Some people believe that governments should decide how cities develop. Others think local residents should make these decisions. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Some people believe that governments should decide how cities develop. Others think local residents should…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Some people believe that governments should decide how cities develop. Others think local residents should make these decisions. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
City development is an important question for every country. Some people believe that the government should make the decisions about how cities grow, but others think that the local residents should decide. In this essay I will look at both views and give my opinion.
On the one hand, government has a lot of advantages in planning cities. Government officials and experts have a knowledge about the economy, transport and environment, so they can see the whole picture. For example, they know how many roads, schools and hospitals will be needed in the next twenty years. Also, if every district make its own plan, there will be a chaos and the city will have no clear direction. Another point is that the government has the money for big projects like metro lines or bridges, which ordinary people can not organise by themselves.
On the other hand, local residents know their area much better than the officials. They live there every day and understand what problems exist, for example where the traffic is dangerous or where a new park is needed. If the people take part in the decisions, they will be more satisfied and more ready to protect the new buildings. Moreover, the government sometimes make decisions which are good for the businessmen but bad for the residents, such as destroying old houses to build shopping centres. In such cases, the voice of the local people is very necessary.
In my opinion, the best way is cooperation between the two sides. The government should make the main plan, but it must ask the opinion of the residents by public meetings or online voting. In this way the plans will be realistic and the people will support them.
To sum up, both the government and the residents have an important role in development of the cities, and they should work together.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6 · LR 5.5 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 5.5: Everyday words dominate ('big', 'important', 'very necessary'), and several noun-use errors appear ('a knowledge', 'a chaos'). Some less common items, such as 'businessmen' and 'metro lines', are used correctly but the overall range is limited.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | Both views are presented with relevant points (expertise, funding and coordination against local knowledge and developers' interests) and the writer clearly favours cooperation, with public meetings or online voting. Support is general: 'they know how many roads, schools and hospitals will be needed' lacks illustration. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6 | Clear paragraphs and signposting ('On the one hand', 'On the other hand', 'In my opinion', 'To sum up') give a clear progression. Linkers such as 'Also' and 'Another point is that' feel formulaic, and the 'In this way' reference at the end is fairly vague. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5.5 | Everyday words dominate ('big', 'important', 'very necessary'), and several noun-use errors appear ('a knowledge', 'a chaos'). Some less common items, such as 'businessmen' and 'metro lines', are used correctly but the overall range is limited. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | Complex sentences with relative clauses and conditionals are attempted ('If the people take part in the decisions, they will be more satisfied'). Agreement slips such as 'every district make' appear, though the meaning remains clear. |
Marked mistakes
-
have a knowledge about
have knowledge of (LR)
'Knowledge' is uncountable and is normally followed by 'of'. -
every district make its own plan
every district makes its own plan (GA)
'Every district' is singular and needs 'makes'. -
there will be a chaos
there will be chaos (GA)
'Chaos' is uncountable and takes no article here. -
can not organise
cannot organise (LR)
'Cannot' is normally written as one word.
What would raise the band
Check subject-verb agreement and countable/uncountable nouns, since errors such as 'a chaos' and 'a knowledge' recur. Also add a specific example of consultation succeeding in a real city.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Some people believe that governments should decide how cities develop. Others think local residents should make these decisions. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Decisions about where to build housing, roads and parks shape residents' lives for decades, so the question of who makes them is significant. Some argue that central or municipal governments are best placed to guide urban growth, while others believe that residents should have the final say. I think the strongest outcomes arise when authorities lead strategic planning but are required to respond genuinely to local views.
The case for government control rests on scale and expertise. City growth involves interlocking systems, such as transport, drainage, energy and schools, which must be planned over wide areas and long periods. A neighbourhood deciding in isolation might block a new tram line that would benefit the entire region, simply because it dislikes the construction noise. Governments also have the borrowing power to fund large infrastructure and the legal means to coordinate land use, as Singapore's long-term planning has demonstrated.
Yet residents bring knowledge that officials in a distant office cannot easily obtain. They know which junction is dangerous for children, which green space is actually used and which shops sustain the local economy. Excluding them can lead to costly mistakes: the demolition of established communities for high-rise estates in many post-war cities produced social problems that took decades to repair. Moreover, people who feel involved in a project are more likely to accept its inconvenience and look after the result.
I therefore favour a model in which governments set the framework, covering overall density, transport corridors and environmental standards, while local people decide detailed matters such as street design, the location of play areas and the character of new buildings. Binding consultation, such as participatory budgeting schemes in Porto Alegre, shows that this is workable.
In conclusion, neither authorities nor residents alone can produce good urban planning. Combining professional oversight with real community participation yields cities that are both coherent and liveable.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8.5 · CC 8.5 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8.5: Both views are examined with well-chosen support: the tram line blocked by noise complaints, Singapore's long-term planning, post-war demolitions, and Porto Alegre. The position is clear: governments set the framework while residents decide the details. The Porto Alegre example is not perfectly matched to the claim.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8.5 | Both views are examined with well-chosen support: the tram line blocked by noise complaints, Singapore's long-term planning, post-war demolitions, and Porto Alegre. The position is clear: governments set the framework while residents decide the details. The Porto Alegre example is not perfectly matched to the claim. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | Smooth progression from 'The case for government control rests on scale and expertise' to 'Yet residents bring knowledge...' to 'I therefore favour a model...'. Cohesion is unobtrusive, and each paragraph has a clear central idea. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8.5 | Precise urban-planning vocabulary such as 'interlocking systems', 'borrowing power', 'participatory budgeting', 'density' and 'transport corridors' is used accurately and flexibly. Word choice is natural throughout. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | A wide range of structures appears: participial phrases, relative clauses, 'while' contrast, and the long sentence 'They know which junction is dangerous for children, which green space is actually used and which shops sustain the local economy'. Errors are very rare and punctuation is precise. |
Marked mistakes
-
Binding consultation, such as participatory budgeting schemes in Porto Alegre, shows that this is workable
Participatory budgeting in Porto Alegre, where residents vote on how part of the city budget is spent, shows that giving local people binding decisions is workable (TR)
Participatory budgeting concerns spending decisions rather than planning consultation, so the example only loosely supports the claim; a brief explanation of how it works would tie it to the point.
What would raise the band
Tie each example more explicitly to your claim, and check for ambiguity in the compressed sentences, to move toward Band 9.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay supports each view with concrete reasoning and examples (a neighbourhood blocking a tram line, Singapore's planning, post-war demolition of communities, participatory budgeting in Porto Alegre), and it specifies exactly what each party should decide. The 6.0 essay gives sensible but general arguments and a more generic 'cooperation' conclusion. The 6.0 text also has article and agreement errors such as 'a knowledge', 'there will be a chaos' and 'every district make'.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people believe that governments should decide how cities develop. Others think local residents should make these decisions. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.