Teachers' salaries should be linked to their students' exam results. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Teachers' salaries should be linked to their students' exam results. To what extent do you agree or disagree?” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: Teachers' salaries should be linked to their students' exam results. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Some people think that teachers should receive a salary which depends on how well their students do in exams. I strongly disagree with this idea because I think it is unfair for teachers and it can harm education.
First of all, exam results do not show only the quality of a teacher. Many other factors have influence on student's marks, for example the family background, the motivation of the student or the facilities of the school. A teacher who works in a poor area with large classes may be excellent, but his students could get low marks because they have many problems at home. If his salary is lower than other teacher's, it would be unfair and he may feel discouraged. In contrast, a teacher in a rich private school can get a high salary just because his students are from educated families.
Secondly, this system makes teachers focus only on the tests. They will teach students how to pass the exam and ignore other important things like creative thinking, communication skills or good behaviour. Some teachers might even cheat. For instance, there were cases in the United States where teachers changed the answers of the students to get a bonus. This situation is very dangerous for the education system.
Moreover, if teachers compete against each other, the cooperation between them will become weaker. Teachers will not share their good ideas with colleagues, because they are afraid that another teacher will get higher results.
On the other hand, I agree that good teachers should be rewarded. The government can give them bonuses for other reasons, like improving their qualifications, the observation of their lessons or the progress of their students during the year, not only the final marks.
In conclusion, I do not think that teachers' pay should be connected to the exam results, because it is not fair and it makes education worse.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6.5 · CC 7 · LR 6.5 · GRA 6.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6.5: The writer strongly disagrees and gives three reasons: unfairness caused by outside factors, teaching to the test, and weaker cooperation. The US example of teachers changing answers is relevant but only mentioned in passing. The paragraph beginning 'On the other hand, I agree that good teachers should be rewarded' adds a useful alternative, though its criteria are listed without explanation.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The writer strongly disagrees and gives three reasons: unfairness caused by outside factors, teaching to the test, and weaker cooperation. The US example of teachers changing answers is relevant but only mentioned in passing. The paragraph beginning 'On the other hand, I agree that good teachers should be rewarded' adds a useful alternative, though its criteria are listed without explanation. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 7 | The essay is clearly organised with ordinal signposts ('First of all', 'Secondly', 'Moreover') and a contrasting paragraph before the conclusion. The poor-area versus rich-school contrast in the first body paragraph builds logically. Referencing with 'his' and 'this situation' is mostly clear. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6.5 | Vocabulary is adequate and sometimes good: 'facilities of the school', 'creative thinking', 'qualifications', 'bonus'. Collocation and form slips occur, notably 'have influence on student's marks' and the unbalanced list 'improving their qualifications, the observation of their lessons or the progress of their students'. Overall the writer shows some less common vocabulary with a few inaccuracies. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6.5 | There is a good mix of simple, complex and conditional sentences, such as 'A teacher who works in a poor area with large classes may be excellent, but his students could get low marks because...'. Errors are frequent but minor: 'student's marks', 'other teacher's' and an awkward list in the last body paragraph. Punctuation is accurate. |
Marked mistakes
-
Many other factors have influence on student's marks
Many other factors influence students' marks (LR)
'Influence' works better as a verb, and the general plural possessive is 'students''. -
If his salary is lower than other teacher's
If his salary is lower than other teachers' (GA)
Comparison with all other teachers needs the plural possessive. -
like improving their qualifications, the observation of their lessons or the progress of their students during the year
such as improving their qualifications, being observed teaching, or helping students progress during the year (GA)
The list mixes a gerund with noun phrases; keeping the forms parallel is clearer. -
there were cases in the United States where teachers changed the answers of the students to get a bonus
in Atlanta, teachers were found to have changed pupils' answers to obtain bonuses (TR)
A specific, named case would make this key example more convincing.
What would raise the band
Develop key examples with names and details, for example the cheating cases, and practise using apostrophes and parallel lists accurately.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Teachers' salaries should be linked to their students' exam results. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Performance-related pay has been tried in teaching in several countries, and the idea has an obvious appeal: if teachers are rewarded for results, standards should rise. I nevertheless disagree with linking salaries to exam results, since the policy measures the wrong thing and produces perverse incentives.
The fundamental problem is that exam scores reflect much more than teaching quality. A student's results are strongly influenced by parental education, income, health and prior attainment, none of which a teacher controls. Under a results-based scheme, a teacher in a deprived area who lifts a class from failing grades to a pass could earn less than a colleague in a prosperous suburb whose pupils would have succeeded with almost any instruction. Talented teachers would then have a financial reason to avoid the very schools that need them most, widening existing inequalities.
The incentives created are also troubling. When pay depends on test scores, teachers are tempted to narrow the curriculum to examinable content, drilling past papers at the expense of discussion, experimentation and critical thinking. In extreme cases they cheat: in Atlanta, a widely reported scandal in 2009 revealed that staff had altered pupils' answer sheets to secure bonuses. Collaboration suffers as well, because colleagues have little reason to share effective lesson plans with someone they are effectively competing against for a pay rise.
None of this means that good teaching should go unrewarded. Pay progression could be tied to a broader assessment that includes classroom observation, professional development and measures of pupils' progress rather than absolute scores, so that a teacher is judged on the value they add. Allowances for working in hard-to-staff schools would reinforce the point.
In conclusion, rewarding excellence is a legitimate aim, but linking salaries to exam results is both unfair and counterproductive, and a wider set of measures would serve students better.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8.5 · CC 8.5 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8.5: The thesis ('the policy measures the wrong thing and produces perverse incentives') is clear and each body paragraph delivers on it. Development is vivid, from the contrast between a deprived-area teacher and a prosperous-suburb colleague to the 2009 Atlanta answer-sheet scandal. The balanced fourth paragraph proposing broader assessment shows full engagement with the task.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8.5 | The thesis ('the policy measures the wrong thing and produces perverse incentives') is clear and each body paragraph delivers on it. Development is vivid, from the contrast between a deprived-area teacher and a prosperous-suburb colleague to the 2009 Atlanta answer-sheet scandal. The balanced fourth paragraph proposing broader assessment shows full engagement with the task. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | Paragraphs are tightly organised around 'The fundamental problem', 'The incentives created' and 'None of this means...', so the reader always knows where the argument stands. Cohesion is managed with subtle devices ('Under a results-based scheme', 'Collaboration suffers as well'). The vague closing 'would reinforce the point' in the fourth paragraph slightly weakens the final link. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8.5 | Lexis is wide and accurate: 'perverse incentives', 'narrow the curriculum to examinable content', 'prior attainment', 'value they add'. Collocations such as 'widening existing inequalities' are natural. The register is consistently formal. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | The essay shows excellent syntactic range, including a long conditional with a relative clause ('a teacher in a deprived area who lifts a class ... could earn less than a colleague...') and a 'so that' purpose clause. Errors are almost absent. A few sentences are long but remain clear. |
Marked mistakes
-
Allowances for working in hard-to-staff schools would reinforce the point.
Allowances for working in hard-to-staff schools would reinforce the principle that pay should reward added value. (CC)
'The point' is imprecise; naming the idea gives a clearer link. -
whose pupils would have succeeded with almost any instruction
whose pupils would probably have succeeded with fairly ordinary instruction (TR)
The sweeping claim is exaggerated and a hedge would be more persuasive.
What would raise the band
To tighten the top-band polish, hedge sweeping claims and replace vague phrases like 'reinforce the point' with the specific idea being supported.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay distinguishes absolute results from value added, which gives it a precise alternative to the policy, and it supports claims with a specific case (the Atlanta scandal) and a clear causal chain about good teachers avoiding deprived schools. The 6.5 essay also opposes the policy but with more general reasoning, repeated 'unfair' and errors such as 'have influence on student's marks' and 'other teacher's'. The 8.5 text uses more varied cohesion, such as 'None of this means...' rather than 'Secondly' and 'Moreover'.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Teachers' salaries should be linked to their students' exam results. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.