IELTS Task 2: Personality: nature or nurture — Band 5.5 sample

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people believe that an individual's personality is determined by their genetic makeup from birth. Others argue that personality is shaped primarily by life experiences and environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 5.5

A real IELTS practice essay scored Band 5.5 by AI on the topic: Some people believe that an individual's personality is determined by their genetic makeup from birth. Others . Read it, then get your own essay graded.

Band 5.5

Prompt: Some people believe that an individual's personality is determined by their genetic makeup from birth. Others argue that personality is shaped primarily by life experiences and environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Some people believe that an individual's personality is determined by their genetic makeup from birth. Others argue that personality is shaped primarily by life experiences and environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree? DNA is the code that shapes most of our specificities in terms of individual. It underlies what makes us special and different from others. While it creates visual and physical differences among us, the question of whether it determines completely our personality is more complex. Personally, I believe that personality is built through personal experiences. What you lived and felt makes who you are, it isn't pre-determined from your birth. On the one hand, personality defines a whole other part of an individual. It can't be fixed by genetics. The way you interact, and think is so complex that it can only be the result of your own experience. One person's mind is affected by its environment and its connection with the surrounding world. For example, the personality of the French people differs greatly from English people. Culture impacts who you are and indeed, personality must derive from what you lived. Furthermore, saying that genetics determines your way of reasoning, communicating or even interacting, is paradoxical with free will. It would mean that right from birth, many things, such as your job or your friends, would be predetermined. I believe that thinking in such a way can discourage you from making your own path in life. For example, knowing that right from birth the person you will become is fixed, doesn't push your limits or make you want to broaden your horizons. Thinking in such a way affects your own way of experiencing life. Finally, an individual's personality can't be the result of DNA. It without a doubt contributes partially to it but doesn't determine it. Travelling, discovering new places, making friends for life are what shape your mind.

Why Band 5.5, not 6

TR 5.5 · CC 6 · LR 5.5 · GRA 5.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: The candidate takes a clear position (personality is shaped by experience, not genetics) and maintains it throughout. However, the task asks 'to what extent do you agree or disagree?', which requires a more nuanced discussion. The opposing view (genetics) is mentioned only to be dismissed, not genuinely explored. Ideas are stated rather than developed — the French/English example is vague and unsupported, and the free will argument is interesting but not fully extended. The conclusion is very brief and adds little new substance.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 5.5 The candidate takes a clear position (personality is shaped by experience, not genetics) and maintains it throughout. However, the task asks 'to what extent do you agree or disagree?', which requires a more nuanced discussion. The opposing view (genetics) is mentioned only to be dismissed, not genuinely explored. Ideas are stated rather than developed — the French/English example is vague and unsupported, and the free will argument is interesting but not fully extended. The conclusion is very brief and adds little new substance.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6 There is a clear overall structure with an introduction, body paragraphs, and a conclusion, and linking phrases such as 'On the one hand', 'Furthermore', and 'Finally' are used to signal progression. However, 'On the one hand' implies a contrasting 'On the other hand' that never appears, creating a structural imbalance. Cohesive devices are sometimes mechanical or misused. Paragraphing is present but the final paragraph is underdeveloped as a conclusion.
Lexical Resource Band 5.5 There is some range of vocabulary (e.g. 'paradoxical', 'predetermined', 'broaden your horizons'), but the essay also relies on repetitive phrasing ('what you lived', 'thinking in such a way' used twice). Several word-form and collocation errors are present: 'specificities in terms of individual', 'what you lived and felt makes who you are', 'it can't be fixed by genetics'. The phrase 'broaden your horizons' is a cliché. Overall, the range is limited and errors occasionally reduce precision.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 5.5 The essay uses a mix of simple and complex structures, and some sentences are well-formed. However, there are recurring grammatical errors: incorrect pronoun use ('its environment' instead of 'their environment'), comma splices ('What you lived and felt makes who you are, it isn't pre-determined'), missing articles, and awkward constructions ('shapes most of our specificities in terms of individual'). Errors are frequent enough to occasionally reduce clarity.

Marked mistakes

  1. For example, the personality of the French people differs greatly from English people.
    For example, research shows that individuals raised in collectivist cultures, such as Japan, tend to develop more reserved and group-oriented personalities compared to those raised in more individualistic societies. (TR)
    The French/English example is vague and stereotypical — it makes a broad cultural claim without any explanation of how or why environment shapes personality, which weakens the argument significantly.
  2. On the one hand, personality defines a whole other part of an individual.
    Firstly, personality defines a dimension of an individual that goes far beyond genetics. (CC)
    'On the one hand' signals that a contrasting 'on the other hand' will follow, but it never does — this creates a structural imbalance and misleads the reader about the essay's organisation.
  3. What you lived and felt makes who you are, it isn't pre-determined from your birth.
    What you have lived and felt makes you who you are; it is not predetermined from birth. (GA)
    Two independent clauses are joined with only a comma, which is a comma splice — they should be separated by a semicolon, a full stop, or a conjunction.
  4. One person's mind is affected by its environment and its connection with the surrounding world.
    One person's mind is affected by their environment and their connection with the surrounding world. (GA)
    When referring to a person, 'their' should be used rather than 'its', which is reserved for objects or animals.
  5. DNA is the code that shapes most of our specificities in terms of individual.
    DNA is the code that shapes most of our individual characteristics. (LR)
    'Specificities in terms of individual' is an unnatural and imprecise collocation — 'individual characteristics' or 'personal traits' would be far more idiomatic and precise.

What would raise the band

Focus on developing each idea fully before moving to the next: state your point, explain the reasoning behind it, give a specific and concrete example, and then link it back to your thesis — this single habit will raise both your Task Response and Coherence scores significantly.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people believe that an individual's personality is determined by their genetic makeup from birth. Others argue that personality is shaped primarily by life experiences and environment. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →