IELTS Task 2: Gender equality at work — Band 6.5 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Companies should be legally required to employ equal numbers of men and women at all levels. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Companies should be legally required to employ equal numbers of men and women at all levels. To what…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: Companies should be legally required to employ equal numbers of men and women at all levels. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Some people think that companies must be forced by law to employ the same number of men and women at every level. I disagree with this idea, because I think it is unfair and it can cause many problems, although the problem of inequality is real.

Firstly, the most important thing in recruiting is skill and experience, not gender. If a company has to take equal numbers, it might reject a better candidate only because of his or her sex. For example, in a building company there are usually more male engineers, because fewer women study this subject. The company will have to hire women who are less qualified, and the quality of work may become worse. This is also unfair for the men who applied and deserve the job.

Secondly, the law can not solve the real reasons of inequality. Women are often under-represented at the top levels because of family duties, traditional attitudes or lack of opportunities in education. Forcing the companies to follow quotas does not change these reasons. Moreover, women who get a job in this way may be not respected by their colleagues who think she got the position only because of the law.

On the other hand, I agree that there is discrimination in many workplaces and women usually earn less than men for the same work. Governments should do something about this. For instance, they can offer childcare, flexible hours and training programmes, so that more women can develop their careers. The companies who show a good result could receive tax benefits.

In conclusion, I do not think that a law about equal numbers is a good solution. It is better to make equal opportunities for everybody and let the companies choose the best candidates.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The vocabulary suits the topic (quotas, discrimination, flexible hours, tax benefits) and is accurate enough to be understood. It is not very flexible, and phrases like make equal opportunities and the real reasons of inequality are inexact.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The essay clearly opposes a legal requirement for equal numbers and supports this with the argument about better candidates being rejected and the building company example. It also considers the causes of inequality and offers alternatives, but the point about quotas making colleagues disrespect women is only briefly developed and the engineering example slightly overgeneralises.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The writer moves logically from the first argument to the second, then a concession and an alternative, with a clear conclusion. Connectors such as Firstly, Secondly, Moreover and On the other hand are used correctly but quite predictably, and the shift to government solutions in the fourth paragraph is introduced a little abruptly.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The vocabulary suits the topic (quotas, discrimination, flexible hours, tax benefits) and is accurate enough to be understood. It is not very flexible, and phrases like make equal opportunities and the real reasons of inequality are inexact.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 There is a satisfactory mix of simple sentences and subordinate clauses (because, who, so that). Several errors, including modal forms, articles and pronoun agreement (women ... she), appear across the essay, but they rarely make the meaning unclear.

Marked mistakes

  1. the law can not solve the real reasons of inequality
    the law cannot solve the real causes of inequality (GA)
    Cannot is written as one word, and causes of is the usual collocation.
  2. may be not respected by their colleagues
    may not be respected by their colleagues (GA)
    The negative is placed after the modal, before be.
  3. women who get a job in this way may be not respected by their colleagues who think she got the position
    women who get a job in this way may not be respected by colleagues who think they got the position (GA)
    The plural women requires the plural pronoun they.
  4. The companies who show a good result
    Companies that show good results (GA)
    'That' is the more usual relative pronoun for companies, no article is needed for companies in general, and 'good results' is the natural plural.
  5. It is better to make equal opportunities for everybody
    It is better to create equal opportunities for everybody (LR)
    Opportunities are created or provided, not made.

What would raise the band

Edit your essay slowly for modal and pronoun errors (can not, may be not, she got) and replace general words like problems and reasons with more precise terms such as barriers and causes.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Companies should be legally required to employ equal numbers of men and women at all levels. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

I disagree that companies should be legally obliged to employ equal numbers of men and women at every level, although I do believe that firms and governments have a responsibility to remove the obstacles that hold women back.

The main flaw in a strict rule is that it takes no account of the pool from which employers recruit. Women make up a large majority of nursing graduates and men dominate engineering degrees, so a hospital and a construction firm would both struggle to comply without turning away well-qualified applicants or leaving posts vacant. A requirement applied at all levels is more impractical still, since it would force companies to demote or reject people simply to balance a chart. Such rigid rules could also damage the very people they aim to help: women promoted under a quota may find that colleagues question their competence, regardless of their real record.

Nor does a quota address the causes of unequal representation. Women are often absent from senior roles because career breaks for childcare are penalised, because they are less likely to be mentored, or because recruiters make biased judgments in the selection process. These problems lie upstream of the hiring decision, and changing the headcount without tackling them treats a symptom rather than a cause.

There is, however, some evidence that legal intervention can work in limited form. Norway required listed companies to have at least 40 per cent of each gender on their boards, and the number of women directors rose sharply without any evident damage to company performance. This suggests that targets for senior positions in large organisations can be justified, even if they are not suitable for every workplace.

On balance, I would support transparent reporting of pay and promotion data, shared parental leave and affordable childcare, along with targets for boardrooms, rather than a legal requirement for strict equality at all levels.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: The position is clearly stated, with a sensible nuance that firms and governments should still remove obstacles for women. The pool-of-graduates argument and the Norway example are well developed, though the final recommendation of boardroom targets sits slightly uneasily with the opening rejection of legally required equal numbers.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The position is clearly stated, with a sensible nuance that firms and governments should still remove obstacles for women. The pool-of-graduates argument and the Norway example are well developed, though the final recommendation of boardroom targets sits slightly uneasily with the opening rejection of legally required equal numbers.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Each paragraph has its own focus: recruitment pool, causes of inequality, limited legal intervention and a recommendation. Cohesion relies on meaning and well-chosen references such as These problems lie upstream and This suggests, though the paragraph on Norway could be linked more explicitly to the thesis.
Lexical Resource Band 8.5 The language is precise and flexible, with items such as the pool from which employers recruit, treats a symptom rather than a cause and transparent reporting of pay. Spelling and word forms are accurate throughout.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8 A wide range of structures is used, including concessive clauses, relative clauses and participle phrases, and nearly every sentence is accurate. A few long sentences would benefit from clearer punctuation.

What would raise the band

Make the conclusion match your thesis more closely by saying that you reject quotas for all levels but accept targets for boardrooms, so the position is perfectly consistent.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 answer shows precisely why the rule is unworkable (nursing versus engineering pipelines, demotion to balance a chart) and distinguishes causes from symptoms, while the 6.5 answer states that the law "can not solve the real reasons" with little elaboration. The 8.0 text also concedes the Norway board example and proposes specific alternatives, which shows a nuanced position. The 6.5 text has errors such as "can not solve", "may be not respected" and "real reasons of inequality".

Check your essay on this task

Task: Companies should be legally required to employ equal numbers of men and women at all levels. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →