Some people believe that criminals should be sent to prison. Others think that they should be educated and given training to find jobs. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Some people believe that criminals should be sent to prison. Others think that they should be educated and…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Some people believe that criminals should be sent to prison. Others think that they should be educated and given training to find jobs. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Crime is a serious problem in every society. Some people believe that criminals must be sent to prison, but others think that it is better to educate them and give them training for jobs. I will discuss both views and then give my opinion.
On the one hand, prison is the traditional punishment for crimes, and it has some important advantages. First of all, it protects the society, because dangerous people like murderers and robbers can not hurt anybody when they are in jail. Also, the fear of prison stops many people from breaking the law. If criminals would not be punished, they will think that the crime is easy, and the crime rate will increase. Moreover, victims and their families feel that justice was done when the criminal go to prison.
On the other hand, education and training can be more useful in the long term. Many criminals have committed crimes because they were poor and did not have any profession. If they learn a skill in prison, they can find a legal job after release and they will not need to steal again. For example, in Norway prisoners study and work, and the percentage of those who return to crime is one of the lowest in the world. In contrast, in countries where prisons are only a punishment, people come out more angry and many of them commit crimes again. Besides, keeping a person in prison is very expensive for the government.
In my opinion, the best solution is to combine these two approaches. Serious criminals must be isolated from society, but at the same time they should have opportunity to study and work. For minor crimes, such as small theft, community service and training courses are better than prison.
In conclusion, I believe that punishment and education should go together. This way society is safe and criminals have a chance to change their life.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: A variety of structures is attempted, including conditionals, relative clauses and a passive, but control is uneven. The mixed conditional 'If criminals would not be punished, they will think' is faulty, and there is an agreement error in 'when the criminal go to prison'. Meaning stays clear.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | Both views are addressed with relevant points, such as protecting society and deterrence for prison, and skills for legal jobs and the Norway example for education. The opinion is clear: combine both, with community service for minor crimes. Some points, like 'keeping a person in prison is very expensive', are added without explanation. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | Paragraphing is clear and the essay progresses logically from prison to education to the combined solution. 'First of all', 'Also', 'Moreover', 'On the other hand' and 'In contrast' are used appropriately although somewhat formulaically, and referencing is generally clear. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The vocabulary is adequate and occasionally less common: 'isolated from society', 'community service', 'crime rate' and 'victims and their families'. There are some imprecise or incorrect uses, such as 'protects the society', and the repetition of 'crime' and 'prison' limits flexibility. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | A variety of structures is attempted, including conditionals, relative clauses and a passive, but control is uneven. The mixed conditional 'If criminals would not be punished, they will think' is faulty, and there is an agreement error in 'when the criminal go to prison'. Meaning stays clear. |
Marked mistakes
-
If criminals would not be punished, they will think that the crime is easy
If criminals were not punished, they would think that crime is easy (GA)
A second conditional uses 'were' in the if-clause and 'would' in the result clause, and 'crime' is general so needs no article. -
when the criminal go to prison
when the criminal goes to prison (GA)
A singular subject in the present simple needs 'goes'. -
it protects the society
it protects society (LR)
'Society' used in the general sense does not take 'the'. -
can not hurt anybody
cannot hurt anybody (GA)
'Cannot' is written as one word. -
they should have opportunity to study and work
they should have an opportunity to study and work (GA)
The singular countable noun 'opportunity' needs an article.
What would raise the band
Review conditional sentences and subject-verb agreement, since they are the main grammar errors in this essay. Also explain briefly why the high cost of prison supports the argument for education.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Some people believe that criminals should be sent to prison. Others think that they should be educated and given training to find jobs. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
When someone breaks the law, society must decide whether the priority is punishment or reform. Some insist that imprisonment is the only appropriate response, while others argue that education and job training do more good. I think the most effective policy uses both, with the emphasis depending on the seriousness of the offence.
Imprisonment has undeniable functions. It removes violent offenders from the public, which is the most immediate way of preventing further harm, and it expresses society's condemnation of serious crime. The prospect of a custodial sentence may also deter some potential offenders, such as those considering fraud or burglary. For the families of victims, seeing a perpetrator held accountable is often essential to some sense of closure, and a policy that appeared lenient could erode public trust in the justice system.
Nevertheless, prison alone has a poor record of changing behaviour. In England and Wales, close to half of released adult prisoners reoffend within a year, largely because they leave without qualifications, stable housing or employment. Rehabilitation programmes address these root causes. Norway, which emphasises vocational training and psychological support, has one of the lowest reoffending rates in Europe, and the savings from fewer repeat offenders can offset the cost of the programmes themselves. Moreover, a former offender who holds a steady job pays taxes instead of consuming public funds.
My own view is that custody should be reserved for serious and violent crime, but that every prisoner should be offered meaningful education and work experience during their sentence. For non-violent offences, community sentences combined with training are likely to prove both cheaper and more effective than a short spell behind bars, which tends to disrupt employment and family ties without teaching anything useful.
In conclusion, prison serves a legitimate purpose in protecting the public, yet it cannot by itself reduce crime in the long run. A system that couples punishment with rehabilitation delivers safer communities and better outcomes for offenders.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8.5 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource at 8: Sequencing is logical, from the functions of prison to its limits to the writer's view, and cohesion is generally well managed with 'Nevertheless', 'Moreover', 'which' clauses and 'yet'. The fourth paragraph's long closing sentence loads several ideas together, slightly reducing the smoothness of the progression.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8.5 | Both views are discussed fully, and the position, custody for serious crime with education and work for every prisoner, is stated at the start and developed in the fourth paragraph. Ideas are thoroughly supported: victims' closure, public trust, the Norway example and the cost saving from fewer repeat offenders. The reoffending statistic is approximate and unsourced. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | Sequencing is logical, from the functions of prison to its limits to the writer's view, and cohesion is generally well managed with 'Nevertheless', 'Moreover', 'which' clauses and 'yet'. The fourth paragraph's long closing sentence loads several ideas together, slightly reducing the smoothness of the progression. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | The vocabulary is wide and precise: 'custodial sentence', 'condemnation', 'perpetrator', 'rehabilitation programmes', 'reoffending' and 'closure' are used accurately with good collocation. One choice, 'spell behind bars', is slightly informal for the register, and there are no spelling errors. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | A wide range of structures is used, including relative clauses, participles ('combined with training'), a 'while' contrast and conditional ideas, with nearly every sentence error-free. Punctuation, including commas around non-defining clauses such as 'Norway, which emphasises vocational training', is accurate. |
Marked mistakes
-
close to half of released adult prisoners reoffend within a year
nearly half of released adult prisoners are reconvicted within a year, according to official figures (TR)
The figure is already given as an approximation, but naming its source would make it more convincing.
What would raise the band
Name the source of statistics or soften them with phrases like 'roughly' or 'according to government data', and keep a consistent formal register in minor word choices.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay uses precise evidence (the reoffending rate in England and Wales, Norway's vocational approach, fiscal savings) and differentiates between serious and non-violent offences when stating its position, so the opinion is nuanced and consistently supported. The 6.0 essay reaches the same compromise but its support is thinner and uses broader statements ('people come out more angry'). The 8.5 text also avoids the grammatical slips seen in the 6.0 text, such as 'If criminals would not be punished, they will think', 'the criminal go to prison' and 'can not hurt'.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people believe that criminals should be sent to prison. Others think that they should be educated and given training to find jobs. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.