IELTS Task 2: Taxing air travel — Band 6 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Flying should be heavily taxed in order to reduce damage to the environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Flying should be heavily taxed in order to reduce damage to the environment. To what extent do you agree…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Flying should be heavily taxed in order to reduce damage to the environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Nowadays, air travel is very popular and many people think that governments should put heavy taxes on flights to protect the environment. I partly agree with this opinion, but I think tax alone is not enough.

Firstly, planes produce a large amount of carbon dioxide, which is one of the main reasons of global warming. If the price of tickets become higher, people will fly less often and the pollution will decrease. For example, many Europeans take short flights for holiday several times a year, because the tickets are cheaper than the train. A heavy tax would make them to think again and choose other transport.

Moreover, the money from the tax can be used by government to invest in green energy and research for cleaner fuel. In this way the tax have a double benefit, it reduces the flights and it also gives money for solving the problem.

However, there are some problems with this idea. Firstly, a heavy tax will be unfair for poor people. Rich people can still afford to fly, but ordinary families will not be able to visit their relatives abroad. Also, tourism is very essential for many countries, and if tourists number fall, thousands of people will lose their job in hotels and restaurants. So the government must be careful.

In my opinion, the better solution is a moderate tax together with improving alternative transport, such as fast trains. Then people will have a real choice.

In conclusion, I agree that flying should be taxed more to reduce damage to the environment, but not too heavily, and the governments should also make other kinds of transport cheaper and better.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5

The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: There is a good mix of conditionals, relative clauses and 'because' clauses, but accuracy lets it down. Repeated subject-verb agreement errors ('the tax have', 'the price of tickets become') and the pattern 'make them to think' appear in many of the complex sentences, though meaning stays clear.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The essay states a clear partial-agreement position ('tax alone is not enough') and keeps it through to the moderate-tax conclusion. Ideas such as short holiday flights being cheaper than trains and tourism jobs being lost are relevant, but they stay at a general level without data or a worked-out consequence.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 Progression from benefits to problems to a compromise is easy to follow, and 'Moreover', 'However' and 'Also' are used appropriately. 'Firstly' is repeated in the fourth paragraph after already opening the second, and the one-sentence paragraph beginning 'In my opinion' feels detached.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The vocabulary is adequate and clear, with phrases such as 'carbon dioxide', 'green energy' and 'alternative transport'. It is repetitive ('tax', 'people', 'problem') and there are word-choice slips like 'very essential' and 'one of the main reasons of global warming'.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 5.5 There is a good mix of conditionals, relative clauses and 'because' clauses, but accuracy lets it down. Repeated subject-verb agreement errors ('the tax have', 'the price of tickets become') and the pattern 'make them to think' appear in many of the complex sentences, though meaning stays clear.

Marked mistakes

  1. If the price of tickets become higher
    If the price of tickets becomes higher (GA)
    The subject is 'price', which is singular, so the verb needs -s.
  2. A heavy tax would make them to think again
    A heavy tax would make them think again (GA)
    'Make' is followed by the bare infinitive without 'to'.
  3. the tax have a double benefit, it reduces the flights
    the tax has a double benefit: it reduces the number of flights (GA)
    'Tax' is singular, and the comma splice should be a colon or full stop.
  4. one of the main reasons of global warming
    one of the main causes of global warming (LR)
    The usual collocation is 'reasons for' or, better, 'causes of'.
  5. if tourists number fall
    if the number of tourists falls (GA)
    The noun phrase and the verb agreement are both wrong in the original.

What would raise the band

Check every verb against its subject before finishing, since agreement slips ('tax have', 'price of tickets become') are what hold the grammar at Band 5.5. Then add one figure or named policy to the tourism point to push the argument beyond general statements.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Flying should be heavily taxed in order to reduce damage to the environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Aviation is one of the few sectors where polluting is effectively subsidised: kerosene is exempt from fuel duty in most countries, while drivers and rail passengers pay tax on their energy. I largely agree that flying should be taxed more heavily, provided the tax is designed with care.

