Some people claim that not enough of the waste from homes is recycled. They say that the only way to increase recycling is for governments to make it a legal requirement. To what extent do you think laws are needed to make people recycle more of their waste?
Band 5.5
A real IELTS practice essay scored Band 5.5 by AI on the topic: Some people claim that not enough of the waste from homes is recycled. They say that the only way to increase . Read it, then get your own essay graded.
Band 5.5
Prompt: Some people claim that not enough of the waste from homes is recycled. They say that the only way to increase recycling is for governments to make it a legal requirement. To what extent do you think laws are needed to make people recycle more of their waste?
Nowadays, many people do not recycle enough rubbish at home.Some people think that the only way to fix this problem is to make new laws. In my opinion, laws can help a lot, but they are not the only answer. Goverments also need to teach people and give them good recycling bins. First, making recycling a law is a fast way to change how people act. Many people are busy or lazy, so thet put all their rubbish into one bag. If the goverment makes a rule and gives fines to people who do not recycle, citiznes will start to sort their waste. They will do it because they do not want to lose money. For examlpe, in some coutries, people must separate paper, plastic and glass by law. Because of these rules, those coutries rycycle a lot of their waste every year. However, laws alone are not enough. People cannot recycle if there are no special bins near their houses. Goverments must first put clear and claen recycling bins on every street. Also, schools and TV programs should teach people why recycling is important for our planet. When people understand that recycling keeps the Earth clean and saves animals, they will want to do it without any always. In conclusion, I believe that laws are very useful to make people recycle more at home. However, laws work best when the government also provides good bins and teaches people about protecting nature.
Why Band 5.5, not 6
TR 6 · CC 6 · LR 5 · GRA 5
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5: The vocabulary range is limited and repetitive (e.g. 'recycle/recycling' used very frequently, 'rubbish', 'bins', 'people' repeated throughout). There are few attempts at less common or precise vocabulary. Word choice is mostly simple and functional. There are also notable spelling errors (Goverments, thet, citiznes, examlpe, coutries, rycycle, claen) and one clear word-form error ('without any always'). These errors are noticeable but do not fully impede communication.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6 | The essay addresses all parts of the question and presents a clear position (laws help but are not the only answer). Both sides are acknowledged — laws and alternative measures — but the development is somewhat thin. The argument about fines is supported with a brief example, but the 'education and bins' point in body paragraph 2 is underdeveloped and lacks specific support. The conclusion restates the position clearly. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6 | There is a clear overall structure with an introduction, two body paragraphs, and a conclusion. Cohesive devices are used (First, However, Also, In conclusion, Because of these rules), but the range is limited and some are mechanical. Paragraphing is present and logical, though the central topic of each paragraph could be signalled more precisely. Referencing is generally clear. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5 | The vocabulary range is limited and repetitive (e.g. 'recycle/recycling' used very frequently, 'rubbish', 'bins', 'people' repeated throughout). There are few attempts at less common or precise vocabulary. Word choice is mostly simple and functional. There are also notable spelling errors (Goverments, thet, citiznes, examlpe, coutries, rycycle, claen) and one clear word-form error ('without any always'). These errors are noticeable but do not fully impede communication. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5 | The essay uses a limited range of grammatical structures, relying heavily on simple sentences and basic compound sentences. There are some attempts at complex structures (e.g. 'If the government makes a rule and gives fines to people who do not recycle, citizens will start to sort their waste'), which are mostly accurate. However, errors are frequent: missing articles, a dangling/incomplete phrase ('without any always'), and inconsistent sentence construction. Errors are noticeable but rarely prevent understanding. |
Marked mistakes
-
Goverments also need to teach people
Governments also need to teach people (LR)
'Government' is misspelled as 'Goverment' throughout the essay — this is a high-frequency word that should be spelled correctly at this level. -
they will want to do it without any always
they will want to do it without being forced (LR)
'Without any always' is not a meaningful English phrase; the intended meaning seems to be 'without being forced' or 'voluntarily', and this error significantly damages the sentence. -
rycycle a lot of their waste every year
recycle a lot of their waste every year (LR)
'Rycycle' is a misspelling of 'recycle', a key topic word that should be spelled correctly throughout the essay. -
making recycling a law is a fast way to change how people act
making recycling a legal requirement is a fast way to change people's behaviour (GA)
While grammatically acceptable, 'making recycling a law' is an imprecise collocation; 'legal requirement' is the standard phrase, and 'people's behaviour' is more precise than 'how people act'. -
First, making recycling a law is a fast way to change how people act.
To begin with, enforcing recycling through legislation is one of the most direct ways to change public behaviour. (CC)
Using only 'First' without a corresponding 'Second' or 'Furthermore' in the next paragraph makes the cohesive structure feel incomplete and mechanical.
What would raise the band
Focus urgently on spelling accuracy — key words like 'government', 'recycle', and 'citizens' are misspelled multiple times, which directly damages your Lexical Resource score. Before submitting any essay, re-read it once specifically to check the spelling of topic-related and high-frequency words.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people claim that not enough of the waste from homes is recycled. They say that the only way to increase recycling is for governments to make it a legal requirement. To what extent do you think laws are needed to make people recycle more of their waste?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.