IELTS Task 2: Limits on research — Band 6 vs 8.5 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people think that scientists should be free to research any topic. Others believe there should be limits on certain kinds of research. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Band 6 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that scientists should be free to research any topic. Others believe there should be…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Some people think that scientists should be free to research any topic. Others believe there should be limits on certain kinds of research. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Science has changed our life a lot, but some research is controversial. Some people think that scientists should be free to study every topic, while others believe there must be limits for some kinds of research. In this essay I will discuss both opinions.

On the one hand, there are people who think that science should have no limits. The main reason is that we cannot know in advance which discovery will be useful. For example, when scientists started to study bacteria, nobody expected that this will lead to antibiotics, which saved millions of lives. If we stop some research, we can lose important opportunities. Moreover, if one country forbid a type of research, scientists will just move to another country that have less rules, so the limits do not really work.

On the other hand, I think there are good reasons to put some limits. Some experiments can be dangerous for people or for the environment. For instance, research on dangerous viruses can cause a new pandemic if there is an accident in the laboratory. Also, there are ethical problems, such as testing medicines on people without their agreement or cloning humans. History shows that when scientists have no control, they can do terrible things, like the experiments in Nazi Germany.

In my opinion, scientists should be free in general, but the society needs rules to protect people. Independent committees, which include not only scientists but also lawyers and ordinary citizens, could check the projects that are risky. In this way, the research can continue and the safety is also guaranteed.

To conclude, complete freedom in science is dangerous, but too many restrictions can slow down progress. I believe that a balanced system with clear ethical rules is the best option.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5

The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: There is a mix of simple and complex sentences, but frequent errors with agreement and tense appear: 'nobody expected that this will lead', 'if one country forbid', 'a country that have less rules'. They rarely block understanding but occur in most paragraphs.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 Both views are discussed, with the antibiotics example for freedom and dangerous viruses and cloning for limits, and the opinion that scientists should be 'free in general' but with rules is clear. The development is uneven: the Nazi Germany reference is only a half-sentence, and 'ordinary citizens' on committees is not explained.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The essay has a clear structure with 'On the one hand', 'On the other hand', 'Moreover', 'Also' and 'In this way'. The linking is correct but mechanical, and the paragraph beginning 'On the other hand' blends the opposing view with the writer's own 'I think', which blurs the paragraph focus.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The topic vocabulary is adequate ('ethical problems', 'pandemic', 'cloning', 'independent committees'), and 'controversial' is a good attempt at a less common word. Phrases such as 'our life a lot', 'less rules' and 'the safety is also guaranteed' show imprecision.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 5.5 There is a mix of simple and complex sentences, but frequent errors with agreement and tense appear: 'nobody expected that this will lead', 'if one country forbid', 'a country that have less rules'. They rarely block understanding but occur in most paragraphs.

Marked mistakes

  1. nobody expected that this will lead to antibiotics
    nobody expected that this would lead to antibiotics (GA)
    The past verb 'expected' requires 'would' for future-in-the-past.
  2. if one country forbid a type of research
    if one country forbids a type of research (GA)
    'One country' is singular, so 'forbids'.
  3. another country that have less rules
    another country that has fewer rules (GA)
    'Country' takes 'has' and 'rules' is countable, so 'fewer'.
  4. the society needs rules to protect people
    society needs rules to protect people (LR)
    'Society' used in a general sense takes no article.
  5. Science has changed our life a lot
    Science has changed our lives considerably (LR)
    'Our lives' is plural and 'considerably' is more precise than 'a lot'.

What would raise the band

Concentrate on verb agreement and tense control, especially in 'that' clauses and relative clauses, as this is the largest barrier to a higher grammar score. Also expand brief references, such as the Nazi experiments, into a sentence explaining why they matter.

Band 8.5

Prompt: Some people think that scientists should be free to research any topic. Others believe there should be limits on certain kinds of research. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Few people would deny that scientific research has improved lives, but there is disagreement over whether researchers should be able to pursue any question they choose. I take the view that freedom of inquiry should be the default, with firm limits applied only where research puts people at serious risk or violates basic ethical principles.

Advocates of unrestricted research make a persuasive point about unpredictability. Many of the most valuable discoveries came from work with no obvious practical purpose: Alexander Fleming's observation of mould killing bacteria was a laboratory accident, and the mathematics behind modern encryption was developed long before computers existed. If funding bodies or governments decide in advance which topics are acceptable, they risk closing off such discoveries. There is also a practical difficulty, since banning a field in one country often just sends researchers and investment to another with weaker oversight.

Nevertheless, history provides clear reasons for restraint. The medical experiments carried out on prisoners during the Second World War showed what can happen when scientific goals are allowed to override human rights, and this led to the modern requirement of informed consent. More recently, the case of a Chinese scientist who created gene-edited babies in 2018 prompted international condemnation because the safety of the procedure and its long-term consequences had not been established. Research that could make dangerous pathogens more transmissible raises a similar concern, as an accidental release would affect millions of people who had no say in the decision.

The sensible solution, in my view, is not a list of forbidden topics but a system of oversight. Independent ethics committees should evaluate proposals according to risk and public benefit, and researchers should be accountable for breaking the rules. Such a system protects participants and the public without discouraging legitimate curiosity.

In conclusion, scientists should be given wide freedom to explore, but this freedom needs to be bounded by transparent ethical review wherever the potential harm is serious.

Why Band 8.5, not 9

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion at 8: The thesis, that 'freedom of inquiry should be the default' with limits for serious risk or ethical violation, is clear and developed throughout. The Fleming example and the 2018 gene-edited babies case are strong and relevant, while the oversight solution is explained, though Fleming's work is arguably not an example of purposeless research.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The thesis, that 'freedom of inquiry should be the default' with limits for serious risk or ethical violation, is clear and developed throughout. The Fleming example and the 2018 gene-edited babies case are strong and relevant, while the oversight solution is explained, though Fleming's work is arguably not an example of purposeless research.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 The paragraphs are logically ordered, each opening with a clear topic sentence such as 'Advocates of unrestricted research make a persuasive point' and 'Nevertheless, history provides clear reasons for restraint'. Cohesion is natural, with 'There is also a practical difficulty' and 'More recently' guiding the reader without overuse.
Lexical Resource Band 8.5 The language is wide, precise and natural: 'freedom of inquiry', 'informed consent', 'transmissible', 'bounded by transparent ethical review'. There are no spelling or word-form errors and collocations such as 'prompted international condemnation' are skilful.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 The essay uses a full range of complex structures, including participial phrases, relative clauses and passives, and virtually every sentence is error-free. Punctuation, such as the colon before the Fleming example, is used confidently.

What would raise the band

To reach the top band, choose examples that exactly illustrate the point being made, for example a case of research with no obvious purpose that later transformed society. Keep the same balance in length between the two opposing paragraphs.

What separates the higher band

The 8.5 essay uses precise, checkable evidence (Fleming's discovery, the post-war requirement of informed consent, the 2018 gene-editing case) and arrives at a specific proposal of ethics review rather than banned topics. The 6.0 essay makes the same kind of points more generally and has grammatical slips ('if one country forbid', 'that have less rules', 'will lead'). The 8.5 essay is also more precise in word choice, for instance 'oversight', 'transmissible' and 'accountable'.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people think that scientists should be free to research any topic. Others believe there should be limits on certain kinds of research. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →