IELTS Task 2: Mobile payments — Band 6.5 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Many people now use mobile payments and rarely carry cash. Do you think the benefits of this trend outweigh the drawbacks?

Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Many people now use mobile payments and rarely carry cash. Do you think the benefits of this trend…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: Many people now use mobile payments and rarely carry cash. Do you think the benefits of this trend outweigh the drawbacks?

Today a lot of people pay by mobile phone and they almost never use cash. I think the benefits of this trend are bigger than the drawbacks, but there are some risks that we must consider.

The first benefit is convenience. People don't need to carry a wallet and they can pay for anything in a few seconds, in a shop, in a taxi or even in a market. This saves time, especially in queues. For example, in China most people use Alipay or WeChat Pay and they can buy even a cup of tea with a phone. Another advantage is that mobile payments are more transparent. The application save the history of all purchases, so users can see how much they spend and plan their budget. Moreover, it is safer than cash in some situations, because if you lose your phone, you can block it, but if you lose your wallet, the money is gone. For shops, there is no need to count the money and to give change, so it is more efficient.

However, there are drawbacks as well. One of them is the danger of fraud. Hackers can steal personal data or money from an account, and some people become victims of fake messages from "banks". Also, mobile payments depend on technology. If the battery is dead or there is no internet, a person can't buy anything, even a bottle of water. Another problem is that elderly people or those with no smartphone have difficulties and may be excluded from the society. Besides, people spend more money when they pay by phone, because they do not feel the real money leaving their hands.

In conclusion, mobile payments are fast and comfortable, so I believe the advantages are more important. However, governments and banks should improve security and make sure that cash is still accepted for those who need it.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The writer has an adequate range with topic-specific items such as 'fraud', 'transparent', 'budget' and 'excluded'. Precision slips appear in 'excluded from the society' and in the phrase 'fake messages from "banks"', and the language is mostly everyday.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The essay addresses both sides and states that the benefits are 'bigger than the drawbacks', with concrete points such as China's Alipay and WeChat Pay and the elderly being excluded. Development is uneven: the claim that people spend more because they do not 'feel the real money leaving their hands' is added as a final idea without explanation.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 Paragraphs are clear and the sequence from convenience to transparency to safety is easy to follow, supported by 'Another advantage', 'Moreover', 'Also' and 'Besides'. The repeated use of simple additive linkers and the abrupt 'For shops...' sentence at the end of paragraph two limit cohesion.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The writer has an adequate range with topic-specific items such as 'fraud', 'transparent', 'budget' and 'excluded'. Precision slips appear in 'excluded from the society' and in the phrase 'fake messages from "banks"', and the language is mostly everyday.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 Complex sentences with 'if', 'because' and relative clauses are used, including a neat contrast between losing a phone and losing a wallet. Errors such as 'The application save the history' are visible but occasional.

Marked mistakes

  1. The application save the history of all purchases
    The application saves the history of all purchases (GA)
    A singular subject requires -s on the present-tense verb.
  2. excluded from the society
    excluded from society (LR)
    'Society' used in the general sense takes no article.
  3. Today a lot of people pay by mobile phone
    Today many people pay by mobile phone (LR)
    'A lot of' is conversational; 'many' is more formal.
  4. people spend more money when they pay by phone
    people tend to spend more when they pay by phone, which can lead to debt (TR)
    The point needs a consequence to be fully developed.

What would raise the band

Choose the exclusion of elderly people and the spending point and give each a short explanation of its effect, then proofread for article and third-person -s errors.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Many people now use mobile payments and rarely carry cash. Do you think the benefits of this trend outweigh the drawbacks?

The spread of mobile payment apps has made cash almost redundant in some cities, and many people now walk out of the house with nothing but a phone. In my opinion, the benefits of this development outweigh the drawbacks, but only if safeguards are put in place for those who could be left behind.

The attractions are easy to see. Transactions take seconds, queues move faster, and there is no need to find an ATM or carry change. Digital records also give users a clear picture of their spending, which many find useful for budgeting. For small businesses, accepting digital payments reduces the cost and risk of handling cash, and it makes it simpler to keep accounts and pay taxes, which in turn helps governments to combat the informal economy. In countries such as Kenya, services like M-Pesa have given millions of people without bank accounts access to savings and transfers for the first time, which is a significant gain for financial inclusion.

Against this, the drawbacks are not trivial. Mobile payments depend on working devices, power and network coverage, so a flat battery or a signal outage can leave someone unable to buy food or fares. Security is another concern, since criminals use phishing messages and fake apps to take over accounts, and the victims are often less experienced users. Some elderly people and those on low incomes do not own a smartphone or feel confident using one, and shops that refuse cash effectively exclude them. There is also evidence that people spend more when paying electronically, as the psychological discomfort of handing over notes disappears.

These risks call for regulation rather than rejection. Governments could require retailers to accept cash, impose stronger authentication standards on payment providers and run education campaigns about scams. With such measures in place, the convenience and efficiency of mobile payments can be enjoyed without penalising vulnerable groups.

In conclusion, mobile payments bring speed, transparency and wider financial access, and their disadvantages can be managed through sensible rules.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 7.5 · GRA 8

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 7.5: A wide, precise range is used: 'redundant', 'financial inclusion', 'phishing messages', 'take over accounts' and 'authentication standards'. Collocation slips are rare, such as 'buy food or fares', where 'fares' needs the verb 'pay'.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The position that benefits outweigh drawbacks 'only if safeguards are put in place' is clear and carried to a final paragraph proposing regulation. Development is strong, from M-Pesa in Kenya and financial inclusion to the 'informal economy' argument.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Logical sequencing with natural signposts: 'The attractions are easy to see', 'Against this' and 'These risks call for regulation'. The detail within each paragraph is linked well, though several sentences are chained with commas and 'which', slightly loading paragraph one.
Lexical Resource Band 7.5 A wide, precise range is used: 'redundant', 'financial inclusion', 'phishing messages', 'take over accounts' and 'authentication standards'. Collocation slips are rare, such as 'buy food or fares', where 'fares' needs the verb 'pay'.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8 Structures are varied and accurate, with relative clauses, 'which in turn helps governments to combat...' and conditional-like 'With such measures in place'. Errors are very rare and punctuation is controlled.

Marked mistakes

  1. unable to buy food or fares
    unable to buy food or pay fares (LR)
    Fares are paid, not bought, so the second item needs its own verb.

What would raise the band

To move closer to Band 8.5 and above, fix the occasional loose collocation (such as 'buy food or fares') and shorten the longest sentence in paragraph two.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 essay supports the 'benefits outweigh' position with developed, specific points (reduced cash handling for small businesses, M-Pesa and financial inclusion, the loss of psychological discomfort when paying electronically) and gives concrete policy measures. The 6.5 essay uses the more obvious benefits, such as convenience, and its examples are brief and more familiar. It also contains errors ('The application save', 'excluded from the society'), whereas the 8.0 text is accurate and has a more precise register.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Many people now use mobile payments and rarely carry cash. Do you think the benefits of this trend outweigh the drawbacks?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →