Some people believe that older employees should be encouraged to retire to make room for younger workers. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 7
A real IELTS practice essay scored Band 7 by AI on the topic: Some people believe that older employees should be encouraged to retire to make room for younger workers. To w. Read it, then get your own essay graded.
Band 7.0
Prompt: Some people believe that older employees should be encouraged to retire to make room for younger workers. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Some people believe that older employees should be encouraged to retire to make room for younger workers. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Nowadays, there is an ongoing debate about whether older employees should be encouraged to retire so that younger people can have more job opportunities. Although I understand this point of view, I partly disagree with the idea because experienced workers still play an important role in the workplace.
On the one hand, encouraging older employees to retire can create more employment opportunities for young people. Many graduates struggle to find jobs because most positions are already occupied by experienced workers. If older employees retire, companies can hire younger individuals who have fresh ideas, modern knowledge and technological skills. Furthermore, young workers often bring energy, creativity and motivation to organisations. This can help businesses develop and become more competitive in the modern world.
On the other hand, I believe that older employees should not be forced or strongly encouraged to leave their jobs simply because of their age. They have many years of professional experience and valuable knowledge that younger workers may not possess. For example, senior employees can train new staff, solve difficult problems and share useful advice. Their experience can improve the overall quality of work and help companies avoid serious mistakes. In addition, some older people still have the ability and desire to work, and retiring early may negatively affect their financial situation and mental well-being.
In my opinion, the best solution is to create a balance between younger and older employees. Companies should provide equal employment opportunities for people of all ages. They can also introduce flexible working hours or part-time positions for older workers while offering training programmes and career opportunities for younger generations.
In conclusion, although the retirement of older employees may help young people find jobs, I do not believe that age should be the main reason for ending someone's career. Both generations can contribute significantly to society and the workplace.
Why Band 7, not 7.5
TR 7 · CC 7 · LR 6.5 · GRA 7
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 6.5: The vocabulary is adequate and generally appropriate for the topic. Some less common items appear (financial situation, mental well-being, competitive, flexible working hours), but the overall range is somewhat limited and relies on fairly common collocations. There is little evidence of sophisticated or precise word choices, and a few phrases are slightly imprecise or repetitive (e.g. 'younger workers' / 'young people' / 'younger individuals' used interchangeably without stylistic variation).
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 7 | The essay addresses all parts of the task with a clear, consistent position (partial disagreement). Both sides are explored and the writer's own view is maintained throughout. Main ideas are extended with relevant supporting points and a practical solution is proposed. However, some arguments remain slightly general and could benefit from deeper development or more specific real-world examples. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 7 | There is a clear and logical progression throughout the essay with well-organised paragraphs, each focused on a central idea. A range of cohesive devices is used (On the one hand / On the other hand / Furthermore / In addition / In conclusion), though their use is slightly formulaic and mechanical in places. Referencing and substitution are handled adequately. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6.5 | The vocabulary is adequate and generally appropriate for the topic. Some less common items appear (financial situation, mental well-being, competitive, flexible working hours), but the overall range is somewhat limited and relies on fairly common collocations. There is little evidence of sophisticated or precise word choices, and a few phrases are slightly imprecise or repetitive (e.g. 'younger workers' / 'young people' / 'younger individuals' used interchangeably without stylistic variation). |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 7 | A good variety of sentence structures is used, including complex sentences with subordinate clauses, relative clauses and conditional forms. The majority of sentences are error-free. There are a small number of minor issues (e.g. slightly awkward phrasing and a missing article), but these do not impede communication. Punctuation is well controlled throughout. |
Marked mistakes
-
most positions are already occupied by experienced workers
most positions are already held by experienced workers (LR)
In the context of jobs and roles, 'held' is the natural and precise collocation; 'occupied' is more commonly used for physical spaces. -
young workers often bring energy, creativity and motivation to organisations
young workers often bring energy, creativity and motivation to organisations — for instance, tech-savvy graduates have driven digital transformation in many industries (TR)
This claim is left as a generalisation without any concrete example or elaboration, which limits the depth of idea development required for a Band 7+ Task Response. -
On the one hand ... On the other hand
While encouraging older employees to retire can create opportunities for young people, there are compelling reasons why this approach is problematic. (CC)
Using 'On the one hand / On the other hand' as the sole structural device for body paragraphs is mechanical and formulaic; varying the linking strategy would demonstrate a wider range of cohesive tools. -
younger workers ... young people ... younger individuals ... younger generations
the younger workforce ... young graduates ... new entrants to the labour market ... the next generation of professionals (LR)
The same concept is referred to with only minor surface variation; using more distinct and precise synonyms would demonstrate a wider lexical range. -
retiring early may negatively affect their financial situation and mental well-being
retiring early may negatively affect their financial situation and their mental well-being (GA)
Adding the possessive determiner 'their' before 'mental well-being' creates a more balanced and grammatically parallel structure in this list.
What would raise the band
Focus on deepening your argument development by supporting each claim with a specific, concrete example or piece of evidence — this is the single most effective way to push from Band 7 to Band 7.5–8 in Task Response and Lexical Resource simultaneously.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people believe that older employees should be encouraged to retire to make room for younger workers. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.