The best way to make society happier is to ensure that the richest and poorest people have the smallest differences in earnings. To what extent do you agree or disagree? Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Band 5.5
A real IELTS practice essay scored Band 5.5 by AI on the topic: The best way to make society happier is to ensure that the richest and poorest people have the smallest differ. Read it, then get your own essay graded.
Band 5.5
Prompt: The best way to make society happier is to ensure that the richest and poorest people have the smallest differences in earnings. To what extent do you agree or disagree? Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Ensuring that the richest and poorest people have the smallest differences in earnings have been considered as the best way to make society happier by some people. However, from my prospective, it may be not a reasonable method not only beacause of the unfair causing to the society structure, but also it will bring a huge stress for the companies and the governments which may make society go worse instead of happier. First of all, the unfairness that ensure the richest and poorest people have the smallest differences in earnings will enlarge social conflicts which may not make society happier. For instance, if the poorest people can have the same earnings with the richest people without paying any effort, this may break down the social structure instead of making societ happier. In addition, society will be full of stress because paying the richest and poorest people in earnings that have the smallest differences can cause a huge outcome in people's wage that no companies or governments can afford. If everyone have the same earnings in a high level, companies have to reduce the headcount to control the cost of wage which will cause the reduce of the quantity of the jobs in the society. On the other hand, government need more income to bridge the payment gap between the rich and the poor, which will cause the increase of the tax need. These consequences can't make society happier but enlarge the stree of society. Although paying everyone with little difference may bridge up the gap between the richest people and the poorest people, it is not always a realistic method that can be used in nowaday's society. Instead,it is a tryable way to provide more multiple opportunities which not only face to the rich, but also the poor can have a try. For example, offering the same opportunities of education so that everyone can get a chance to improve their payment when they grow up. In this way, the society will be happier and fairer. In conclusion, it is not the best way to make society happier that pay the richest people and poorest people the smallest differences in their earnings.
Why Band 5.5, not 6
TR 6 · CC 5 · LR 5 · GRA 5
The weakest criterion is Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5: There is a recognisable four-paragraph structure with an introduction and conclusion, which shows basic organisation. However, cohesive devices are limited and sometimes mechanical ('First of all', 'In addition', 'On the other hand'). The first body paragraph lacks clear progression and circles back on itself. The concession paragraph feels disconnected from the rest of the argument. Referencing is occasionally unclear.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6 | The student takes a clear position (disagreement) and addresses the prompt throughout. Two main reasons are offered (unfairness and financial stress) and a counter-argument with an alternative is briefly included. However, ideas are underdeveloped and sometimes repetitive — the 'unfairness' paragraph essentially restates the same point without real extension. The alternative solution (equal education opportunities) is introduced too late and too briefly to be well-supported. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 5 | There is a recognisable four-paragraph structure with an introduction and conclusion, which shows basic organisation. However, cohesive devices are limited and sometimes mechanical ('First of all', 'In addition', 'On the other hand'). The first body paragraph lacks clear progression and circles back on itself. The concession paragraph feels disconnected from the rest of the argument. Referencing is occasionally unclear. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5 | The vocabulary range is limited and repetitive — phrases like 'make society happier', 'richest and poorest people', and 'smallest differences in earnings' are copied from the prompt and recycled throughout. Attempts at less common vocabulary are inaccurate ('prospective' for 'perspective', 'tryable', 'face to'). Spelling errors ('beacause', 'societ', 'stree') and awkward word forms are present throughout. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5 | There is some variety in sentence structure, including attempts at complex sentences with subordinate clauses and relative clauses. However, errors are frequent and sometimes impede communication. Subject-verb agreement errors are consistent ('have been considered' used correctly but 'everyone have', 'government need'), and there are issues with article use, prepositions, and awkward constructions throughout. |
Marked mistakes
-
from my prospective
from my perspective (LR)
'Prospective' means 'expected in the future', whereas 'perspective' means 'point of view' — these are completely different words and using the wrong one changes the meaning entirely. -
If everyone have the same earnings
If everyone has the same earnings (GA)
'Everyone' is a singular indefinite pronoun and must take a singular verb ('has'), not the plural form 'have'. -
it is a tryable way
it is a viable / feasible alternative (LR)
'Tryable' is not a standard English word; 'viable' or 'feasible' are the correct and precise academic alternatives here. -
opportunities which not only face to the rich
opportunities that are not only available to the rich (GA)
In English, 'face to' is not used to mean 'directed at' or 'available to'; the correct phrasing is 'available to' or 'accessible to'. -
beacause of the unfair causing to the society structure
because of the unfairness it causes to the social structure (LR)
'Beacause' is a misspelling of 'because', and 'unfair causing' is not grammatically correct — 'unfairness it causes' is the proper noun-phrase construction.
What would raise the band
Focus on vocabulary development as the single highest-impact improvement: stop copying phrases directly from the question prompt and instead paraphrase them using your own words (e.g. replace 'make society happier' with 'enhance social well-being' or 'foster a more content society'), and eliminate non-standard words like 'tryable' and 'prospective' by building a bank of precise academic synonyms before your exam.
Check your essay on this task
Task: The best way to make society happier is to ensure that the richest and poorest people have the smallest differences in earnings. To what extent do you agree or disagree? Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.