People rely too much on technology to remember information, and this is making them less intelligent. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “People rely too much on technology to remember information, and this is making them less intelligent. To…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: People rely too much on technology to remember information, and this is making them less intelligent. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Technology has changed the way we store and use information. Some people claim that we depend on devices too much to remember things, and that this makes us less intelligent. I partly agree with this statement, because technology can weaken some skills, but I do not think it makes people less intelligent in general.
It is true that many people rely on their phones and computers for memory. For example, few people nowadays remember the phone numbers of their friends, because they are saved in the contacts. Also, instead of remembering the way, drivers use GPS, and students use calculators or search engines for every small question. As a result, our memory and ability to find directions may become weaker, as we do not practise it. Some research even showed that people who use GPS all the time have a worse sense of direction. Another problem is that people read only short pieces of text and they can not concentrate on a long book or a difficult problem.
However, I do not agree that this means people are less intelligent. Intelligence is not just a good memory. It includes thinking critically, solving problems and being creative. When technology keeps all the details for us, our brain is free to do more important things. For instance, a doctor can use a database to check the information about medicines, and then he can use his time to make a better diagnosis. In the past, people spent many years to memorise facts, while now we can find information in few seconds and use it in a new ways.
Furthermore, technology can even improve our abilities. There are apps for learning languages and training memory, and online courses make education available for everyone.
In conclusion, relying on technology for memory may reduce some skills, but it does not make people less intelligent, as long as they continue to think and use the information in a smart way.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: Topic vocabulary is sound ('critically', 'diagnosis', 'memorise', 'database'), and the writer shows some less common items. Errors in word form and structure such as 'in few seconds' and 'in a new ways' show some imprecision.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The writer gives a clear 'partly agree' stance: technology weakens some skills, but intelligence is not reduced. The GPS and phone-number examples are relevant and the doctor example is useful, but the 'Some research even showed' claim is vague and the last body paragraph is thin. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | Paragraphs follow a clear order: agreement, disagreement, extra benefits. Linking words such as 'Also', 'As a result', 'However' and 'Furthermore' are used, yet some are mechanical, and the short fourth paragraph on apps and courses feels disconnected. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | Topic vocabulary is sound ('critically', 'diagnosis', 'memorise', 'database'), and the writer shows some less common items. Errors in word form and structure such as 'in few seconds' and 'in a new ways' show some imprecision. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | The essay includes a variety of structures: 'When technology keeps all the details for us, our brain is free...' and relative clauses. Errors with articles, quantifiers and plural forms recur and are noticeable but rarely impede meaning. |
Marked mistakes
-
in few seconds
in a few seconds (GA)
'A few' is needed for a positive meaning; 'few' alone means almost none. -
use it in a new ways
use it in new ways (GA)
'A' cannot be used with a plural noun. -
In the past, people spent many years to memorise facts
In the past, people spent many years memorising facts (LR)
'Spend time' is followed by an -ing form, not an infinitive. -
they can not concentrate on a long book
they cannot concentrate on a long book (LR)
'Cannot' is written as one word.
What would raise the band
Check small grammar words (quantifiers, articles, plurals) systematically after writing, and expand the last body paragraph with one specific example of an app or course.
Band 8.5
Prompt: People rely too much on technology to remember information, and this is making them less intelligent. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Few of us can recall more than one or two telephone numbers, and many drivers would struggle to reach a familiar destination without satnav. Such observations lead some to conclude that technology is eroding human intelligence. I disagree with that conclusion: certain memory skills do decline with disuse, but intelligence is broader than recall, and technology can extend it.
The worry has some basis. Memory and spatial skills respond to practice, and studies of London taxi drivers, who memorise thousands of streets, show measurable differences in the brain regions involved in navigation. Conversely, people who follow turn-by-turn directions pay little attention to their surroundings and later find it harder to recall routes. Similarly, the habit of searching for every answer can create an illusion of knowledge, in which people believe they understand a topic because they know where to look it up. Constant notifications also fragment attention, making sustained reading or deep thought more difficult.
Nevertheless, the leap from weaker recall to lower intelligence is unjustified. Intelligence includes reasoning, judgement and the ability to combine ideas, and these depend on having material to think about rather than on storing it all internally. Offloading routine details can release mental capacity for analysis, much as writing allowed earlier generations to stop memorising epic poems and concentrate on interpreting them. A hospital doctor who consults a drug-interaction database in seconds is less likely to make an error and has more time to talk with the patient about symptoms. There is little evidence that average ability has fallen; indeed, scores on many intelligence tests rose throughout the twentieth century, a period of increasing reliance on external aids.
The risk lies in the manner of use. People should still memorise core knowledge in their field, since expertise requires an internal framework to judge information, and they should deliberately limit distractions to protect concentration.
In conclusion, technology changes which mental skills we exercise, but it does not make us less intelligent so long as we use it to support thinking rather than replace it.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8.5 · CC 8 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Coherence & Cohesion at 8: Cohesion is natural, with 'The worry has some basis', 'Nevertheless, the leap from weaker recall...', and 'The risk lies in the manner of use' marking the progression. Referencing is clear, but the fourth paragraph is quite short, and 'Similarly' links two ideas that are not quite parallel.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8.5 | The writer disagrees clearly, concedes certain skills decline, and argues that 'intelligence is broader than recall'. The London taxi drivers, the 'illusion of knowledge' and the doctor database are well chosen. The Flynn-effect point is slightly over-claimed as supporting evidence. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | Cohesion is natural, with 'The worry has some basis', 'Nevertheless, the leap from weaker recall...', and 'The risk lies in the manner of use' marking the progression. Referencing is clear, but the fourth paragraph is quite short, and 'Similarly' links two ideas that are not quite parallel. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8.5 | The lexis is sophisticated and accurate: 'eroding', 'offloading', 'fragment attention', 'spatial skills', 'internal framework'. The phrases 'illusion of knowledge' and 'release mental capacity' show flexibility and control of collocation. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | A very wide range of structures is controlled accurately, including the comparison 'much as writing allowed earlier generations...', 'since' clauses and participial phrases. Punctuation, including colons and semi-colons, is accurate, with no real errors. |
Marked mistakes
-
indeed, scores on many intelligence tests rose throughout the twentieth century, a period of increasing reliance on external aids
indeed, scores on many intelligence tests rose throughout the twentieth century, although this does not by itself prove that external aids helped (TR)
The rise is only correlational evidence and should be hedged. -
Similarly, the habit of searching for every answer
In addition, the habit of searching for every answer (CC)
'Similarly' suggests a comparison, but this is a new point rather than a parallel one.
What would raise the band
Hedge the intelligence-test claim so it does not sound like proof of cause, and expand the final body paragraph with an example of how to limit distractions.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay draws on specific evidence (London taxi drivers, rising IQ test scores) and a clear distinction between 'recall' and 'intelligence', with a historical analogy to writing. It also states what individuals should do. The 6.5 essay is sensible but its examples are everyday (phone numbers, GPS) and unspecific, with errors like 'few seconds', 'in a new ways' and 'can not concentrate'. The 6.5 response also lists points rather than building a single argument across paragraphs.
Check your essay on this task
Task: People rely too much on technology to remember information, and this is making them less intelligent. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.