IELTS Task 2: Older managers — Band 6 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people think that managers should always be older and more experienced. Others believe young people make better leaders. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that managers should always be older and more experienced. Others believe young people…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Some people think that managers should always be older and more experienced. Others believe young people make better leaders. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Some people say that managers must be older people with a lot of experience, but other people think that young people can be better leaders. In this essay I will discuss both opinions and then say what I think.

On the one hand, older managers have many years of working experience. They have seen different situations in the past, so they know how to solve problems and avoid the mistakes. For example, if a company has a financial crisis, a manager who already passed through a crisis before will be calmer and take better decisions. Furthermore, employees often respect older people more, so they follow their instructions without arguing. Age also gives patience, which is very essential for dealing with workers who have different characters.

On the other hand, young managers have some advantages too. They are usually more energetic and not afraid of changes, so they can bring new ideas to the company. Nowadays technology develops very quickly and young people understand it better than older generation. For instance, a young manager can easily use social media for advertising or introduce a new software, while an older manager may refuse to do it because he is used to the old methods. Also, young leaders are closer to the age of their team and it is easier for them to motivate the workers.

In my opinion, age is not the most important thing. A good manager must have skills such as communication, honesty and responsibility, and these qualities do not depend on age. Some young people are very mature and some old people are not good leaders at all. Companies should choose managers by their results and abilities.

To sum up, both older and younger people can be successful leaders. I think that the best solution is to create a team where managers of different ages work together and share their knowledge.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6 · CC 6 · LR 5.5 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 5.5: Adequate range for the topic is shown with 'financial crisis', 'energetic' and 'motivate', and 'not afraid of changes' attempts a less common phrase. Misused or inaccurate items such as 'very essential' and 'avoid the mistakes' appear, but do not block meaning.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6 Both views are covered and the opinion that 'age is not the most important thing' is clear and well linked to skills such as communication and honesty. Support is mainly generic; 'Age also gives patience' and 'employees often respect older people more' are not backed by examples.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6 The essay is organised clearly into an introduction, one paragraph for each side, an opinion and a conclusion, with 'On the one hand', 'Furthermore', 'Also' and 'For instance' showing progression. Cohesive devices are common but predictable, and the 'For instance' examples are a little detached from the preceding sentence.
Lexical Resource Band 5.5 Adequate range for the topic is shown with 'financial crisis', 'energetic' and 'motivate', and 'not afraid of changes' attempts a less common phrase. Misused or inaccurate items such as 'very essential' and 'avoid the mistakes' appear, but do not block meaning.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 The writing mixes simple and complex sentences, including 'while' clauses and 'who already passed' relative clauses. Errors affect verb tense and form ('who already passed through', 'introduce a new software') and article use, but they rarely reduce communication.

Marked mistakes

  1. avoid the mistakes
    avoid mistakes (LR)
    General statements normally take no article.
  2. which is very essential for dealing with workers
    which is essential for dealing with workers (LR)
    'Essential' is already absolute and cannot be modified with 'very'.
  3. a manager who already passed through a crisis before will be calmer
    a manager who has already been through a crisis will be calmer (GA)
    The present perfect is needed for earlier experience that matters now.
  4. understand it better than older generation
    understand it better than the older generation (GA)
    The definite article is needed before 'older generation'.
  5. introduce a new software
    introduce new software (GA)
    'Software' is uncountable and cannot take 'a'.

What would raise the band

Make examples more precise and fix word-level errors: use 'essential' rather than 'very essential', and treat 'software' as uncountable. A careful check of articles ('the older generation', 'avoid mistakes') would improve both Lexical Resource and Grammar.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Some people think that managers should always be older and more experienced. Others believe young people make better leaders. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Leadership is traditionally associated with seniority, yet many modern companies are promoting people in their late twenties to management roles. Both approaches have merit. I believe that experience is valuable, but it should not be treated as a requirement, since leadership ability depends more on temperament and skill than on years served.

The argument for older managers rests on accumulated judgement. Someone who has worked through two or three economic downturns has learned which warning signs to look for and how to keep a team calm when budgets are cut. Such managers also tend to have broad professional networks, which can help secure suppliers, clients or talent. Moreover, staff in some cultures defer more readily to a leader who is visibly more experienced, which can reduce friction in decision-making.

Younger leaders, however, bring strengths that are harder to find in established executives. They are often more comfortable with digital tools and fast-changing markets; a thirty-year-old product manager at a software firm, for instance, will probably understand how customers actually use an app better than a sixty-year-old director who has never used it. Younger managers may also be more open to feedback and willing to question inherited routines, and their closeness in age to most staff can make it easier to build trust and gather honest opinions.

In my view, companies should appoint managers according to demonstrated results, communication ability and willingness to learn. A capable young person who has led a successful project deserves the opportunity just as much as a veteran. The ideal arrangement is a leadership team that combines both groups, so that the caution of experience balances the energy of youth.

To conclude, neither age group has a monopoly on good management. Selecting leaders on merit and pairing different generations produces better decisions than any fixed rule about age.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8 · GRA 8

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: The essay fully addresses both views and the position ('experience is valuable, but it should not be treated as a requirement') is stated at the start and held to the end. Ideas are well extended, as in the 'two or three economic downturns' example, though the thirty-year-old product manager sketch leans on a stereotype.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The essay fully addresses both views and the position ('experience is valuable, but it should not be treated as a requirement') is stated at the start and held to the end. Ideas are well extended, as in the 'two or three economic downturns' example, though the thirty-year-old product manager sketch leans on a stereotype.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8.5 Sequencing is skilful, with each paragraph opening with a clear topic sentence ('The argument for older managers rests on accumulated judgement', 'Younger leaders, however, bring strengths'). Cohesion is effortless, using 'Moreover', 'also' and 'so that' without drawing attention, and the conclusion avoids repetition.
Lexical Resource Band 8 The essay uses a wide, natural range: 'accumulated judgement', 'defer more readily', 'inherited routines', 'a monopoly on good management' are precise and idiomatic. There are only rare slight overstatements and no spelling or word-form errors.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8 Complex structures such as the relative 'Someone who has worked through ...' and the long noun-phrase subject in 'their closeness in age to most staff can make it easier' are controlled very well. The overwhelming majority of sentences are error-free and punctuated accurately.

Marked mistakes

  1. a sixty-year-old director who has never used it
    an older director who has never used it (TR)
    The specific figure and the assumption that a senior person has never used an app reads as a stereotype rather than a supported point.

What would raise the band

Watch for slightly sweeping claims about whole age groups. Adding a qualifier ('some', 'often') or one real-world case would give the younger-leaders paragraph the same authority as the older-managers paragraph.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 answer gives each side one developed, concrete argument (surviving downturns and professional networks versus digital fluency and openness to feedback) and states a precise position about merit-based appointment with mixed-age teams. The 6.0 answer makes the same broad conclusion but its supporting points are more general ('more energetic', 'respect older people') and partly repeat each other. Vocabulary and grammar are also more accurate in the 8.0 text, while the 6.0 text includes slips like 'very essential', 'avoid the mistakes' and 'passed through a crisis before will be calmer'.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people think that managers should always be older and more experienced. Others believe young people make better leaders. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →