IELTS Task 2: The best way to reduce — Band 3.5 vs 7.5 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people think the best way to reduce crime is to give longer prison sentences. Others believe there are better alternative ways. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

2 real answers to “Some people think the best way to reduce crime is to give longer prison sentences. Others believe there…” (Band 3.5–7.5), graded on the official criteria — see what separates the bands, then get yours graded free.

Band 3.5 · real student answer

Prompt: Some people think the best way to reduce crime is to give longer prison sentences. Others believe there are better alternative ways. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Nowadays, more and more people after graduating from university continue to live with their parents. I believe that it is mostly related to the cost of living on some countries especially for countries in European union.

Let's take a look at Spain for instance. Large cities have become quite expensive in recent years, common price range to rent apartment is about 1000-1500 euros and usually it takes at least 3 months to find appropriate apartment. But it is only start of journey of getting your place for living. You will also need to prove that you have reliable money income to be able to manage further payment.

Considering that average salary in Spain is about 2000 euros, for just graduated person with first work, that basically can be less paid than rent price, usually push them to stay with their parents

Why Band 3.5, not 4

TR 1 · CC 4 · LR 4 · GRA 4

The weakest criterion is Task Response at 1: The essay completely ignores the given topic. The question asks about reducing crime and prison sentences, but the student wrote entirely about young people living with their parents after university — a completely different subject. There is no attempt to discuss either view from the prompt, and no relevant opinion is given. This is a near-total failure of Task Response.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 1 The essay completely ignores the given topic. The question asks about reducing crime and prison sentences, but the student wrote entirely about young people living with their parents after university — a completely different subject. There is no attempt to discuss either view from the prompt, and no relevant opinion is given. This is a near-total failure of Task Response.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 4 There is a basic attempt at paragraphing, but the overall structure is weak and incomplete — the essay ends abruptly mid-sentence. Cohesive devices are minimal and sometimes awkward ('Let's take a look at', 'But it is only start of journey'). There is no clear introduction-body-conclusion structure.
Lexical Resource Band 4 Vocabulary is limited and repetitive. There are several word-form and collocation errors ('money income', 'first work', 'cost of living on some countries', 'reliable money income'). The range is insufficient for a Task 2 essay, and informal/imprecise language is used throughout.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 4 There is a limited range of grammatical structures. Errors are frequent and sometimes impede communication ('cost of living on some countries', 'it is only start of journey', 'first work, that basically can be less paid than rent price'). The final sentence is incomplete and ungrammatical. Simple sentences are more accurate than complex ones.

Marked mistakes

  1. Nowadays, more and more people after graduating from university continue to live with their parents.
    Nowadays, crime rates remain a pressing concern, and people debate whether longer prison sentences are the most effective solution. (TR)
    The entire essay addresses a completely different topic (young adults living with parents) instead of the assigned question about crime reduction and prison sentences.
  2. reliable money income
    a reliable source of income (LR)
    'Money income' is not a natural English collocation; the correct phrase is 'a reliable source of income' or simply 'a steady income'.
  3. Considering that average salary in Spain is about 2000 euros, for just graduated person with first work, that basically can be less paid than rent price, usually push them to stay with their parents
    Considering that the average salary in Spain is about 2,000 euros, a recently graduated person in their first job — which may pay less than the cost of rent — is often pushed to stay with their parents. (GA)
    This sentence is grammatically incomplete (no main finite verb), contains multiple errors ('just graduated person', 'first work', 'less paid'), and ends without a full stop, making it very difficult to understand.
  4. cost of living on some countries
    cost of living in some countries (GA)
    The correct preposition with 'countries' is 'in', not 'on'.
  5. it is only start of journey of getting your place for living
    it is only the start of the journey to getting your own place to live (LR)
    Multiple articles are missing and the phrasing is unnatural; 'place for living' should be 'place to live' or 'your own home'.

What would raise the band

The most critical action is to read the essay question carefully before writing — this entire essay answered a completely different topic. Always identify the key words in the question (here: 'crime', 'prison sentences', 'alternative ways', 'discuss both views') and plan your response around them before writing a single sentence.

Band 7.5 · real student answer

Prompt: Some people think the best way to reduce crime is to give longer prison sentences. Others believe there are better alternative ways. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Crime is a serious problem in many societies, and there is an ongoing debate about how it should be tackled. While some people argue that longer prison sentences are the most effective solution, others believe that alternative approaches work better. In my opinion, a combination of both is needed, but prevention should be the priority.

Those who support harsher punishments claim that long sentences deter potential criminals and keep dangerous individuals away from the public. For example, if people know that committing a serious crime will result in many years in prison, they may think twice before breaking the law. In addition, keeping repeat offenders in prison protects communities from further harm.

However, opponents argue that prison alone does not address the root causes of crime, such as poverty, lack of education, and unemployment. They suggest that investing in social programmes, rehabilitation, and job training is more effective in the long term. Countries that focus on rehabilitation often have lower reoffending rates, which shows that helping criminals reintegrate into society can be more beneficial than simply punishing them.

In conclusion, although longer prison sentences may be necessary for the most serious crimes, I believe that tackling the underlying social problems is a more sustainable way to reduce crime. Governments should therefore balance firm punishment with strong prevention and rehabilitation programmes.

Why Band 7.5, not 8

TR 7.5 · CC 7.5 · LR 7 · GRA 7.5

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 7: The vocabulary is sufficiently wide: precise phrases such as 'deter potential criminals', 'reoffending rates', 'reintegrate into society' and 'underlying social problems' are used. However, some words are repeated ('crime', 'prison', 'rehabilitation') and could have been replaced with less common words. There are no spelling mistakes.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 7.5 The essay considers both points of view and states its own opinion clearly. The main ideas are supported with examples. However, some ideas remain rather general and could have been developed further. For example, the claim 'Countries that focus on rehabilitation often have lower reoffending rates' should have been backed up with a more specific example or a figure.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 7.5 The essay is logically organised: an introduction, two body paragraphs and a conclusion. Linking devices ('However', 'In addition', 'In conclusion', 'therefore') are used correctly. Each paragraph has a clear central topic. With a little more variety in linking devices, it could reach band 8.
Lexical Resource Band 7 The vocabulary is sufficiently wide: precise phrases such as 'deter potential criminals', 'reoffending rates', 'reintegrate into society' and 'underlying social problems' are used. However, some words are repeated ('crime', 'prison', 'rehabilitation') and could have been replaced with less common words. There are no spelling mistakes.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 7.5 Complex grammatical structures are used correctly: conditional sentences ('if people know that committing a serious crime will result in...'), relative clauses and modal verbs. Errors are very rare and do not impede communication. Punctuation is used correctly.

Marked mistakes

  1. Countries that focus on rehabilitation often have lower reoffending rates
    Countries such as Norway, which prioritise rehabilitation, report reoffending rates as low as 20%, compared to over 60% in countries that rely solely on imprisonment. (TR)
    This claim is not supported by a specific example or statistic, so the idea looks not fully developed.
  2. crime ... crime ... crime
    crime ... criminal activity ... offending behaviour (LR)
    The word 'crime' is repeated very often throughout the essay; synonyms should have been used to add variety.
  3. However, opponents argue that prison alone does not address the root causes of crime
    Despite this, opponents contend that imprisonment in isolation fails to address the root causes of crime (CC)
    'However' is a very simple and common linker; alternatives such as 'Despite this', 'Nevertheless' or 'Notwithstanding this view' add stylistic variety.
  4. keep dangerous individuals away from the public
    keep dangerous individuals away from the general public (GA)
    This phrase is grammatically correct, but 'the general public' is a more natural English collocation; 'the public' sounds somewhat general.
  5. investing in social programmes, rehabilitation, and job training is more effective in the long term
    investing in social programmes, rehabilitation, and vocational training is demonstrably more effective in the long term, as it targets the socioeconomic conditions that drive individuals towards criminal behaviour (TR)
    The idea is heading in the right direction, but the essay does not explain how it reaches the conclusion 'more effective'; a cause-and-effect link should have been added.

What would raise the band

Support every main idea with specific examples, figures or real-life facts — for example, referring to the rehabilitation systems of Norway or Finland would noticeably increase the essay's credibility and raise the Task Response band to 8.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people think the best way to reduce crime is to give longer prison sentences. Others believe there are better alternative ways. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →