Mental health should be taught in schools as an important subject alongside physical health. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Mental health should be taught in schools as an important subject alongside physical health. To what…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Mental health should be taught in schools as an important subject alongside physical health. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Nowadays, many young people suffer from stress, depression and anxiety. I strongly agree that mental health should be taught in schools as an important subject together with physical health.
The first reason is that students have a lot of pressure. They must pass difficult exams, get good marks and also deal with the problems like bullying and social media. If nobody explain to them how to manage stress, they can become depressed and some of them even think about suicide. If schools teach mental health, children will learn how to recognise the signs of problem and where to ask for help. For example, in my school we had a psychologist who gave lessons once a month, and many students said that it helped them a lot.
The second reason is that mental illness is still a taboo in many societies. People are afraid to say that they have a problem because others will think they are weak or crazy. When mental health become a normal school subject, children will understand that it is same as physical health, and they will not be ashamed to talk. This will make the society more kind and tolerant in future.
On the other hand, there are some problems with this idea. Schools already have a very full curriculum, and teachers may not have enough training to teach this subject. If a teacher gives wrong advice, it can do more harm than good. Moreover, some parents may not agree with it because they think it is a family matter.
To solve this, the schools need to employ professional psychologists and give special training to teachers.
In conclusion, I believe mental health education is very essential for students and should be part of the school programme.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: Conditionals and time clauses are attempted ('If schools teach mental health, children will learn'), but subject-verb agreement fails repeatedly, as in 'nobody explain' and 'mental health become'. Articles are also dropped in 'same as physical health' and 'signs of problem', so errors are frequent enough to be noticeable.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | 'I strongly agree' gives a clear position, and the points about exam pressure and mental-health stigma are relevant. Support relies on a personal example ('in my school we had a psychologist') and the discussion of problems ('teachers may not have enough training') is brief, with the answer to it left to a single one-line paragraph. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6 | The essay moves clearly from first reason to second reason to counter-arguments, using 'The first reason', 'Moreover' and 'On the other hand'. 'To solve this, the schools need to...' sits alone as a one-sentence paragraph, which weakens paragraphing. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The topic vocabulary is adequate ('taboo', 'tolerant', 'curriculum', 'stress, depression and anxiety'), but there is reliance on simple items like 'problems' and 'a lot', and 'very essential' is a redundant intensifier. Word-form slips such as 'signs of problem' show that precision is uneven. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | Conditionals and time clauses are attempted ('If schools teach mental health, children will learn'), but subject-verb agreement fails repeatedly, as in 'nobody explain' and 'mental health become'. Articles are also dropped in 'same as physical health' and 'signs of problem', so errors are frequent enough to be noticeable. |
Marked mistakes
-
If nobody explain to them how to manage stress
If nobody explains to them how to manage stress (GA)
'Nobody' is singular and needs the verb ending -s. -
When mental health become a normal school subject
When mental health becomes a normal school subject (GA)
'Mental health' is an uncountable singular noun, so the verb needs -s. -
it is same as physical health
it is the same as physical health (GA)
'The same as' requires the definite article. -
the signs of problem and where to ask for help
the signs of a problem and where to ask for help (GA)
A singular countable noun needs an article, or the plural 'problems'. -
is very essential for students
is essential for students (LR)
'Essential' is already absolute, so it cannot be modified by 'very'.
What would raise the band
Proofread every sentence for subject-verb agreement and articles, and merge the one-line 'To solve this' paragraph into the counter-argument paragraph with a fuller explanation.
Band 8.0
Prompt: Mental health should be taught in schools as an important subject alongside physical health. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
I agree that mental health deserves a place in the school curriculum beside physical education and health lessons, and I think the case is stronger than many people realise.
The most compelling argument concerns timing. Studies suggest that about half of all lifelong mental health conditions begin by the age of fourteen, yet many young people go years without help because they do not recognise what they are experiencing or fear being judged. Schools are the one institution that reaches nearly every child, so they offer an unusual chance to identify problems early. Lessons can teach pupils to spot warning signs in themselves and their friends, to understand that anxiety or low mood is a medical matter rather than a personal failing, and to know where to turn. Such knowledge can have a real effect on a classmate in crisis, who is more likely to confide in a friend than in an adult.
Mental health education can also build practical skills. Techniques for managing exam stress, dealing with conflict and limiting social media use are no less useful than the ability to solve equations, and unlike many subjects they apply throughout adult life. Taught well, they could also reduce the stigma that persists in many communities.
There are reasonable objections. Timetables are already crowded, and lessons delivered by teachers without training could be superficial, or even encourage pupils to interpret ordinary sadness as illness. Both risks can be managed. The material can be integrated into existing personal development lessons, delivered by teachers with proper training and supported by counsellors for pupils needing individual attention.
On balance, I believe that treating mental and physical health as equally important is justified by the evidence, and schools are the most effective place to begin doing so.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8 · GRA 8
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: The position is clear from the first sentence ('the case is stronger than many people realise') and developed through early identification, practical skills and a rebuttal of objections. The statistic about 'about half of all lifelong mental health conditions' is unsourced, and the link in 'a classmate in crisis' is slightly under-explained.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The position is clear from the first sentence ('the case is stronger than many people realise') and developed through early identification, practical skills and a rebuttal of objections. The statistic about 'about half of all lifelong mental health conditions' is unsourced, and the link in 'a classmate in crisis' is slightly under-explained. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | Sequencing is skilful: it moves from timing to practical skills to objections and then to the conclusion, with signposting such as 'The most compelling argument concerns timing' and 'There are reasonable objections'. Cohesion is well managed with 'Both risks can be managed' pointing back accurately to the two risks just named. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | Flexible, precise vocabulary is used: 'personal failing', 'stigma that persists', 'superficial', 'personal development lessons'. Collocations are mostly natural, with minor looseness in 'a real effect on a classmate in crisis'. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8 | Most sentences are error-free and structures are varied, including a passive reduced clause ('delivered by teachers with proper training'), contrast with 'yet' and a long cumulative list sentence on skills ('no less useful than the ability to solve equations'). |
Marked mistakes
-
Studies suggest that about half of all lifelong mental health conditions begin by the age of fourteen
According to World Health Organization estimates, about half of all lifelong mental health conditions begin by the age of fourteen (TR)
Naming the source makes a key statistic credible; 'Studies suggest' is vague. -
Such knowledge can have a real effect on a classmate in crisis, who is more likely to confide in a friend than in an adult.
As a result, a pupil in crisis is more likely to be helped, since they are more likely to confide in a friend than in an adult. (CC)
The sentence jumps from taught knowledge to a classmate without stating that the friend acts on what they have learned.
What would raise the band
Back up the key statistic with a named source and make cause and effect explicit in the sentence about peer support, so that every claim is fully extended.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 answer rests on one strong, specific argument (most conditions begin in adolescence and schools reach every child) and ties it to concrete lesson content, while the 6.0 answer states general pressures on students and a single anecdote about a school psychologist. The 8.0 answer also gives a balanced treatment of the risks, including over-medicalising normal sadness, and explains how to manage them. The 6.0 text has errors such as "nobody explain", "mental health become" and "very essential", and its solution is brief.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Mental health should be taught in schools as an important subject alongside physical health. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.