IELTS Task 2: Self-driving cars — Band 6.5 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Self-driving cars will make roads safer, and human drivers should eventually be banned from public roads. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Self-driving cars will make roads safer, and human drivers should eventually be banned from public roads.…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: Self-driving cars will make roads safer, and human drivers should eventually be banned from public roads. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Self-driving cars are becoming more popular and some people believe they will be safer than cars driven by humans. They also say that in the future people should not be allowed to drive on public roads. I agree that autonomous cars can improve safety, but I think a total ban on human drivers is going too far.

Firstly, there are good reasons to think that self-driving cars are safer. Most accidents happen because of human mistakes, for example drivers who are tired, drunk or looking at their phones. A computer never get tired and it can react more quickly than a person. Self-driving cars also follow the traffic rules all the time and they can use sensors to see in the dark. If all vehicles were automated, the number of accidents and deaths would probably decrease a lot. Moreover, older people and people with disabilities could travel more easily.

However, banning human drivers is not a realistic idea. The first problem is cost. Autonomous cars are still very expensive, and many people can not afford to buy one. It would be unfair to force everyone to change their car, especially in poor countries. Secondly, the technology is not perfect yet. There have been accidents when the system did not recognise a pedestrian or when the weather was bad, and it is not clear who is responsible in such cases, the owner or the company. Also, computers can be hacked, so criminals might control the cars, which is a serious risk.

In addition, many people enjoy driving and see it as a freedom. For example, some drivers like to travel on the weekend in mountains, and a ban would take this pleasure away from them.

In conclusion, self-driving cars may make roads safer in future, but human drivers should not be banned. It would be better to allow both types of vehicles and to improve the technology step by step.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 7 · LR 6 · GRA 6.5

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 6: There is adequate vocabulary for the topic ('autonomous cars', 'sensors', 'responsible', 'hacked'), but much of the language is everyday: 'a lot', 'good reasons', 'a serious risk'. Slips such as 'can not afford' and 'in mountains' do not impede meaning, but precise collocation is limited.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The position is clear from the opening paragraph: safer cars are accepted but 'a total ban on human drivers is going too far'. Cost, imperfect technology and hacking are relevant objections, yet the weekend-in-the-mountains example for driving pleasure is thin and the short fourth paragraph is underdeveloped.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 7 The essay progresses logically from safety benefits to objections, with clear sequencers such as 'Firstly', 'The first problem is cost' and 'Secondly'. The one-sentence-plus-example fourth paragraph feels bolted on, and 'Also, computers can be hacked' is a slightly abrupt link.
Lexical Resource Band 6 There is adequate vocabulary for the topic ('autonomous cars', 'sensors', 'responsible', 'hacked'), but much of the language is everyday: 'a lot', 'good reasons', 'a serious risk'. Slips such as 'can not afford' and 'in mountains' do not impede meaning, but precise collocation is limited.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6.5 The essay mixes conditionals ('If all vehicles were automated... would probably decrease'), relative clauses and 'when' clauses with generally good control. Slips like 'A computer never get tired' and 'can not afford' show accuracy is not yet consistent.

Marked mistakes

  1. A computer never get tired
    A computer never gets tired (GA)
    Third-person singular subjects need -s on the verb.
  2. many people can not afford to buy one
    many people cannot afford to buy one (LR)
    'Cannot' is written as one word in formal writing.
  3. travel on the weekend in mountains
    travel on the weekend in the mountains (LR)
    A mountain area as a destination needs the definite article: 'in the mountains'. ('On the weekend' is the American form of 'at the weekend' and is fine.)

What would raise the band

Develop your last body paragraph with a real consequence instead of a single casual example, and replace everyday words like 'a lot' and 'good reasons' with more precise alternatives.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Self-driving cars will make roads safer, and human drivers should eventually be banned from public roads. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Autonomous vehicles are often promoted as a route to near-zero road deaths, and the statement goes further by proposing to exclude human drivers altogether. I accept that automation is likely to make roads safer, but I disagree that a ban would be justified, at least in the foreseeable future.

The safety argument is strong. Human error contributes to the great majority of crashes, through fatigue, alcohol, distraction and speeding, and none of these affects a machine. A system that monitors 360 degrees at all times and brakes in milliseconds should, once mature, avoid many collisions that people cause. Early data from robotaxi trials already suggest fewer serious injuries per kilometre in certain conditions, and automation could give independence to elderly and disabled people who cannot currently drive.

Even so, a legal ban faces serious obstacles. Current systems perform well in mapped urban areas but are less reliable in heavy rain, snow or on poorly marked rural roads, so it would be reckless to remove the human fallback before the technology has proved itself in all conditions. There are also unresolved questions about liability, the vulnerability of connected cars to hacking, and the ethical choices that software must make in unavoidable collisions. Perhaps most importantly, a ban would impose a heavy cost on households. Millions of people drive vehicles worth a few thousand dollars, and expecting them to replace those cars with expensive autonomous models would be unaffordable for many, making mobility a privilege of the better-off. Professional drivers, from lorry operators to taxi drivers, would also lose their livelihoods with little notice.

A more reasonable path is gradual. Governments can restrict human driving in particular zones, such as dedicated motorway lanes or city centres, as autonomous vehicles prove reliable, while setting strict safety standards and providing support for those who need to retrain.

In conclusion, self-driving cars probably will make roads safer, but a blanket prohibition of human drivers would be premature, unaffordable and unnecessary.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource at 8: The thesis is stated precisely ('I accept that automation is likely to make roads safer, but I disagree that a ban would be justified') and sustained to the end. Ideas are well supported with specifics such as rain and snow limits, liability, hacking, household cost and drivers' livelihoods, though the robotaxi data claim is left vague.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The thesis is stated precisely ('I accept that automation is likely to make roads safer, but I disagree that a ban would be justified') and sustained to the end. Ideas are well supported with specifics such as rain and snow limits, liability, hacking, household cost and drivers' livelihoods, though the robotaxi data claim is left vague.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Paragraphs each have a clear controlling idea, and the flow from 'The safety argument is strong' to 'Even so, a legal ban faces serious obstacles' to 'A more reasonable path is gradual' is smooth. Linking is subtle ('Perhaps most importantly', 'also') though the third paragraph is heavy and could be split.
Lexical Resource Band 8 The essay uses precise, natural phrasing such as 'foreseeable future', 'human fallback', 'blanket prohibition' and 'reckless'. Collocations like 'proved itself in all conditions' and 'impose a heavy cost on households' show wide flexible control, with only an occasional vague phrase like 'certain conditions'.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 Sentence structures are varied, with participial phrases ('making mobility a privilege'), subordinate clauses and appositive lists, and errors are very rare. Punctuation is accurate, including the commas around the phrase 'from lorry operators to taxi drivers'.

Marked mistakes

  1. Early data from robotaxi trials already suggest fewer serious injuries per kilometre in certain conditions
    Early data from robotaxi trials in several US cities already suggest fewer serious injuries per kilometre in good weather (TR)
    The claim is unspecified; naming the setting would make the support more convincing.

What would raise the band

To reach Band 8.5+, back at least one general claim (robotaxi safety data) with a specific, believable example and consider splitting the long third paragraph into technology risks and economic costs.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 essay separates the two halves of the statement (safety and banning) and develops the second with several distinct, specific obstacles: weather limits, liability, hacking and affordability for households and professional drivers. It ends with a practical phased proposal (zones and lanes). The 6.5 essay covers similar points but in less depth, relies on listed 'Firstly/Secondly/Also', and contains errors such as 'A computer never get tired' and 'can not'. Its weekend-in-the-mountains example is also weaker than the 8.0 essay's concrete policy suggestions.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Self-driving cars will make roads safer, and human drivers should eventually be banned from public roads. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →