Some people prefer to work for a large company, while others prefer to work for a small business. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people prefer to work for a large company, while others prefer to work for a small business. Discuss…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Some people prefer to work for a large company, while others prefer to work for a small business. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Choosing a workplace is an important decision in life. Some people want to work for a large company, but others think that a small business is better for them. I will discuss both sides and explain which one I prefer.
Firstly, large companies usually offer more security and higher salary. Employees get a fixed contract, health insurance and often a pension, so they do not need to worry about the future very much. Also, a big company has many departments, so a worker can change his position inside the same company and make a career step by step. For example, my cousin started in the call centre of a bank and now she is a manager in the marketing department.
However, small businesses have their own advantages. In a small team everybody know each other, so the atmosphere is more friendly and the communication is quicker. Moreover, an employee can do many different tasks and learn a lot of skills very fast, because there are not enough people to do everything. In a large company, in contrast, people sometimes do the same boring job for years and feel like a small part of a machine. Their opinion is rarely listened by the managers.
Personally, I think that a large company is better for young graduates who have no experience. They can learn from professional colleagues, attend trainings and put the name of a famous company in their CV, which is very useful for the future job search. But later, when a person have enough experience, he can move to a small business and have more freedom and responsibility.
To conclude, both kinds of workplace are good in different situations. In my opinion, it depends on the age and the personality of the worker, but I would recommend starting in a big company.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6 · CC 6.5 · LR 5.5 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: The writer has enough words for the topic ('fixed contract', 'pension', 'departments') but relies on basic items like 'good', 'important' and 'learn a lot'. Collocation slips such as 'make a career step by step' and 'put the name ... in their CV' show that less common phrasing is attempted with some inaccuracy.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6 | Both views are discussed and the writer states that a large company suits graduates and a small one suits experienced workers, which is a relevant position. The support is mostly personal and simple, such as the cousin who 'started in the call centre of a bank', and claims about friendly atmosphere or higher salary are not explained further. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | Paragraphs are clearly organised, with one for each view, a personal opinion and a conclusion. Linkers such as 'Firstly', 'Moreover', 'in contrast' and 'But later' make the progression easy to follow, though they are somewhat predictable and 'step by step' is only loosely connected to the argument. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5.5 | The writer has enough words for the topic ('fixed contract', 'pension', 'departments') but relies on basic items like 'good', 'important' and 'learn a lot'. Collocation slips such as 'make a career step by step' and 'put the name ... in their CV' show that less common phrasing is attempted with some inaccuracy. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | Complex sentences with 'because', 'so' and 'when' appear regularly, giving a reasonable range. Errors in agreement ('everybody know', 'a person have'), a faulty passive ('is rarely listened by') and a misplaced preposition appear often enough to be distracting, but the message is clear. |
Marked mistakes
-
In a small team everybody know each other
In a small team everybody knows each other (GA)
'Everybody' is singular and takes 'knows'. -
Their opinion is rarely listened by the managers.
Managers rarely listen to their opinions. (GA)
'Listen' is intransitive and cannot be made passive this way; use the active form or 'is rarely listened to'. -
when a person have enough experience
when a person has enough experience (GA)
The singular subject 'a person' requires 'has'. -
make a career step by step
advance in their career step by step (LR)
'Make a career' is not natural; 'advance' or 'progress' fits the idea of gradual promotion. -
put the name of a famous company in their CV
put the name of a famous company on their CV (LR)
The correct preposition with CV is 'on'.
What would raise the band
Work on verb agreement and passive forms. Reread each sentence and underline the subject ('everybody', 'a person') before checking the verb, and replace 'is rarely listened by' with an active structure. Add one precise example for the small-business side, as you did for the large company.
Band 8.0
Prompt: Some people prefer to work for a large company, while others prefer to work for a small business. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
People's preferences about where to work often reflect what they value at different stages of life. While large corporations appeal to those who want stability and structure, small firms attract people seeking variety and influence. In my view, neither is universally superior, although small businesses suit ambitious people better in the long run.
Large employers do have clear strengths. They can afford formal training schemes, clear promotion ladders and benefits such as private health cover, which smaller firms often cannot match. Working alongside specialists in a mature organisation also lets a newcomer learn recognised professional standards. A graduate who spends two years at an international bank, for instance, gains a credential that opens doors elsewhere. Pay is typically higher too, which matters to those with a mortgage or young children.
On the other hand, the same size that creates security can limit individual impact. In a company of 20,000 people, a junior employee's idea must pass through several layers of approval, and many workers perform a narrow task without seeing how it affects the final product. Small businesses offer the opposite experience. A designer at a ten-person start-up may speak directly to clients, help set prices and see the result of a decision within days. This breadth builds the kind of judgement that is difficult to acquire in a large hierarchy. The trade-off is less job security, since a single lost contract can threaten the whole firm.
Weighing these points, I would recommend large companies for early career years, when learning from established systems is most valuable, and small businesses for people who already have skills and want autonomy. That said, anyone who is naturally entrepreneurial may find the smaller setting more rewarding from the start.
Overall, the choice depends on whether a person prioritises security or influence. Since these priorities change over time, many people will reasonably experience both types of employer during their working lives.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8 · GRA 8
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: All parts are covered in depth, with vivid and specific illustrations: 'a designer at a ten-person start-up may speak directly to clients' and 'a company of 20,000 people' give each side real substance. The position is slightly blurred, though, because the introduction favours small firms 'in the long run' while the conclusion advises large companies for early career years.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | All parts are covered in depth, with vivid and specific illustrations: 'a designer at a ten-person start-up may speak directly to clients' and 'a company of 20,000 people' give each side real substance. The position is slightly blurred, though, because the introduction favours small firms 'in the long run' while the conclusion advises large companies for early career years. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | Progression is smooth, from large-firm strengths to the 'other hand' paragraph and then a recommendation. 'Small businesses offer the opposite experience' and 'This breadth builds' are examples of referencing that carries the argument forward without any mechanical linkers. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | Word choice is flexible and exact: 'promotion ladders', 'private health cover', 'credential that opens doors' and 'the trade-off' show strong command of workplace collocations. Spelling is accurate, and there are no word-form errors worth noting. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8 | A broad variety of structures is controlled well, such as the concessive 'While large corporations appeal ... small firms attract' and the relative 'which smaller firms often cannot match'. Almost all sentences are error-free with accurate punctuation. |
Marked mistakes
-
small businesses suit ambitious people better in the long run
small businesses suit people who already have skills better in the long run (TR)
The introduction makes a broader claim than the later recommendation, so the position reads as slightly inconsistent.
What would raise the band
Make your thesis match your final recommendation: say in the introduction that large firms suit the start of a career and small ones suit later stages. That small alignment would remove the only tension in the argument.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 essay develops each side with a specific mechanism (formal training and credentials versus approval layers that dilute a junior's impact, plus the security trade-off in small firms) and gives a nuanced opinion tied to career stage with a stated exception. The 6.0 essay reaches a similar conclusion but supports it with a personal anecdote and general phrases such as 'a small part of a machine' and 'the atmosphere is more friendly'. The higher-scoring text also shows more flexible grammar and precise collocations, while the 6.0 text has errors such as 'everybody know', 'listened by the managers' and 'a person have'.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people prefer to work for a large company, while others prefer to work for a small business. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.