University tuition should be free for all students, regardless of their family income. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “University tuition should be free for all students, regardless of their family income. To what extent do…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: University tuition should be free for all students, regardless of their family income. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
The question of who should pay for university education is discussed a lot. Some people think tuition must be free for all students whatever their family income. I disagree with this idea, because I believe free education for everybody is not fair and not realistic.
The first reason is the cost for the government. Universities are very expensive to run because they need modern equipment, laboratories and qualified professors. If students do not pay anything, all this money must come from taxes. It means that people who never went to university, such as farmers or drivers, are paying for the education of others. Also, the government has to spend money on hospitals, roads and schools, so there is not enough budget to give free places to everyone. In some countries which tried it, the quality of education became lower because universities were overcrowded.
Another problem is that rich families do not need this help. For example, a student whose parents are business owners can easily pay the fees. It would be better to use the money to support poor students who really need it, for instance by giving them scholarships or low interest loans. In this way the system is more fair and more efficient.
On the other hand, I understand that free tuition has advantages. Talented students from poor families will not be afraid of debt, and the country gets more educated workers. In Germany, for example, most universities charge no tuition and this attracts many international students. But even in this case, students still have to pay for accommodation and food, so it is not completely free.
In conclusion, although free higher education has some benefits, I think it should be only for students from low income families, and others should pay.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource at 6: The essay clearly opposes free tuition for all and proposes aid only for poor students, and it also admits the benefits in the fourth paragraph. Several points, such as 'the quality of education became lower' in countries that tried it, are asserted without any specific case, and the Germany example is brief.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6 | The essay clearly opposes free tuition for all and proposes aid only for poor students, and it also admits the benefits in the fourth paragraph. Several points, such as 'the quality of education became lower' in countries that tried it, are asserted without any specific case, and the Germany example is brief. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | 'The first reason', 'Another problem', 'On the other hand' and 'In conclusion' create a clear progression through taxes, fairness and counter-arguments. The concession paragraph arrives late, after the recommendation, which slightly disturbs the flow. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | Good topic words like 'scholarships', 'low interest loans', 'overcrowded' and 'laboratories' support the argument. Word choices are weaker in 'not fair and not realistic', 'there is not enough budget' and 'must be free', which are slightly inexact. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6.5 | This is the most accurate of the four areas: relative clauses, conditionals and 'although' clauses are mostly correct. The remaining slips are minor, such as the modal choice in 'must be free'. |
Marked mistakes
-
Some people think tuition must be free
Some people think tuition should be free (LR)
'Should' expresses an opinion, whereas 'must' suggests an obligation. -
free education for everybody is not fair and not realistic
free education for everybody is unfair and unrealistic (LR)
Use the negative adjectives 'unfair' and 'unrealistic' instead of repeating 'not'. -
there is not enough budget to give free places to everyone
there is not enough funding to give free places to everyone (LR)
'Budget' is a plan for spending, so 'funding' or 'money' is the correct noun. -
In some countries which tried it, the quality of education became lower because universities were overcrowded.
In the UK in the 1990s, rapid expansion left universities overcrowded and reduced the quality of teaching. (TR)
A named case would support the claim instead of leaving it as a general assertion.
What would raise the band
Support each main claim with one specific example (a named country, a figure) instead of general statements such as 'in some countries', and practise negatives like unfair and unrealistic.
Band 8.0
Prompt: University tuition should be free for all students, regardless of their family income. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Whether higher education should be free for everyone, including the children of wealthy parents, is a question on which I take a qualified position. I agree that no capable student should be kept out of university by cost, but I do not think universal free tuition is the best way to achieve that.
The principal argument in favour is access. When fees are high, students from low-income families either abandon the idea of university or graduate with debts that shape their choices for a decade, steering them towards well-paid jobs rather than, say, teaching or research. Countries such as Germany and Norway, where tuition is free, have broader participation and graduates who can take risks early in their careers. A highly educated population also generates tax revenue and innovation that benefit everyone, so one can argue that society recoups its investment.
However, a blanket policy is a blunt and expensive instrument. Public money is limited, and every pound spent subsidising a banker's child is a pound unavailable for maintenance grants, which research suggests are what really determine whether poorer students can attend: living costs, not tuition, are usually the larger barrier. Free tuition for all can even be regressive, because graduates earn substantially more over their lifetimes yet the cost is borne partly by taxpayers who never attended university. Where funding fails to keep pace with enrolment, quality tends to suffer, as lecture halls fill and staff-student ratios worsen.
A more equitable model combines fees with strong safeguards: tuition waived or heavily subsidised for low-income applicants, and income-contingent loans for others, repaid only once earnings pass a threshold, as in Australia. This preserves access while asking those who benefit most to contribute.
In conclusion, free tuition is a worthy aim for those who need it, but making it universal is neither the fairest nor the most efficient use of public funds.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8 · GRA 8
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: The 'qualified position' is clearly stated and both access and cost are discussed in depth. The point that living costs, not tuition, are the larger barrier is persuasive, though 'research suggests' and the Germany and Norway claims are not backed by detail.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The 'qualified position' is clearly stated and both access and cost are discussed in depth. The point that living costs, not tuition, are the larger barrier is persuasive, though 'research suggests' and the Germany and Norway claims are not backed by detail. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | The argument advances smoothly from the case for free tuition to a critique and then to the income-contingent loans model, with 'However' and 'This preserves access' linking each step. Each paragraph has a clear central idea, and the short fourth paragraph is neatly placed. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | Wide vocabulary such as 'regressive', 'blunt and expensive instrument', 'income-contingent loans' and 'maintenance grants' is accurate and flexible. 'Every pound spent subsidising a banker's child' is vivid but slightly stereotyped. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8 | Accurate use of complex sentences with 'where', 'yet', participle phrases and 'only once earnings pass a threshold' shows strong control. Only a couple of dense sentences reduce readability. |
Marked mistakes
-
which research suggests are what really determine whether poorer students can attend
which studies by the OECD suggest are the main factor in whether poorer students can attend (TR)
Naming the source would turn a vague reference into real support. -
every pound spent subsidising a banker's child
every pound spent subsidising a wealthy family's child (LR)
A neutral phrase avoids a stereotype and sounds more formal.
What would raise the band
Name the research or give one statistic when you say 'research suggests', so every key claim is as well supported as your Australia example.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 essay weighs both sides before reaching a position and adds a more sophisticated, specific point: living costs rather than tuition are often the real barrier, and universal free tuition can be regressive. It ends with a concrete alternative (income-contingent loans, as in Australia). The 6.5 essay gives a clear opinion, but its reasons stay general ('the government has to spend money on hospitals, roads and schools'), the 'rich families' argument is thin, and the concession paragraph arrives late, after the recommendation. It also asserts that the system is 'more fair and more efficient' without explaining why.
Check your essay on this task
Task: University tuition should be free for all students, regardless of their family income. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.