IELTS Task 2: Money skills at school — Band 6 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Schools should teach children how to manage money and budget, as these skills are more useful than many traditional subjects. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Schools should teach children how to manage money and budget, as these skills are more useful than many…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Schools should teach children how to manage money and budget, as these skills are more useful than many traditional subjects. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Nowadays many people have problems with money, so some people think schools should teach children how to budget. I agree with this opinion to a large extent, but I do not think traditional subjects are useless.

Firstly, financial skills are very essential in adult life. Many young people finish school and then get a first salary, but they do not know how to save it. They spend all money on clothes or entertainment and at the end of the month they have debts. If schools teach budgeting, students would understand the difference between needs and wants. For example, a lesson where pupils plan a monthly budget for a family can be very useful and also interesting.

Moreover, money management help people to avoid serious problems later. Credit cards and online loans are easy to get today, and a person without knowledge can fall in a trap of high interest. Parents often do not teach their children about this because they are busy or they don't know it themselves. So school is the best place to learn.

However, I do not agree that these skills are more useful than all traditional subjects. Subjects like maths, science and languages give students a base for their future career. For instance, a doctor needs biology and chemistry, and nobody can learn this by himself easily. Also, financial education can be included inside maths lessons, so schools do not need to remove other subjects.

Another point is that teachers must be well prepared. If a teacher have no knowledge about investments or taxes, the lessons will be a waste of time. The government should make a special training for teachers.

In conclusion, I believe schools should add money management to the curriculum, because it prepare students for real life, but this should not replace the traditional subjects which are also important.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5

The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: Conditionals ('If schools teach budgeting, students would ...') and 'because' clauses give some range, but third-person agreement fails repeatedly: 'money management help', 'a teacher have', 'it prepare'. These slips appear in the more ambitious sentences, although meaning is always recoverable.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The opening gives a clear qualified position ('I agree ... to a large extent, but I do not think traditional subjects are useless') and it is kept to the conclusion. The monthly-family-budget lesson and the credit-card trap are relevant, but the doctor example and the teacher-training paragraph are only briefly developed.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 Each paragraph has a clear job (benefits, risks of debt, limits, teacher training) and 'Firstly', 'Moreover', 'However' and 'Another point' guide the reader. The final teacher paragraph feels added on and 'So school is the best place to learn' is a thin link after the parents sentence.
Lexical Resource Band 6 Topic words such as 'budget', 'credit cards', 'interest' and 'needs and wants' are suitable and clear. Collocation and word choice slip in 'very essential', 'fall in a trap' and 'make a special training', and 'money' and 'students' are repeated a great deal.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 5.5 Conditionals ('If schools teach budgeting, students would ...') and 'because' clauses give some range, but third-person agreement fails repeatedly: 'money management help', 'a teacher have', 'it prepare'. These slips appear in the more ambitious sentences, although meaning is always recoverable.

Marked mistakes

  1. money management help people to avoid serious problems later
    money management helps people to avoid serious problems later (GA)
    The singular subject 'money management' needs the verb 'helps'.
  2. If a teacher have no knowledge about investments or taxes
    If a teacher has no knowledge about investments or taxes (GA)
    'A teacher' is singular, so the verb must be 'has'.
  3. because it prepare students for real life
    because it prepares students for real life (GA)
    After 'it' the present simple verb takes -s.
  4. can fall in a trap of high interest
    can fall into a high-interest debt trap (LR)
    The natural collocation is 'fall into a trap', and 'high-interest' works better as a compound adjective.
  5. financial skills are very essential in adult life
    financial skills are essential in adult life (LR)
    'Essential' is already a strong, absolute adjective and does not take 'very'.

What would raise the band

Re-read every sentence for a singular subject and check the verb ending ('management helps', 'teacher has', 'it prepares'); fixing this one pattern would lift your Grammar band the most.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Schools should teach children how to manage money and budget, as these skills are more useful than many traditional subjects. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Few skills are used as often as budgeting, yet most students leave school without ever having been taught it. I largely agree that schools should teach money management, although I would stop short of claiming it outweighs every traditional subject.

