Some people believe that tourism helps to protect historical sites. Others think it damages them. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people believe that tourism helps to protect historical sites. Others think it damages them. Discuss…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: Some people believe that tourism helps to protect historical sites. Others think it damages them. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Historical sites like old castles and temples attract millions of visitors every year. Some people say that tourism helps to protect these places, but others believe that it damages them. In my opinion, tourism has both effects, but the damage can be controlled.
Firstly, I will explain why tourism can be helpful. Tourists pay for tickets, and this money is often used for restoration and cleaning of the monuments. For example, the entrance fees of the Colosseum in Rome are used to repair the walls. Without this income, the government could not afford to keep many historical places. Also, when a site is popular, the local people understand that it is valuable and they start to care about it more. Tourism also creates jobs, such as guides and sellers of souvenirs, so the community has a reason to protect the heritage.
However, there are serious problems too. When too many people visit a site, the buildings can be damaged by touching, walking and taking photographs with flash. Some visitors even write their names on the walls or take small pieces of stone as souvenir. In addition, big crowds make a lot of pollution and rubbish. A good example is Machu Picchu in Peru, where the government had to limit the number of tourists because the stairs and paths were destroying.
I think that tourism is useful if the government manage it carefully. They can set a maximum number of visitors per day, build special paths and train guides to explain the rules to the tourists. Also, ticket prices can be higher in the high season. In this way, the sites will have money for protection and will not be damaged by crowds.
To conclude, tourism is both a danger and a benefit for historical sites. The result depends on how well the authorities control it.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The vocabulary fits the topic ('restoration', 'heritage', 'maximum number of visitors') but is limited and sometimes imprecise. 'make a lot of pollution and rubbish' and 'as souvenir' show collocation and form problems that do not block meaning.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | Both views are discussed and the position that 'tourism has both effects, but the damage can be controlled' is clear and returns in the fourth paragraph. The examples are relevant, the Colosseum entrance fees and Machu Picchu's visitor limit, but they are stated briefly and the Colosseum claim is not explained further. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | The structure is clear: benefits, problems, solutions, conclusion. The linkers 'Firstly', 'However', 'In addition' and 'In this way' are correct but somewhat predictable, and 'Firstly, I will explain' is a mechanical signpost with no 'Secondly' to follow it. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The vocabulary fits the topic ('restoration', 'heritage', 'maximum number of visitors') but is limited and sometimes imprecise. 'make a lot of pollution and rubbish' and 'as souvenir' show collocation and form problems that do not block meaning. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | A mix of complex sentences with 'when', 'because' and 'if' is used, but errors occur, most clearly the active 'were destroying' where a passive is needed. The punctuation is generally accurate. |
Marked mistakes
-
the stairs and paths were destroying
the stairs and paths were being destroyed (GA)
The meaning is passive, so 'were being destroyed' or 'were being worn away' is needed. -
take small pieces of stone as souvenir
take small pieces of stone as souvenirs (LR)
'Souvenir' is countable and should be plural here. -
big crowds make a lot of pollution and rubbish
large crowds create a lot of pollution and litter (LR)
'Create' pollution and 'litter' are the natural choices.
What would raise the band
Proofread for passive forms and noun endings, since these errors are holding your grammar score at 6. Also explain your examples in a sentence rather than only naming them, for example how Machu Picchu's limit worked.
Band 8.0
Prompt: Some people believe that tourism helps to protect historical sites. Others think it damages them. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Historic monuments are among the world's most visited attractions, and opinions differ on whether this popularity preserves them or wears them down. I would argue that tourism is a necessary source of funding for conservation, but that its benefits are realised only when visitor numbers are managed.
The positive case is mainly financial. Maintaining ancient buildings is costly, since stone must be cleaned, roofs repaired and structures monitored for subsidence, and many governments have little money to spare for this. Entrance fees and related income can therefore be decisive. Pompeii, for example, relies largely on ticket revenue to fund restoration work across a site covering more than sixty hectares. Tourism can also change local attitudes: when residents see that a ruin brings income to their neighbourhood, they have a practical reason to protect it rather than build over it.
Yet the physical consequences of large crowds are well documented. Millions of footsteps wear down stone floors, humidity from breathing and sweat can damage painted surfaces, and some visitors touch or even remove parts of monuments. The tomb paintings at Lascaux in France were so affected by visitors that the original cave was closed in the 1960s and replaced with a replica. Tourist infrastructure such as hotels and car parks can also spoil the setting of a site and increase air pollution around it.
These risks do not mean that visitors should be turned away, but they do justify limits. Timed tickets, daily caps and higher prices at peak times reduce crowding while increasing the income per visitor. Replicas or virtual tours can take pressure off the most fragile sites, and part of every ticket should be legally earmarked for conservation rather than general government spending.
In conclusion, tourism both finances and endangers historical sites, and whether it protects them depends on the willingness of authorities to regulate visitor numbers.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource at 8: The opening takes a clear position that tourism is 'a necessary source of funding' only when numbers are 'managed', and both views are fully developed. The Pompeii funding and the Lascaux replica show strong, specific support, and the fourth paragraph proposes concrete measures.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The opening takes a clear position that tourism is 'a necessary source of funding' only when numbers are 'managed', and both views are fully developed. The Pompeii funding and the Lascaux replica show strong, specific support, and the fourth paragraph proposes concrete measures. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | The progression from funding to physical damage to regulation is logical, and each paragraph begins with a clear topic sentence ('The positive case is mainly financial', 'Yet the physical consequences...'). Cohesion relies on reference and lexical links, such as 'These risks do not mean...', rather than on visible linking words. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | The vocabulary is wide and exact: 'subsidence', 'earmarked for conservation', 'peak times', 'spoil the setting'. Collocations are natural and there are no spelling or word-form errors. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | The essay uses varied complex structures, including a 'since' clause with a list, a participial construction and passive forms ('so affected by visitors'), almost all error-free. Punctuation is controlled throughout. |
What would raise the band
To move towards a 9, give every point the same level of evidence, for example one example for the infrastructure claim. Add a brief concession to counter-arguments, such as the cost of replicas.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 essay supports both sides with precise, relevant examples (Pompeii ticket revenue, Lascaux closure) and ends with specific management measures such as timed tickets and ring-fenced income. The 6.5 essay uses more familiar examples with less detail and its solution is more general. Accuracy also differs: the 6.5 text has errors such as 'the stairs and paths were destroying' and 'as souvenir', while the 8.0 text has precise vocabulary like 'earmarked for conservation' and 'subsidence'.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people believe that tourism helps to protect historical sites. Others think it damages them. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.