Voting should be compulsory in national elections. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Voting should be compulsory in national elections. To what extent do you agree or disagree?” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: Voting should be compulsory in national elections. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
In some countries, such as Australia, voting is compulsory and citizens are fined if they do not vote. I agree that voting should be compulsory in the national elections, because it has more advantages than disadvantages.
The main advantage is that it increases the participation. In many countries, only half of the people go to vote, and the result of the election does not represent the opinion of the whole society. If everybody must vote, the government will be really chosen by the majority, so it will have more legitimacy. In Australia, about 90 percent of the people vote in every election, which is much higher than in countries without this rule.
Another advantage is that politicians have to care about all groups of the society, not only the groups who usually vote, like the old people. For example, young people and the poor often don't vote, so the parties ignore their problems. With compulsory voting, they would have to make a policies for these people as well. Besides, citizens may become more interested in politics and study the programs of the parties, because they know they have to make a choice.
However, there are some disadvantages. Some people say that to vote is a right, not a duty, and the government should not force people to do it. Also, voters who are not interested in politics may choose a candidate randomly or just for his appearance, and this can give bad results. Moreover, it is difficult and expensive to control and punish millions of people who did not vote.
To solve this problem, people should be allowed to submit an empty ballot paper, so those who do not support any candidate can show it.
In conclusion, I believe that compulsory voting is a good idea, because it makes the democracy stronger and more fair.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The vocabulary is adequate for the topic, with 'legitimacy', 'ballot paper', 'participation' and 'represent the opinion of the whole society'. Unnecessary articles ('the participation', 'the democracy') and 'the old people' show weak control of word forms, and phrases such as 'for his appearance' are slightly unnatural.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The writer agrees clearly and supports the view with participation, legitimacy and attention to marginalised groups, using Australia's 90 percent turnout as evidence. The disadvantages (right versus duty, random voting, cost of enforcement) are listed, but the proposed remedy of empty ballots is not linked to those problems convincingly. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | There is a clear structure of advantages, disadvantages and a suggested solution, signalled by 'The main advantage', 'Another advantage', 'However' and 'To solve this problem'. 'Besides' and 'Moreover' add information somewhat mechanically, and 'this problem' in the fifth paragraph is vague about which of the three disadvantages it refers to. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The vocabulary is adequate for the topic, with 'legitimacy', 'ballot paper', 'participation' and 'represent the opinion of the whole society'. Unnecessary articles ('the participation', 'the democracy') and 'the old people' show weak control of word forms, and phrases such as 'for his appearance' are slightly unnatural. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | The essay includes conditionals ('If everybody must vote, the government will be...') and 'because' clauses, and many sentences are accurate. Errors such as 'make a policies' and 'the democracy', along with repeated article misuse, are noticeable but do not obscure meaning. |
Marked mistakes
-
they would have to make a policies for these people as well
they would have to make policies for these people as well (GA)
'Policies' is already plural, so 'a' must be removed. -
it increases the participation
it increases participation (GA)
'Participation' is used in a general sense and takes no article. -
it makes the democracy stronger and more fair
it makes democracy stronger and fairer (GA)
'Democracy' as a general concept takes no article; 'fairer' is also the more common comparative, although 'more fair' is acceptable. -
like the old people
such as older people (LR)
'The old people' is outdated and generic; 'older people' or 'the elderly' is more neutral. -
To solve this problem, people should be allowed to submit an empty ballot paper
To address the objection that voting is a right rather than a duty, people should be allowed to submit a blank ballot paper (CC)
'This problem' does not clearly refer to a single earlier disadvantage; also 'blank' is the standard collocation for ballot papers.
What would raise the band
Link the proposed blank ballot directly to the 'right, not a duty' objection so the solution feels like part of the argument, and review articles with abstract nouns such as 'participation' and 'democracy'.
Band 8.0
Prompt: Voting should be compulsory in national elections. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
I do not support compulsory voting. Higher turnout is a worthwhile goal, but compelling people to vote treats a symptom of political disengagement and creates problems of its own.
The strongest argument for compulsion is that it produces results that represent the whole electorate. In Australia, where non-voters are fined, turnout exceeds ninety per cent, compared with around sixty per cent in many countries without such a rule. Because poorer and younger citizens are the least likely to vote voluntarily, parties in systems without compulsion can safely ignore them. This concern is real, and I do not dismiss it.
However, a high turnout figure does not indicate a healthy democracy by itself. Citizens who vote only to avoid a penalty often know little about the candidates, and some will tick boxes at random or support whoever appears first on the ballot paper. Australia records noticeable numbers of blank and spoiled papers, and the so-called donkey vote for the first name listed is a known phenomenon. The result may be an electorate that is larger but not better informed, which does not improve the quality of decisions.
There is also a question of principle. Taking part in politics is a right, and the right to participate implies the freedom to abstain, whether as a protest or because no candidate is acceptable. Fining someone for staying away from the polls effectively punishes a political choice, and it requires the state to track and prosecute millions of people.
The more effective approach is to make voting easier and more relevant: allowing registration on the day, holding elections at weekends, enabling postal or secure online voting, and teaching civic education in schools. When politicians give people a reason to vote, turnout tends to rise without the need for coercion.
For these reasons, I believe voting should remain a right that governments encourage, not a duty they enforce.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8 · GRA 8
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: The opening 'I do not support compulsory voting' is followed by a fair treatment of the strongest argument for compulsion (Australia's 90 per cent turnout, ignored young and poor voters) before it is answered. The position is developed through informed voters, principle, and a constructive alternative of weekend elections and civic education; some figures are given without sources.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The opening 'I do not support compulsory voting' is followed by a fair treatment of the strongest argument for compulsion (Australia's 90 per cent turnout, ignored young and poor voters) before it is answered. The position is developed through informed voters, principle, and a constructive alternative of weekend elections and civic education; some figures are given without sources. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | Each paragraph advances the case in order: concession, quality of votes, principle, then solutions. Linking is natural ('However', 'There is also a question of principle', 'The more effective approach is'), and 'This concern is real' refers back precisely to the previous point. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | The vocabulary is wide and exact: 'compelling', 'spoiled papers', 'donkey vote', 'abstain', 'coercion', 'civic education'. Collocations are accurate, though 'right' is repeated in one sentence. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8 | Structures include relative and participle clauses ('where non-voters are fined'), a parallel list after a colon, and nuanced concessions ('This concern is real, and I do not dismiss it'). Error-free sentences dominate and punctuation is precise. |
Marked mistakes
-
Taking part in politics is a right, and the right to participate implies the freedom to abstain
Taking part in politics is a right, and that right implies the freedom to abstain (LR)
'Right' appears twice in quick succession and 'to participate' repeats the idea of 'Taking part'; 'that right' is neater.
What would raise the band
Attach a source or approximate date to the turnout statistics (ninety per cent versus sixty per cent) and avoid repeating words such as 'right' within one sentence to move towards the very top band.
What separates the higher band
The two answers take opposite sides, but the 8.0 answer is stronger because it states the best argument for the other side fairly, then shows why high turnout alone is not enough (blank papers, donkey voting) and proposes concrete alternatives (weekend elections, same-day registration, civic education). The 6.5 answer lists advantages and disadvantages without weighing them and gives a brief remedy (a blank ballot). The 6.5 text also has errors such as "make a policies", "the participation" and "the democracy".
Check your essay on this task
Task: Voting should be compulsory in national elections. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.