developing each argument with a specific, relevant example or explanation — for instance, instead of repeating that 'parents brought children into the world', explain HOW parents can teach values (e.g., through daily routines, modelling behaviour) and WHY this is effective. One well-developed idea is worth far more than two vague, repetitive ones.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people think that parents should teach children how to be good members of society. Others believe that school is the place to learn this. Discuss both views and give your opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.