IELTS Task 2: Compulsory retirement — Band 6.5 vs 8.5 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

People should be allowed to work for as long as they wish, and compulsory retirement ages should be abolished. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “People should be allowed to work for as long as they wish, and compulsory retirement ages should be…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: People should be allowed to work for as long as they wish, and compulsory retirement ages should be abolished. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

In many countries, people must stop working when they reach a certain age, usually 60 or 65. I agree that this rule should be abolished and people should be allowed to work as long as they want.

The first reason is that many old people are still healthy and full of energy. Today, people live longer than in the past, so a person of 65 can be as active as a 50-year-old in earlier time. If they are forced to retire, their knowledge and experience are wasted. For example, a teacher or a doctor with forty years of experience can help young colleagues a lot. Also, working keeps the old people active and give them a purpose in life, whereas those who sit at home are often lonely and depressed.

The second reason is financial. In some countries the pension is very small and retired people cannot live on it. If they are allowed to continue working, they can earn more money and don't depend on their children or the government. In addition, it is good for the economy, because the state will pay less pensions and the employed old people pay the taxes.

However, there are some negative sides. Young people may find it difficult to get jobs and promotions if the older employees stay in their positions for a long time. Also, some jobs, such as pilots or construction workers, need good physical condition and the elderly may be dangerous in them.

Because of this, I think the employers should do regular medical tests, and people who are not fit for a job can be moved to easier positions.

In conclusion, I strongly agree that compulsory retirement age should be abolished, because it gives people freedom and benefits both the individuals and the society, but some safety control is needed.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: There is some topical vocabulary (pension, promotions, physical condition, depressed), and the essay is understandable throughout. Word choice is repetitive (old people, the elderly, older employees) and slips such as pay less pensions and in earlier time show limited control of collocation and word form.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The writer clearly agrees with abolishing compulsory retirement and supports it with health, experience and financial reasons, then acknowledges the problem of young people's promotion and dangerous jobs for pilots and construction workers. The solution of regular medical tests is useful, but the ideas about the economy and loneliness are stated more than developed.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The structure is clear, with the first reason, the second reason, the objections and a conclusion. Linking words such as Also, In addition and Because of this are used correctly but repetitively, and the one-sentence paragraph beginning Because of this feels detached from the one before it.
Lexical Resource Band 6 There is some topical vocabulary (pension, promotions, physical condition, depressed), and the essay is understandable throughout. Word choice is repetitive (old people, the elderly, older employees) and slips such as pay less pensions and in earlier time show limited control of collocation and word form.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 The essay includes conditional, whereas and because clauses, so there is a fair mix of structures. Errors occur in most paragraphs (keeps the old people active and give them, the employed old people pay the taxes) but rarely stop the reader from understanding.

Marked mistakes

  1. as active as a 50-year-old in earlier time
    as active as a 50-year-old in earlier times (GA)
    Time here is plural in meaning, so earlier times is the correct phrase.
  2. working keeps the old people active and give them a purpose in life
    working keeps older people active and gives them a purpose in life (GA)
    Both verbs share the singular subject working, so gives is required, and the article before old people is unnecessary.
  3. the state will pay less pensions
    the state will pay fewer pensions (LR)
    Pensions is countable, so fewer is needed instead of less.
  4. the employed old people pay the taxes
    older people who stay in work pay taxes (LR)
    The original is unnatural; use a relative clause and drop the before taxes.
  5. Because of this, I think the employers should do regular medical tests
    To address these concerns, I think employers should carry out regular medical tests (CC)
    'Because of this' refers vaguely to the problems in the previous paragraph; 'To address these concerns' links more precisely, 'carry out' is the natural verb with 'medical tests', and no article is needed before 'employers'.

What would raise the band

Reread your draft for plural and singular forms (pay fewer pensions, keeps and gives, in earlier times) because these repeated errors are what stop your grammar and vocabulary from reaching Band 7.

Band 8.5

Prompt: People should be allowed to work for as long as they wish, and compulsory retirement ages should be abolished. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

I agree that fixed retirement ages should be abolished, since they treat age as a proxy for ability and ignore both the preferences of individuals and the needs of ageing societies.

Chronological age is a poor guide to how well someone can do a job. A university lecturer of seventy may be sharper than a colleague twenty years younger, while a manual worker may find a physically demanding role too difficult at fifty-five. A blanket cut-off discards capable people and keeps in place those who are struggling, whereas a system based on performance would treat each worker fairly. For many, work is also a source of identity and social contact, and studies of retirees suggest that an abrupt end to it can contribute to isolation and a decline in health.

There is a strong economic case as well. In countries such as Japan and Italy, the proportion of people of working age is falling, and pension systems that rely on contributions from workers are under strain. Allowing people who wish to continue to remain in employment increases tax revenue, reduces the cost of pensions, and helps employers who face skills shortages.

The main concern is that older workers who stay on will block promotion for younger colleagues. This fear rests on the assumption that the number of jobs is fixed, which is not borne out by evidence; countries with higher employment among older people do not generally have higher youth unemployment. Safety is a more serious issue in some occupations. For pilots, firefighters or surgeons, regular medical and competence checks for all employees, regardless of age, would be a better safeguard than a fixed date, and workers could be offered reduced duties or part-time hours as they grow older.

Overall, ending compulsory retirement would give workers real choice and make better use of experience, as long as it is accompanied by fair assessment of fitness for each role.

Why Band 8.5, not 9

TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource at 8: The first sentence sets out a clear position and the reason behind it, that age is a poor proxy for ability. Arguments on ability, identity, economics, promotion and safety are all developed with examples such as the lecturer of seventy and pilots or surgeons, though the claim about Japan, Italy and youth unemployment is made without a precise source.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The first sentence sets out a clear position and the reason behind it, that age is a poor proxy for ability. Arguments on ability, identity, economics, promotion and safety are all developed with examples such as the lecturer of seventy and pilots or surgeons, though the claim about Japan, Italy and youth unemployment is made without a precise source.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8.5 Paragraphs follow a logical order from individual fairness to economic benefits and then to the main concerns, and the conclusion ties them together. Cohesion is smooth because ideas are linked by meaning (This fear rests on the assumption, a better safeguard) rather than by a list of connectors.
Lexical Resource Band 8 Vocabulary is precise and academic, for instance chronological age, blanket cut-off, skills shortages and not borne out by evidence. A few phrases are slightly repetitive or clumsy, such as to continue to remain in employment, but there are no spelling or word-form faults.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 Sentences are varied and include relative clauses, whereas contrasts, conditionals and a semicolon used correctly. Errors are very rare and do not affect the meaning at all.

Marked mistakes

  1. Allowing people who wish to continue to remain in employment
    Allowing people who wish to do so to remain in employment (LR)
    Continue and remain overlap in meaning, which makes the phrase heavy.

What would raise the band

To move closer to Band 9, support one economic claim with an exact figure or named study and polish the few heavier phrases such as continue to remain.

What separates the higher band

The 8.5 answer starts from a precise idea, that age is a poor proxy for ability, and develops it with a contrasting pair (a seventy-year-old lecturer versus a fifty-five-year-old manual worker). It also rebuts the "blocking young people" objection with reasoning instead of just mentioning it, as the 6.5 answer does. The 6.5 text has slips such as "give them a purpose", "pay less pensions", "may be dangerous in them" and "in earlier time".

Check your essay on this task

Task: People should be allowed to work for as long as they wish, and compulsory retirement ages should be abolished. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →