IELTS Task 2: Competitive school sports — Band 6.5 vs 8.5 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Competitive sports at school do more harm than good because they discourage children who are not athletic. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Competitive sports at school do more harm than good because they discourage children who are not athletic.…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: Competitive sports at school do more harm than good because they discourage children who are not athletic. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Sport is part of the school programme in almost every country. Some people argue that competition in sport is harmful because children who are not athletic feel bad. I disagree with this opinion, as I think competitive sports give more benefits than problems if they are organised in a right way.

It is true that some children are discouraged by competition. A child who is always chosen last for the team or who loses every race can feel ashamed in front of classmates. This may lead to low self-esteem and then the child will avoid doing any exercise, even when he is adult. For example, my cousin was overweight at school and the teacher used to laugh when he could not run fast, so now he hate sport completely.

However, I believe that the advantages are bigger. Firstly, competition teaches children important life skills. They learn how to work in a team, how to follow rules and how to accept losing. These lessons are very useful because in real life people do not always win, for example when they apply for a job. Secondly, sport is good for health. Nowadays children spend many hours with phones and computers, so school sport is often the only physical activity they have. Competition makes them more motivated to train and to improve.

Furthermore, the problem of discouraged students can be solved by teachers. Schools can organise different kind of activities, such as swimming, dance or running, so that every child can find something he is good at. Teachers should also praise effort and not only the results, and they should not make the weaker students feel embarrassed.

In conclusion, competitive sport can be harmful for some pupils if teachers manage it badly, but in general it is useful for development, so I disagree that it does more harm than good.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The vocabulary is adequate and clear ('low self-esteem', 'ashamed in front of classmates', 'motivated to train'), but it rarely goes beyond common words. Several slips in collocation and word form appear: 'in a right way', 'different kind of activities' and 'even when he is adult'. These do not impede meaning but cap the band.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The essay takes a clear position (disagree, with the condition 'if they are organised in a right way') and covers both the discouragement argument and the benefits. The cousin example is personal and brief, and the claim that school sport is 'often the only physical activity they have' is asserted rather than supported. The solution paragraph about swimming, dance or running is relevant but stays general.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 Progression is clear: concession paragraph, two numbered advantages, then a solution paragraph. Linkers such as 'Firstly', 'Secondly', 'Furthermore' and 'However' are accurate but fairly predictable, and 'This may lead to low self-esteem and then the child will avoid' is loosely chained. Paragraphing is sound with one idea per paragraph.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The vocabulary is adequate and clear ('low self-esteem', 'ashamed in front of classmates', 'motivated to train'), but it rarely goes beyond common words. Several slips in collocation and word form appear: 'in a right way', 'different kind of activities' and 'even when he is adult'. These do not impede meaning but cap the band.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 The writer mixes simple and complex sentences, including 'so that every child can find something he is good at' and conditional clauses. Accuracy is the weak point: 'now he hate sport completely' has subject-verb disagreement, and article and number errors recur. Punctuation is generally correct.

Marked mistakes

  1. if they are organised in a right way
    if they are organised in the right way (LR)
    'The right way' is the fixed collocation; 'a right way' sounds unnatural.
  2. so now he hate sport completely
    so now he hates sport completely (GA)
    The third-person singular subject 'he' requires 'hates'.
  3. even when he is adult
    even when he is an adult (GA)
    'Adult' as a noun needs the article 'an'; 'even as an adult' is more natural.
  4. different kind of activities
    different kinds of activities (GA)
    'Different' with a plural noun phrase needs the plural 'kinds'.
  5. school sport is often the only physical activity they have
    school sport is, for many of them, one of the few regular physical activities they have (TR)
    The absolute claim is not backed up, and softening it makes the argument more credible.

What would raise the band

Replace general assertions such as 'children spend many hours with phones and computers' with one concrete, extended example, and drill third-person -s and article use, which are your most frequent slips.

Band 8.5

Prompt: Competitive sports at school do more harm than good because they discourage children who are not athletic. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Competitive sport divides opinion in education. Critics claim it alienates children who lack natural ability; supporters point to the discipline and fitness it builds. I largely disagree with the statement, since the harm described is real but results from how competition is run, not from competition itself.

The critics' concern deserves acknowledgement. Anyone who has endured being picked last for a team knows how humiliating it can be, and repeated public failure can persuade a child that exercise is simply not for them. Studies of adult physical inactivity often trace its roots to negative experiences in school games, so the long-term damage may extend well beyond the playground.

Yet the same research suggests that what discourages children is not the existence of a scoreboard but the way a lesson is structured. A teacher who selects teams by popularity, or who gives the least athletic pupils nothing to do except stand in goal, will produce resentment in any format. By contrast, well-designed competition can make weaker students feel included. Leagues grouped by ability, matches in which every player must take part, and individual targets such as improving a personal best over a term allow children to compete against their own previous performance, which is both motivating and fair.

Moreover, removing competition entirely would deprive pupils of experiences that are hard to replicate elsewhere. Learning to lose a match on Friday and train again on Monday builds resilience, and playing in a team teaches cooperation, since success depends on others. Such qualities are valued by employers and are difficult to teach in a classroom. At a time when many children spend most of their free hours on screens, competitive games may also be the only occasion on which they are sufficiently motivated to exert themselves physically.

In conclusion, competitive sport can discourage some children when badly managed, but with inclusive design its developmental and health benefits clearly outweigh the risks.

Why Band 8.5, not 9

TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response at 8: The position ('the harm described is real but results from how competition is run') is nuanced and maintained to the end. Ideas are well extended, for example the list of structures such as 'Leagues grouped by ability, matches in which every player must take part'. The reference to 'Studies of adult physical inactivity' and 'the same research' is not specific, and 'Such qualities are valued by employers' is generalised.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The position ('the harm described is real but results from how competition is run') is nuanced and maintained to the end. Ideas are well extended, for example the list of structures such as 'Leagues grouped by ability, matches in which every player must take part'. The reference to 'Studies of adult physical inactivity' and 'the same research' is not specific, and 'Such qualities are valued by employers' is generalised.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8.5 Each paragraph has a clear job: concession, rebuttal via design, the cost of removing competition, then conclusion. Devices like 'Yet', 'By contrast' and 'Moreover' are varied and unobtrusive. The reference in 'Yet the same research suggests' leans on a vague earlier mention, which is a small blemish.
Lexical Resource Band 8.5 Precise, natural vocabulary appears throughout: 'alienates', 'repeated public failure', 'resentment in any format', 'exert themselves physically'. Collocations are accurate and the register is controlled. Occasional phrases such as 'Competitive sport divides opinion in education' are slightly generic.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 A wide range of structures is used with control, including relative clauses ('a teacher who selects teams by popularity'), a participial phrase and a 'since' clause. Almost every sentence is error-free. The long sentence listing leagues, matches and targets is punctuated correctly but dense.

Marked mistakes

  1. Such qualities are valued by employers and are difficult to teach in a classroom.
    Such qualities are valued by many employers and are difficult to teach through classroom instruction alone. (TR)
    The unqualified claim over-generalises; softening it keeps the argument precise.
  2. Yet the same research suggests
    Yet research on school sport suggests (CC)
    'The same research' points back to the studies of adult inactivity, which concern long-term effects rather than lesson design, so the link is loose; describing the research directly makes it clearer.

What would raise the band

To reach the top of the scale, replace generalised references such as 'Studies' with one named or precisely described source, and qualify claims like the employer statement.

What separates the higher band

The 8.5 essay shifts the argument from 'competition' to 'how it is run' and gives specific design solutions (ability-grouped leagues, personal-best targets, compulsory participation). The 6.5 essay uses a personal anecdote with errors ('now he hate sport', 'different kind of activities') and offers a broader, less detailed remedy. The higher answer also cites a plausible link between school experiences and adult inactivity, whereas the lower one stays at the level of general claims like 'sport is good for health'.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Competitive sports at school do more harm than good because they discourage children who are not athletic. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →