Alternative medicine is as effective as modern medicine and should receive equal government support. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Alternative medicine is as effective as modern medicine and should receive equal government support. To…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: Alternative medicine is as effective as modern medicine and should receive equal government support. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Some people believe that alternative medicine, such as herbal remedies and acupuncture, is as effective as modern medicine and the government should support it equally. I disagree with this opinion, although I accept that alternative medicine has some benefits.
Firstly, modern medicine is based on science. New drugs and treatments are tested many times on thousands of patients before doctors can use them, so we know that they work and are safe. Most of the alternative methods have not passed the same tests. For example, antibiotics and vaccines have saved millions of lives, but no herbal tea can cure a serious infection or cancer. If patients use only the traditional methods in serious cases, they may lose the time and die.
Secondly, the government has limited budget and it must spend it on the things which are proven to be effective. Hospital equipment, doctors training and new research are very expensive, so it is not fair to give the same amount of money to treatments without good evidence. Also, some alternative products are not controlled and may contain dangerous substances.
However, I do not think that alternative medicine is useless. In my country, many people use herbs like ginger and honey when they have a cold, and it can make them feel better. Some methods such as acupuncture and massage may help with pain and stress. Therefore, they can be used as additional treatment together with the modern medicine, if the doctor allow it.
In conclusion, I do not agree that alternative medicine is as effective as modern medicine or that it should have equal support. The government should give priority to scientific medicine, and only support alternative methods which are proved by research.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: Words like 'herbal remedies', 'acupuncture', 'proven' and 'additional treatment' show suitable topic vocabulary. The range is limited by repetition of 'modern medicine', 'effective' and 'method', and 'lose the time and die' and 'doctors training' show imprecision.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The essay disagrees clearly and also concedes that alternative medicine has some value, so both parts of the prompt (effectiveness and equal support) are addressed. Development is uneven: the claim that 'no herbal tea can cure a serious infection or cancer' is overgeneralised, and the support for government funding is mostly assertion. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | There is a clear structure of two reasons against, one concession and a conclusion, using 'Firstly', 'Secondly' and 'However, I do not think...'. Cohesion is sometimes mechanical, and 'they can be used as additional treatment' has an unclear reference after the list of methods. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | Words like 'herbal remedies', 'acupuncture', 'proven' and 'additional treatment' show suitable topic vocabulary. The range is limited by repetition of 'modern medicine', 'effective' and 'method', and 'lose the time and die' and 'doctors training' show imprecision. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | Complex sentences with 'so', 'because' and 'if' are frequent and mostly clear, but errors recur with articles and agreement: 'the government has limited budget', 'if the doctor allow it'. These do not usually obscure meaning. |
Marked mistakes
-
the government has limited budget
the government has a limited budget (GA)
A singular countable noun needs the article. -
doctors training
doctors' training (LR)
The training of doctors needs an apostrophe: 'doctors' training'. -
if the doctor allow it
if the doctor allows it (GA)
A singular subject needs the verb ending -s. -
they may lose the time and die
they may lose valuable time and die (LR)
'Lose the time' is not natural; use 'waste time' or 'lose valuable time'. -
together with the modern medicine
together with modern medicine (GA)
'Modern medicine' is uncountable and used generally, so no article is needed.
What would raise the band
Make your claims more careful (say 'have not been shown to' rather than 'no ... can') and check singular nouns for articles and verb endings.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Alternative medicine is as effective as modern medicine and should receive equal government support. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
I disagree with both parts of this statement. The claim that alternative medicine is as effective as conventional treatment is not supported by the evidence, and equal funding would therefore be difficult to justify.
Effectiveness is measured through controlled trials in which a treatment is compared with a placebo, and by this standard most alternative therapies perform poorly. Homeopathic remedies, for example, have been tested repeatedly and generally do no better than a dummy pill, whereas conventional treatments such as antibiotics, insulin or chemotherapy have demonstrable effects on survival. The danger is not only that some remedies are useless but that patients may rely on them instead of proven care. Cases of people who delayed cancer treatment in favour of herbal alternatives, only to see the disease reach an advanced stage, show the real consequences of treating the two as equivalent.
This does not mean that traditional practices have nothing to offer. Some have given rise to important drugs: artemisinin, used against malaria, was developed from a Chinese herbal remedy once it had been tested rigorously. Acupuncture and massage may provide modest relief for chronic back pain, and patients who feel cared for often report that they feel better, which has genuine value in the management of long-term conditions.
On funding, public money should follow evidence rather than be divided equally for the sake of fairness. Health budgets are limited, and every pound spent on an unproven therapy is a pound not spent on cancer screening or mental health services. A better approach would be to fund good-quality trials of traditional treatments, support those that pass and regulate the rest more strictly, particularly in relation to advertising and the training of practitioners.
In conclusion, alternative medicine may play a supporting role, but it should be judged by the same scientific standards as any other treatment.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8.5 · CC 8 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Coherence & Cohesion at 8: The structure is logical, moving from effectiveness to the concession, then funding, then conclusion, with 'does not mean that' and 'On funding' as clear signposts. The reference of 'the two' in 'treating the two as equivalent' is clear, but the funding paragraph has a slightly abrupt start.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8.5 | The opening deals with both parts of the statement ('disagree with both parts') and the essay develops each: effectiveness through trials, then funding. Examples are specific and well chosen (homeopathy versus placebo, artemisinin from a Chinese herbal remedy) and a constructive proposal to fund trials is given. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | The structure is logical, moving from effectiveness to the concession, then funding, then conclusion, with 'does not mean that' and 'On funding' as clear signposts. The reference of 'the two' in 'treating the two as equivalent' is clear, but the funding paragraph has a slightly abrupt start. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8.5 | Vocabulary is precise and academic ('controlled trials', 'placebo', 'demonstrable effects on survival', 'regulate the rest'), with natural collocations. 'Every pound spent on an unproven therapy' shows idiomatic control, though 'pound' narrows the context to the UK. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | A wide range of structures includes contrastive, relative and infinitive clauses ('only to see the disease reach an advanced stage'), and nearly every sentence is error-free. Punctuation is accurate throughout, with the only weakness being a few long sentences that pack in several ideas. |
Marked mistakes
-
Cases of people who delayed cancer treatment in favour of herbal alternatives, only to see the disease reach an advanced stage, show the real consequences of treating the two as equivalent.
Reported cases of people who delayed cancer treatment in favour of herbal alternatives illustrate the possible consequences of treating the two as equivalent. (TR)
A few cases illustrate a risk but cannot by themselves show a general consequence.
What would raise the band
Keep the high level by qualifying anecdotal evidence slightly and by trimming the longest sentences so that each clause is easy to follow.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 answer addresses both halves of the task (effectiveness and funding) in separate paragraphs, uses the placebo-controlled trial standard to explain why evidence matters, and cites the artemisinin example to show where traditional medicine has real value. The 6.5 answer makes the same overall point but with general claims ("no herbal tea can cure a serious infection or cancer") and a homespun example (ginger and honey). The 6.5 text also has errors such as "lose the time", "doctors training", "the modern medicine" and "if the doctor allow it".
Check your essay on this task
Task: Alternative medicine is as effective as modern medicine and should receive equal government support. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.