Some people think that the government should be responsible for supporting artists and musicians. Others believe artists should earn their own living. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that the government should be responsible for supporting artists and musicians. Others…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: Some people think that the government should be responsible for supporting artists and musicians. Others believe artists should earn their own living. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Art and music are important parts of every culture. Some people think that the government should support artists and musicians financially, while other people believe that they must earn money by themselves. In this essay I will discuss both views.
On the one hand, there are good reasons for government support. Many artists, for example painters, poets or classical musicians, can not earn enough money from their work because only a small number of people want to buy it. Without help, they would have to leave their art and find another job. Moreover, art is very essential for the national culture and identity. If the government do not support it, many traditional forms of art may disappear. For example, in some countries the folk music is supported by the state and young people can learn it at special schools. Also, art gives the tourists a reason to visit the country, so it can bring the money back.
On the other hand, some people say that artists should be independent. Taxpayers' money is limited and the government has to spend it on more important things such as hospitals, schools and roads. Furthermore, if artists get money from the state, they may become lazy and not try to create something that people really like. They can also be afraid to criticize the government because they can lose the support. In contrast, an artist who sells his work must be creative and understand what the audience wants.
In my opinion, the government should give some support, especially to young artists and to the traditional arts, but not pay for everything. For popular artists, the market is enough.
To conclude, I think the state has a role in supporting culture, but artists should also try to earn their own living when it is possible.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The vocabulary is adequate and topic-appropriate ('traditional forms of art', 'taxpayers' money', 'audience'), but it is repetitive: 'money', 'support' and 'earn' recur constantly. There are collocation slips such as 'very essential' and 'bring the money back', which do not block meaning.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | Both views are covered in separate paragraphs and the writer gives a clear position (some support for young artists and traditional arts, not for popular ones). Ideas such as folk music schools and tourism are relevant but stay general, and the point that artists 'may become lazy' is asserted without explanation. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | The structure is orderly, with an introduction, one paragraph per view, an opinion paragraph and a conclusion. Linkers like 'Moreover', 'Furthermore' and 'In contrast' are used correctly, though 'On the one hand / On the other hand' and 'Also' are rather mechanical, and the opinion paragraph is very short. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The vocabulary is adequate and topic-appropriate ('traditional forms of art', 'taxpayers' money', 'audience'), but it is repetitive: 'money', 'support' and 'earn' recur constantly. There are collocation slips such as 'very essential' and 'bring the money back', which do not block meaning. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | A mix of simple and complex sentences is used, including conditionals ('Without help, they would have to leave their art') and relative clauses. Errors do occur, though, such as 'can not', and article use is unreliable ('the folk music', 'the tourists'). |
Marked mistakes
-
art is very essential for the national culture
art is essential for the national culture (LR)
'Essential' is already extreme, so it is not normally modified by 'very'. -
the folk music is supported by the state
folk music is supported by the state (GA)
An uncountable noun used in a general sense takes no article. -
can not earn enough money
cannot earn enough money (LR)
'Cannot' is written as one word in formal writing. -
so it can bring the money back
so it can generate revenue for the economy (LR)
'Bring the money back' is vague; 'generate revenue' is the natural academic collocation.
What would raise the band
Fix the recurring article slips ('the folk music', 'the tourists') by proofreading noun phrases for an unnecessary 'the', then expand your opinion paragraph with a reason for each part of your compromise.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Some people think that the government should be responsible for supporting artists and musicians. Others believe artists should earn their own living. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Whether public money should be used to support artists is a question that divides taxpayers. Some see culture as a shared responsibility of the state, while others think creators, like any other workers, should earn their income in the market. I believe a limited form of public funding is justified, directed at work that would otherwise vanish.
The argument for state support starts from the economics of the arts. Much valuable work, such as experimental theatre, poetry or chamber music, appeals to small audiences and will never cover its costs, however skilled the artists are. Without subsidy, talented people may abandon their craft for stable employment, and a country loses art that might be recognised only decades later. Cultural institutions also bring indirect returns: museums, festivals and concert halls attract tourists, support restaurants and hotels, and improve the image of a city. Countries like Germany, which fund regional orchestras and theatres generously, enjoy a cultural life that private income alone could not sustain.
Opponents counter that taxpayers should not be obliged to fund tastes that they do not share, particularly when budgets are under pressure from healthcare and education. There is also the danger of dependency and political influence: if funding decisions are made by officials, artists may self-censor or produce work designed to please a committee rather than an audience. Those who succeed commercially, they argue, show that creativity can be rewarded without government help, and the internet has made it possible for musicians to reach listeners directly.
My position is that governments should provide grants to emerging artists and to heritage forms, with decisions made by independent panels of peers instead of ministers. Established performers who can sell tickets and recordings do not need such support. This approach keeps costs modest while protecting the diversity of a country's culture.
In conclusion, the market rewards popular art but overlooks much that is valuable. Targeted, independent public funding is therefore a reasonable investment.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource at 8: The position is stated in the introduction ('a limited form of public funding is justified, directed at work that would otherwise vanish') and held throughout. Both sides are developed with economics, tourism, the German orchestra example, and the self-censorship risk. The claim that Germany's cultural life 'private income alone could not sustain' is not backed by evidence.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The position is stated in the introduction ('a limited form of public funding is justified, directed at work that would otherwise vanish') and held throughout. Both sides are developed with economics, tourism, the German orchestra example, and the self-censorship risk. The claim that Germany's cultural life 'private income alone could not sustain' is not backed by evidence. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | Each paragraph has one clear job, and the argument moves from the opening thesis through support, opposition and the writer's solution without gaps. Devices such as 'Opponents counter that', 'There is also the danger of' and 'This approach' are varied and invisible, and the closing 'therefore' echoes the thesis. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | The range is wide and precise: 'subsidy', 'self-censor', 'heritage forms', 'independent panels of peers' and 'indirect returns' are all used naturally. Word choice is natural and errors are rare. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | Sentence structures are varied and controlled, including a fronted 'Whether...' clause, participial phrases ('designed to please a committee') and a colon list. Nearly every sentence is error-free, and punctuation is accurate throughout. |
Marked mistakes
-
enjoy a cultural life that private income alone could not sustain
enjoy a cultural life that, according to cultural-policy studies, private income alone could not sustain (TR)
The claim about Germany is asserted as fact; a brief source or qualifier would make it fully supported.
What would raise the band
To move closer to Band 9, back one claim, such as the German orchestras, with a verifiable example or figure.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay specifies who should be supported and how (grants to emerging artists and heritage forms, awarded by independent peer panels), linking this to arguments about small audiences, self-censorship and tourism, with Germany as an example. The 6.5 essay reaches a similar view but with generic reasons ('lazy', 'more important things') and no mechanism. The 6.5 text also has errors such as 'can not', 'very essential', 'the folk music' and repeated simple connectors.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people think that the government should be responsible for supporting artists and musicians. Others believe artists should earn their own living. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.