The strongest argument for financial education is that its consequences are immediate and personal. A school-leaver who takes up a first job, rents a flat and is offered a credit card faces decisions within months that can affect their finances for years. A teenager who has never calculated what a 24 per cent interest rate means on an unpaid balance is easy prey for lenders. By contrast, pupils who have practised building a monthly budget, comparing loan offers or estimating the cost of a student loan are far better placed to avoid debt, and the benefit is not limited to the individual, since personal bankruptcies and household stress carry social costs.

Schools are also the only institution that reaches every child. Parents differ widely in their own financial literacy, so leaving the subject to families simply reproduces inequality: children from households that discuss money learn good habits, while others learn nothing or, worse, copy poor ones.

Nevertheless, the claim that these skills are more useful than traditional subjects is overstated. Mathematics, science and literature develop analytical thinking and open up careers in a way that a budgeting lesson cannot. Indeed, sound financial decisions depend on numeracy: a student who cannot handle percentages will not understand compound interest, however many hours are devoted to personal finance. The sensible approach is therefore integration rather than replacement, for example by teaching interest and probability through real mortgage and insurance examples within existing maths classes, supplemented by a short dedicated course in the final years.

In conclusion, money management deserves a secure place in the curriculum because it equips young people for decisions they will face almost immediately, but it should complement, not displace, the core academic subjects on which it relies.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource at 8: The qualified position ('largely agree ... stop short of claiming it outweighs every traditional subject') is held throughout and both halves of the statement are answered. The 24 per cent interest example and the argument that compound interest needs numeracy are well developed, though the final-years course is left vague.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The qualified position ('largely agree ... stop short of claiming it outweighs every traditional subject') is held throughout and both halves of the statement are answered. The 24 per cent interest example and the argument that compound interest needs numeracy are well developed, though the final-years course is left vague.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 The essay moves smoothly from personal consequences to schools reaching every child to the limits of the claim, with 'By contrast', 'Nevertheless', 'Indeed' and 'therefore' used naturally. The integration recommendation is neatly tied back to the maths argument that precedes it.
Lexical Resource Band 8 Precise, less common items such as 'easy prey for lenders', 'financial literacy', 'reproduces inequality' and 'compound interest' show wide flexible vocabulary. Occasional absolute phrasing like 'the only institution' is slightly overstated, but there are no real lexical errors.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 Complex structures, including relative clauses ('A teenager who has never calculated ...'), contrast with 'while' and 'however many hours are devoted', are controlled with near-total accuracy. The very long second-paragraph sentence is the only place where control wavers.

Marked mistakes

  1. and the benefit is not limited to the individual, since personal bankruptcies and household stress carry social costs
    The benefit is not limited to the individual: personal bankruptcies and household stress also carry social costs. (CC)
    Splitting this tail from an already long sentence would make the claim easier to follow.
  2. Schools are also the only institution that reaches every child.
    Schools are also the one institution that reaches almost every child. (LR)
    'Only' and 'every' are absolute, and a hedge is more accurate.
  3. supplemented by a short dedicated course in the final years
    supplemented by a short dedicated course in the last two years of secondary school (TR)
    Naming the stage makes the proposal concrete rather than general.

What would raise the band

Add one concrete piece of evidence for the proposed solution, such as a named country or a short course length, so the final recommendation is as well supported as the earlier arguments.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 essay grounds its argument in specific consequences (a 24 per cent interest rate, credit offers to school-leavers) and explains why schools, not families, must teach the subject because of unequal household literacy. It also qualifies the claim in the prompt precisely by arguing that financial decisions rely on numeracy, then proposes a concrete solution of integrating the topic into maths lessons. The 6.0 essay takes a similar position but its support is generic ('they spend all money on clothes'), it has repeated errors such as 'money management help' and 'a teacher have', and relies on mechanical linkers like 'Firstly' and 'Moreover'.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Schools should teach children how to manage money and budget, as these skills are more useful than many traditional subjects. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →