Some people think that physical strength is important for success in sport, while other people think that mental strength is more important. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 5
A real IELTS practice essay scored Band 5 by AI on the topic: Some people think that physical strength is important for success in sport, while other people think that ment. Read it, then get your own essay graded.
Band 5.0
Prompt: Some people think that physical strength is important for success in sport, while other people think that mental strength is more important. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
A lot of times, sports is associated with physical strength. Someone who's physically well built is often presumed by people to play sports even if they have never touched a sport in their life. But the truth is that sports involves more calculations and mental ability than physical ability. Someone physical and agressive can always be outwitted by someone mentally in sports. But it varies sport to sport.
Physical strength is one of the most important aspects in sport and it is essential to anyone playing, Especially contact sports like rugby or boxing. People who are not as physically built would find it extremely difficult to play these games. Coaches in different teams generally look for those who are physically built, But if that was the only factor, then the only people we would see playing rugby are those people built like cranes. Most people that play rugby are fit, yet not giants.
That is where mental ability becomes a factor. Setting aside sports like chess, which rely on sheer mental ability. Sports like football, basketball, and even rugby require a lot of calculations. The importance of being able to predict the opponents next move, to know where to make the run in a champions league final, to keep yourself calm when taking the final penalty that could win your team the trophy, to remain calm in situations like that is where mental strength comes in. Only people calm enough and mentally stable in that moment can succeed.
Although physical strength is important, it isnt the sole category that leads success in sports. Mental strength also plays a huge role in sports success.
Why Band 5, not 5.5
TR 5.5 · CC 5 · LR 5 · GRA 5
The weakest criterion is Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5: There is a basic organisational structure with four paragraphs, but progression is weak. The third paragraph is a run-on list of ideas joined by commas rather than a coherent argument. Cohesive devices are limited and sometimes faulty ('That is where', 'Setting aside sports like chess' is a dangling modifier). Referencing is occasionally unclear and paragraphing is unbalanced — the conclusion is only two sentences.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 5.5 | The essay attempts to discuss both views and offers a loose opinion (mental strength is more important), but the position is never clearly stated and the conclusion is thin. Ideas are introduced but not fully extended or supported with concrete evidence. The phrase 'it varies sport to sport' is dropped without development. The task asks for a clear opinion throughout, which is largely absent. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 5 | There is a basic organisational structure with four paragraphs, but progression is weak. The third paragraph is a run-on list of ideas joined by commas rather than a coherent argument. Cohesive devices are limited and sometimes faulty ('That is where', 'Setting aside sports like chess' is a dangling modifier). Referencing is occasionally unclear and paragraphing is unbalanced — the conclusion is only two sentences. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5 | The vocabulary range is limited and repetitive ('physically built' appears three times, 'mental ability/strength' is recycled throughout). Informal and imprecise language is used ('built like cranes', 'someone physical and aggressive'). There are spelling errors ('agressive', 'isnt' without apostrophe) and word form issues ('someone physical' instead of 'someone physically strong'). Less common vocabulary is rarely attempted. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5 | There is a mix of simple and some complex structures, but errors are frequent. Comma splices appear throughout (e.g. 'it isnt the sole category that leads success in sports'). A dangling participle is present ('Setting aside sports like chess, which rely on sheer mental ability' — this clause is never resolved into a proper sentence). Punctuation errors include missing apostrophes and incorrect capitalisation mid-sentence ('Especially', 'But'). These errors are noticeable and occasionally impede clarity. |
Marked mistakes
-
But it varies sport to sport.
However, the relative importance of each quality varies depending on the sport in question. (TR)
The candidate's opinion is never clearly stated; this sentence is dropped without any follow-up, leaving the reader unsure of the writer's actual position. -
Setting aside sports like chess, which rely on sheer mental ability. Sports like football, basketball, and even rugby require a lot of calculations.
Setting aside sports like chess, which rely on sheer mental ability, sports like football, basketball, and even rugby still require a great deal of tactical thinking. (CC)
The first part is a dangling modifier left as a standalone sentence fragment; it must be attached to the main clause it introduces. -
it isnt the sole category that leads success in sports
it is not the sole factor that leads to success in sport (GA)
'Leads success' is ungrammatical; the correct collocation is 'leads to success'. The missing apostrophe in 'isnt' and the imprecise word 'category' are also corrected here. -
agressive
aggressive (LR)
'Aggressive' requires a double 'g'; this is a basic spelling error that affects the impression of lexical control. -
playing, Especially contact sports
playing, especially contact sports (GA)
'Especially' follows a comma and is not the start of a new sentence, so it should not be capitalised.
What would raise the band
Focus on stating your personal opinion clearly in the introduction and returning to it in the conclusion — IELTS 'discuss both views and give your opinion' tasks require a visible, consistent stance throughout the essay, not just a vague hint at the end.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people think that physical strength is important for success in sport, while other people think that mental strength is more important. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.