IELTS Task 2: Health education spending — Band 6.5 vs 8.5 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Prevention is better than cure, so governments should spend more on health education than on hospitals. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Prevention is better than cure, so governments should spend more on health education than on hospitals. To…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: Prevention is better than cure, so governments should spend more on health education than on hospitals. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Prevention is better than cure is a well-known saying. Some people believe that governments should spend more money on health education than on hospitals. I agree with this view to some extent, but I think hospitals are also important.

Firstly, if people know how to keep healthy, they will have fewer diseases and the hospitals will have less patients. For example, health education in schools can teach children about the dangers of smoking, junk food and lack of exercise. When they grow up, they will have a healthy lifestyle and will not need medical treatment so often. In this way the government can save a lot of money, because treating a serious disease like cancer or diabetes is much more expensive than preventing it.

Secondly, education can reach many people with a low cost. The government can use television, social networks and posters to explain the importance of washing hands, vaccination and regular check-ups. It was very useful during Covid, when the campaigns helped to stop the virus spreading.

However, it is not possible to reduce the spending on hospitals. Accidents and emergencies always happen, and people who have a heart attack or a broken leg need urgent treatment, not an education. Moreover, many diseases are not caused by lifestyle, for example, genetic illnesses and infections, so people cannot prevent them even if they are well educated. If the hospitals do not have enough doctors and equipment, many patients will die.

In conclusion, I agree that governments should invest more in health education because it is a cheaper and more effective way to improve health in long term, but they must not forget to maintain good hospitals for people who are already ill.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The vocabulary is sufficient for the topic (vaccination, check-ups, genetic illnesses, equipment), and meaning is clear. Collocation and form errors such as less patients, with a low cost and in long term show that the range is not yet flexible.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The essay agrees to some extent with spending more on health education while insisting that hospitals matter, a position stated clearly in the introduction and conclusion. The school education example and the Covid campaigns are relevant, but the claim that education is cheaper and more effective is supported by general statements rather than data.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The organisation is logical: reasons for education, then the need for hospitals, then a summary. Firstly, Secondly, However and Moreover are used correctly, but reference is sometimes unclear (It was very useful during Covid) and the connectors are quite mechanical.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The vocabulary is sufficient for the topic (vaccination, check-ups, genetic illnesses, equipment), and meaning is clear. Collocation and form errors such as less patients, with a low cost and in long term show that the range is not yet flexible.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 The essay uses conditionals, relative clauses and time clauses with some success. Errors with countable nouns, articles and prepositions appear in most paragraphs, but they seldom interfere with understanding.

Marked mistakes

  1. the hospitals will have less patients
    the hospitals will have fewer patients (LR)
    Patients is countable, so fewer is required.
  2. education can reach many people with a low cost
    education can reach many people at a low cost (LR)
    At a low cost is the fixed phrase.
  3. need urgent treatment, not an education
    need urgent treatment, not education (GA)
    Education in this general sense is uncountable and takes no article.
  4. in long term
    in the long term (GA)
    The phrase needs the definite article.
  5. It was very useful during Covid, when the campaigns helped to stop the virus spreading.
    This was very useful during Covid, when campaigns helped to stop the virus from spreading. (GA)
    'It' has no clear referent, so 'This' is clearer. 'Stop the virus spreading' is correct British usage, and 'from spreading' is an equally good alternative.

What would raise the band

Focus on countable and uncountable nouns (less patients, an education) and fixed phrases (at a low cost, in the long term); correcting these will lift both your lexical and grammatical bands.

Band 8.5

Prompt: Prevention is better than cure, so governments should spend more on health education than on hospitals. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

I agree that governments should devote a larger share of health budgets to prevention, but I would not accept that hospitals should be cut to pay for it, because the two serve different needs.

Prevention offers remarkable value for money. Anti-smoking campaigns, combined with tobacco taxes and advertising bans, have cut smoking rates in many countries, and with them the number of patients requiring expensive treatment for lung cancer and heart disease. Vaccination programmes cost a tiny fraction of what it would cost to treat the diseases they prevent, and smallpox was eliminated entirely. Since ageing populations are driving up the number of people with chronic illnesses like type 2 diabetes, which are strongly linked to diet and inactivity, spending that delays or prevents these conditions can ease pressure on hospitals in the future.

Education on its own, however, has a surprisingly limited effect. Most people already know that fast food and a sedentary life are unhealthy; what they lack is the opportunity or incentive to change. A worker with long hours and little money cannot be expected to cook fresh meals because a leaflet told her to. Effective prevention therefore needs more than information: it requires affordable healthy food, safe places to exercise and regulation of harmful products. If 'health education' is defined narrowly as awareness campaigns, the case for putting it ahead of hospitals is weaker than it first appears.

Hospitals also deal with a large category of problems that no amount of prevention can remove, including accidents, inherited conditions, infections and the illnesses of people who are already old. Underfunding emergency departments or cancer wards would cause immediate and often irreversible harm.

For these reasons, I think governments should gradually raise the proportion spent on prevention, including wider public health measures, while keeping hospital funding at a level that guarantees timely, high-quality treatment.

Why Band 8.5, not 9

TR 8.5 · CC 8 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Coherence & Cohesion at 8: The argument progresses logically from the value of prevention to the limits of education, then to the unavoidable role of hospitals. References like If 'health education' is defined narrowly and For these reasons are skilfully used, although the third paragraph is long and the shift to hospitals is short.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8.5 The essay takes a nuanced position, supporting more spending on prevention without cutting hospitals, and it develops this fully. It goes further by questioning whether health education alone works, which engages critically with the wording of the prompt, and the examples of anti-smoking campaigns and smallpox are well chosen.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 The argument progresses logically from the value of prevention to the limits of education, then to the unavoidable role of hospitals. References like If 'health education' is defined narrowly and For these reasons are skilfully used, although the third paragraph is long and the shift to hospitals is short.
Lexical Resource Band 8.5 The lexis is precise and natural, with phrases such as remarkable value for money, a sedentary life and irreversible harm. A very small number of choices, for example eliminated entirely, are slightly less exact than eradicated.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 The sentence patterns are varied, using relative clauses, conditionals and a colon, and nearly all sentences are accurate. Only slight wordiness in constructions such as cost a tiny fraction of what it would cost appears.

Marked mistakes

  1. smallpox was eliminated entirely
    smallpox was eradicated (LR)
    Eradicated is the standard word for removing a disease completely, so entirely is redundant.
  2. cost a tiny fraction of what it would cost to treat the diseases they prevent
    cost a tiny fraction of the price of treating the diseases they prevent (LR)
    The verb cost is repeated; a noun phrase avoids it.
  3. that no amount of prevention can remove
    that no amount of prevention can avert (LR)
    Illnesses are averted or prevented rather than removed.

What would raise the band

For an even higher score, shorten the longer middle paragraph and give the hospital paragraph an example or statistic so both sides have equal development.

What separates the higher band

The 8.5 answer questions the premise by pointing out that information alone rarely changes behaviour, and argues that prevention needs wider measures such as affordable food and regulation, whereas the 6.5 answer assumes that education automatically leads to healthy lifestyles. It also supports its points with precise examples (smoking rates, vaccination, smallpox). The 6.5 text has errors such as "less patients", "with a low cost", "in long term" and "need urgent treatment, not an education".

Check your essay on this task

Task: Prevention is better than cure, so governments should spend more on health education than on hospitals. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →