Some people argue that nuclear power is the best answer to the world's energy needs. Others believe renewable sources such as wind and solar should be used instead. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people argue that nuclear power is the best answer to the world's energy needs. Others believe…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Some people argue that nuclear power is the best answer to the world's energy needs. Others believe renewable sources such as wind and solar should be used instead. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Energy is a very important problem for every country nowadays. Some people think that nuclear power is the best solution, while other people prefer renewable sources like wind and solar. In this essay I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
On the one hand, supporters of nuclear power say that it can produce a huge amount of electricity all the time. A nuclear plant does not depend on the weather, so factories and hospitals can have stable electricity every day. Moreover, nuclear energy does not produce much carbon dioxide, so it is good for fighting climate change. For example, France take most of its electricity from nuclear plants and its emissions are lower than many countries.
On the other hand, many people believe that renewable energy is more safe and cleaner. Firstly, accidents like Chernobyl and Fukushima showed that nuclear power can be very dangerous for people and environment. Secondly, nuclear waste stay radioactive for thousands of years and nobody knows exactly where to keep it. Wind and solar do not have this problem. In addition, the price of solar panels have fallen a lot in recent years, so it become cheaper for ordinary families to use them.
In my opinion, renewable sources are the better choice in the long term, but they cannot solve everything at the moment. Sun does not shine at night and sometimes there is no wind, so countries still need another source. Therefore I think governments should invest mainly in wind and solar, and use nuclear power only as a temporary support until batteries become better.
In conclusion, both nuclear and renewable energy have advantages and disadvantages. I believe that renewable energy is the best answer for the future, because it is safer and does not leave dangerous waste for next generations.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6 · CC 6 · LR 5.5 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: Vocabulary is adequate for the topic ('carbon dioxide', 'climate change', 'radioactive'), but the writer relies on simple items such as 'very important problem', 'a lot' and 'good'. Word-form errors like 'more safe and cleaner' and 'it become cheaper' show weak control of less simple language.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6 | Both views are covered and the writer clearly prefers renewables, but the support stays general: 'it can produce a huge amount of electricity all the time' and 'nobody knows exactly where to keep it' are not developed with data or fuller explanation. The France example and the brief mention of Chernobyl and Fukushima are the only concrete evidence, and neither is explained. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6 | Each paragraph has a clear job (nuclear case, renewable case, opinion) and 'On the one hand / On the other hand / Firstly / Secondly / In addition' give a visible structure. The linking is rather mechanical, and the conclusion repeats the safety and waste points already made in the third paragraph. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5.5 | Vocabulary is adequate for the topic ('carbon dioxide', 'climate change', 'radioactive'), but the writer relies on simple items such as 'very important problem', 'a lot' and 'good'. Word-form errors like 'more safe and cleaner' and 'it become cheaper' show weak control of less simple language. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | A mix of simple and complex sentences is used, including 'because' and 'until batteries become better' clauses. However, repeated subject-verb agreement slips ('France take', 'nuclear waste stay', 'the price ... have fallen') and a missing article in 'Sun does not shine' occur in many sentences, though meaning stays clear. |
Marked mistakes
-
France take most of its electricity from nuclear plants
France takes most of its electricity from nuclear plants (GA)
The singular subject 'France' needs the verb 'takes'. -
nuclear waste stay radioactive for thousands of years
nuclear waste stays radioactive for thousands of years (GA)
'Waste' is an uncountable singular noun and takes 'stays'. -
the price of solar panels have fallen a lot in recent years
the price of solar panels has fallen a lot in recent years (GA)
The subject is 'price', not 'panels', so the verb must be 'has'. -
so it become cheaper for ordinary families to use them
so it has become cheaper for ordinary families to use them (GA)
A present perfect form is needed for a change over recent years. -
renewable energy is more safe and cleaner
renewable energy is safer and cleaner (LR)
Short adjectives like 'safe' take -er, which also keeps the pair parallel.
What would raise the band
Check every verb against its subject before you finish: most of your errors ('France take', 'waste stay', 'price ... have fallen') are the same agreement mistake, and fixing it would raise your accuracy score quickly. Also replace general claims like 'a huge amount of electricity' with a figure or a specific example.
Band 8.0
Prompt: Some people argue that nuclear power is the best answer to the world's energy needs. Others believe renewable sources such as wind and solar should be used instead. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Few issues divide opinion on energy policy as sharply as nuclear power. Advocates see it as the only low-carbon option that can power a modern economy, while critics argue that wind and solar can do the job more safely. I believe both camps are partly right, although the balance should favour renewables.
The case for nuclear rests on reliability. A reactor runs around the clock regardless of weather, which matters for steelworks, hospitals and rail networks that cannot tolerate interruptions. Land use is another point in its favour: a single plant can generate as much electricity as thousands of wind turbines spread across hundreds of square kilometres. France, which derives roughly two-thirds of its power from reactors, has some of the lowest per-capita emissions in Europe, which shows what this approach can achieve.
Nevertheless, the drawbacks are considerable. Reactors take over a decade to build and routinely exceed their budgets; Britain's Hinkley Point C is a well-known example. Waste remains hazardous for millennia, and few countries have found a permanent storage site. Renewables, by contrast, can be installed in months, and their costs have dropped dramatically, with solar electricity now cheaper than gas in many regions. The weakness of intermittency is also being addressed through large-scale batteries and better grid connections between regions.
On balance, I would argue that governments should concentrate investment on wind, solar and storage, since these can be deployed quickly enough to meet climate targets. Existing nuclear plants, however, should not be shut down prematurely, because they provide a steady base load while storage technology matures. Building new reactors is justified only where a country lacks suitable sun or wind.
In summary, nuclear power offers dependable output but at a high financial and environmental cost, whereas renewables are cheaper and faster to build. A pragmatic strategy would rely mainly on the latter, using the former as a bridge rather than a destination.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: The essay gives each side a developed case (reliability and land use for nuclear; build time, waste and cost for renewables) and a clear, nuanced position: renewables first, existing reactors kept as a 'steady base load'. Examples such as Hinkley Point C and France's two-thirds share are specific, though some figures, such as the turbine comparison, are given without support.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The essay gives each side a developed case (reliability and land use for nuclear; build time, waste and cost for renewables) and a clear, nuanced position: renewables first, existing reactors kept as a 'steady base load'. Examples such as Hinkley Point C and France's two-thirds share are specific, though some figures, such as the turbine comparison, are given without support. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | The sequence is very logical, moving from 'The case for nuclear rests on reliability' through 'Nevertheless, the drawbacks are considerable' to 'On balance'. Cohesion is natural, with 'by contrast', 'however' and the closing 'the latter ... the former' referencing used precisely, and every paragraph has one clear topic. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | Vocabulary is wide and precise: 'intermittency', 'base load', 'low-carbon option', 'tolerate interruptions' and 'a bridge rather than a destination' are used naturally. Collocations are accurate, and the only weakness is a slightly loose phrase such as 'do the job'. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8 | Sentence structures vary widely, with relative clauses ('France, which derives roughly two-thirds of its power from reactors'), concessive 'although' and a well-used semicolon. Nearly all sentences are error-free and the punctuation is controlled. |
Marked mistakes
-
wind and solar can do the job more safely
wind and solar can meet demand more safely (LR)
'Do the job' is slightly colloquial for a high-band academic register.
What would raise the band
To move toward the top bands, support the statistics with precise, defensible figures (for example the number of turbines a single plant replaces) or a source. A single sentence on the cost of storage would also test your own preferred solution.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 answer takes a clear, qualified position (renewables first, existing reactors kept as a bridge) and backs each side with concrete evidence such as France's emissions, Hinkley Point C's delays and falling solar costs, while the 6.0 answer stays at the level of general claims like 'nuclear power can be very dangerous'. It also addresses the weakness of its own preferred option (intermittency) with a specific solution, storage and grid links, whereas the 6.0 essay only mentions the problem and gives a vague 'temporary support' fix. Grammar and cohesion are more controlled in the 8.0 text; the 6.0 text has agreement and article errors ('France take', 'Sun does not shine', 'it become cheaper') and relies on mechanical linkers.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people argue that nuclear power is the best answer to the world's energy needs. Others believe renewable sources such as wind and solar should be used instead. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.