The strongest argument is that price is the most direct way to change behaviour. Cheap flights have encouraged trips that would never otherwise have been made, such as a weekend abroad that costs less than a train ticket across the same country. When a short-haul return flight is cheaper than a taxi ride across the city, the climate cost is simply not reflected in the fare. A substantial tax would correct this, and the revenue could fund high-speed rail and research into sustainable aviation fuel, which is currently several times more expensive than conventional kerosene.

Critics argue that such a tax would be unfair, since it would hit lower-income families hardest while wealthy travellers carry on as before. This is a legitimate concern, but it is a matter of design rather than a reason to reject the principle. A levy that rises with each additional flight a person takes in a year would leave the occasional family holiday or visit to relatives largely untouched, while targeting frequent flyers and private-jet passengers, who account for a disproportionate share of emissions.

Another objection is that tourism-dependent economies, such as small island states, would suffer. Here, targeted exemptions or support would be more appropriate than abandoning the policy, as these countries are also the most exposed to rising sea levels.

Taxation alone will not solve the problem, because passengers need credible alternatives. Nevertheless, a well-designed and heavy tax is a necessary part of any serious attempt to reduce aviation emissions, and the revenue it raises can help to make those alternatives available.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource at 8: The position is clear and nuanced: 'largely agree... provided the tax is designed with care'. Both objections (fairness and tourism-dependent economies) are addressed with workable answers such as a levy that rises with each flight. A couple of claims, for instance kerosene being exempt 'in most countries', are asserted without support.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The position is clear and nuanced: 'largely agree... provided the tax is designed with care'. Both objections (fairness and tourism-dependent economies) are addressed with workable answers such as a levy that rises with each flight. A couple of claims, for instance kerosene being exempt 'in most countries', are asserted without support.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 The structure runs cleanly from the main argument, through two objections, to the conclusion, and each paragraph has a clear controlling idea. Referencing is precise ('This is a legitimate concern', 'Here'). The penultimate paragraph is brief and the final paragraph's opening, 'Taxation alone will not solve the problem', arrives slightly abruptly.
Lexical Resource Band 8 Precise topic vocabulary is used naturally, including 'effectively subsidised', 'short-haul', 'sustainable aviation fuel' and 'a disproportionate share of emissions'. Collocations are accurate and there are no spelling errors. One or two phrasings are slightly loose, such as 'the climate cost is simply not reflected in the fare'.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 A wide range of structures appears, including concessive 'while', 'provided' clauses, relative clauses and a well-controlled 'would leave... largely untouched, while targeting...'. Nearly every sentence is error-free and punctuation is exact.

Marked mistakes

  1. kerosene is exempt from fuel duty in most countries
    kerosene used on international flights is exempt from fuel duty in most countries (TR)
    The claim is accurate only for international flights, so qualifying it would make the opening premise stronger.
  2. When a short-haul return flight is cheaper than a taxi ride across the city
    When a short-haul return flight can cost less than a taxi ride across the city (TR)
    The comparison is rhetorical and should be hedged to stay credible.
  3. Taxation alone will not solve the problem, because passengers need credible alternatives.
    Taxation alone will not solve the problem, because passengers need credible alternatives such as night trains on major routes. (CC)
    The idea is important but it is stated in one line without an example.

What would raise the band

Support one or two factual claims, such as the kerosene exemption, with a qualifier or a named example. Develop the last-paragraph point about alternatives into a sentence of its own to reach Band 8.5 or above on Task Response.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 answer names a concrete mechanism (untaxed kerosene) and answers the fairness objection with a specific design, a levy that rises with each extra flight, whereas the 6.0 answer only says that poor people would suffer and then retreats to a vague "moderate tax". The 8.0 essay also adds a separate point on island economies and links the revenue to rail and sustainable fuel. The 6.0 text relies on formulaic linkers, using "Firstly" twice, and contains slips such as "reasons of global warming", "make them to think" and "tourists number fall".

Check your essay on this task

Task: Flying should be heavily taxed in order to reduce damage to the environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →