Students should be allowed to choose which subjects they study at secondary school from an early age. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Students should be allowed to choose which subjects they study at secondary school from an early age. To…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Students should be allowed to choose which subjects they study at secondary school from an early age. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Some people think that students should select their own subjects in secondary school when they are still young. I partly disagree with this view. Although choice has some benefits, I believe that early specialisation can be harmful for most students.
On the one hand, allowing students to choose can increase their motivation. When a pupil study a subject he likes, for example music or computers, he will be more interested and work harder. Some children also discover their talent early, and they can start to develop it. A girl who loves painting could spend more time on art and become a professional artist in the future. Also, students who are forced to study subjects they hate often get bad marks and lose confidence.
On the other hand, children at the age of twelve or thirteen are too young to make such an important decision. They usually do not know what job they want, and their choices are influenced by friends or by what is easy. For example, many students may avoid maths and physics only because they are difficult, and later they will understand that they closed many doors for their career. It is very hard to come back to these subjects after some years. In addition, a narrow education makes people less flexible, because the modern world need workers who have wide knowledge.
I think the best system is when all students study basic subjects like maths, science, languages and history until about fifteen, and after this they can choose some subjects. Before that, schools should offer many activities and clubs so that children can try different things. Parents and teachers should also give advice to them about the choice.
In conclusion, I do not fully agree with early choice of subjects. Students need a broad base first, and later they can specialise in what they are good at.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: Several different structures are attempted, including conditional-like clauses and 'when' phrases, but agreement is regularly wrong: 'a pupil study', 'the modern world need'.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The 'partly disagree' stance is stated at the start and the essay weighs motivation against children being 'too young to make such an important decision'. The painting and maths-and-physics examples are relevant, but the 'closed many doors' argument is not explained further. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | The structure with 'On the one hand', 'On the other hand' and 'In addition' is clear and each paragraph has a main idea. Overuse of 'students' and 'children', and the pronoun 'he' for 'a pupil', slightly weaken reference. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The vocabulary is appropriate ('specialisation', 'motivation', 'flexible', 'narrow education'), and 'closed many doors' is a good idiom. Some word choices are inexact, for example 'give advice to them about the choice' and 'come back to these subjects'. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | Several different structures are attempted, including conditional-like clauses and 'when' phrases, but agreement is regularly wrong: 'a pupil study', 'the modern world need'. |
Marked mistakes
-
When a pupil study a subject he likes
When a pupil studies a subject he likes (GA)
Singular 'a pupil' needs 'studies'. -
the modern world need workers who have wide knowledge
the modern world needs workers who have wide knowledge (GA)
'The modern world' is singular, so the verb takes -s. -
should also give advice to them about the choice
should also advise them on their choices (LR)
'Advise someone on something' is more natural and concise than 'give advice to them about'.
What would raise the band
Check subject-verb agreement in every sentence ('a pupil studies', 'the world needs') and expand the 'closed many doors' point with a specific example of a later career that needs science.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Students should be allowed to choose which subjects they study at secondary school from an early age. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Letting teenagers pick their own subjects is often presented as a way of respecting individual talent. While I accept that choice can raise motivation, I disagree that it should begin early, because the likely costs outweigh the benefits.
The attraction of early choice is clear. A pupil who is allowed to spend more time on programming or music will probably be more engaged than one who sits through lessons that seem pointless, and engagement is closely linked to achievement. Some talents, such as in sport or instrumental performance, also require early and intensive practice, so a rigid curriculum may hold back exceptionally gifted children.
Against this, children of eleven or twelve are poorly equipped to judge what they will need. Their preferences are often shaped by a charismatic teacher, a friend's opinion or the desire to avoid effort, rather than by informed reflection on their abilities. A girl who drops physics because she finds the first topic confusing may, three years later, discover a passion for engineering and find the path closed. Such decisions are hard to reverse, since later courses assume knowledge built up over several years. Moreover, early narrowing deprives students of the breadth that employers increasingly value; a future journalist benefits from understanding statistics, and a scientist from being able to write clearly.
This does not mean that students should have no say. A better arrangement is a common core of mathematics, science, languages and humanities until around fifteen, accompanied by a limited number of electives and short taster courses that allow pupils to sample unfamiliar fields without commitment. Careers guidance and conversations with parents could then inform the more significant choices made in the final years of school.
In conclusion, choice is valuable but premature freedom risks closing doors that students did not know existed, so specialisation should be delayed until they are older and better informed.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion at 8: The disagreement is clear from the opening, and the essay credits motivation and early talent in sport or music before showing why choosing at eleven is risky. The physics-to-engineering example is vivid, but the opening 'teenagers' sits oddly with the 'eleven or twelve' of the argument.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The disagreement is clear from the opening, and the essay credits motivation and early talent in sport or music before showing why choosing at eleven is risky. The physics-to-engineering example is vivid, but the opening 'teenagers' sits oddly with the 'eleven or twelve' of the argument. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | Paragraphs follow a clear plan: attraction of choice, objections, then a compromise with a common core and electives. 'Against this', 'Moreover' and 'This does not mean' are used skilfully to turn the argument. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8.5 | Precise vocabulary such as 'charismatic teacher', 'taster courses', 'early narrowing' and 'informed reflection' shows wide control with natural collocations. There are no spelling or word-form errors. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | Complex sentences with semicolons, 'since' clauses and modal 'may ... discover' are accurate and varied, and almost every sentence is error-free. A tense shift in 'may, three years later, discover' is handled correctly. |
Marked mistakes
-
Letting teenagers pick their own subjects is often presented as a way of respecting individual talent.
Letting young pupils pick their own subjects is often presented as a way of respecting individual talent. (TR)
The essay later discusses children of eleven or twelve, so 'teenagers' does not match the focus on early age. -
engagement is closely linked to achievement
engagement is closely linked to achievement, according to numerous educational studies (TR)
A reference to evidence would strengthen this assertion.
What would raise the band
Keep the age reference consistent with the question ('early age') and add one piece of evidence to the claim about engagement and achievement.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay anticipates counterarguments and uses a well-developed example (a girl dropping physics then wanting engineering) to explain why early choice is irreversible. It proposes a nuanced compromise with electives and taster courses and ties it to guidance. The 6.0 essay reaches a similar compromise but with simpler development and grammar slips ('a pupil study', 'the modern world need', 'give advice to them about the choice'), plus mechanical transitions ('On the one hand... On the other hand').
Check your essay on this task
Task: Students should be allowed to choose which subjects they study at secondary school from an early age. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.