IELTS Task 2: Prison vs community work — Band 6.5 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Prison is not an effective punishment, and criminals should do community work instead. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Prison is not an effective punishment, and criminals should do community work instead. To what extent do…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: Prison is not an effective punishment, and criminals should do community work instead. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Some people argue that prison is not an effective punishment and criminals should do community work instead. I partly agree with this statement. For minor crimes, community work is better, but for serious crimes prison is still necessary.

On the one hand, prison has many problems. It is very expensive for the government to keep thousands of prisoners, and the money could be used for schools or hospitals. In addition, when young people who did a small crime are put in prison with dangerous criminals, they learn bad habits from them and often come back to prison after release. For example, in many countries, more than half of the prisoners commit crimes again. Community work can be a better punishment, because the offender have to repair the damage to society, for instance by cleaning parks or helping elderly people. They also keep their jobs and families, so it is easier for them to start a normal life.

On the other hand, community work is not suitable for everyone. Murderers, rapists and other violent criminals are dangerous for the society and they must be separated from the other people. If they are free, they could hurt somebody again. Also, the victims and their families would feel that it is not fair if the criminal receive only a light punishment. Another problem is that people might not take community work seriously, because it is not so frightening as prison, and the crime rate may increase.

In my opinion, the courts should look at every case individually. Prison should be used for serious and violent crimes, and community work for thieves, drivers who break the rules and young offenders.

To sum up, prison is not always effective, so alternative punishments should be used more often, but they cannot completely replace it.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: Topic words such as 'offender', 'release', 'violent criminals' and 'alternative punishments' are suitable. The essay repeats 'prison', 'punishment' and 'crime' and uses some imprecise phrasing, e.g. 'a small crime'.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 'I partly agree' is a clear position, and the split between minor crimes (community work) and serious crimes (prison) is carried through to the conclusion. Support is sound but general, for example 'more than half of the prisoners commit crimes again' has no source and 'the crime rate may increase' is only asserted.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The 'On the one hand' and 'On the other hand' structure gives a clear progression, and the paragraph 'In my opinion, the courts should look at every case individually' is a useful bridge. 'In addition' and 'Also' are used mechanically.
Lexical Resource Band 6 Topic words such as 'offender', 'release', 'violent criminals' and 'alternative punishments' are suitable. The essay repeats 'prison', 'punishment' and 'crime' and uses some imprecise phrasing, e.g. 'a small crime'.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 The range includes relative clauses, conditionals and 'because' constructions, with several error-free long sentences. Agreement slips such as 'the offender have' and 'the criminal receive' and the article in 'dangerous for the society' recur.

Marked mistakes

  1. because the offender have to repair the damage to society
    because the offender has to repair the damage to society (GA)
    A singular subject takes 'has'.
  2. are dangerous for the society
    are dangerous for society (GA)
    'Society' used in the general sense takes no article.
  3. if the criminal receive only a light punishment
    if the criminal receives only a light punishment (GA)
    'The criminal' is singular so the verb needs -s.
  4. young people who did a small crime
    young people who committed a minor offence (LR)
    'Commit an offence' is the standard collocation and 'minor' is more natural than 'small'.
  5. They also keep their jobs and families
    Offenders also keep their jobs and stay with their families (CC)
    'Keep their families' is an odd collocation; 'stay with their families' is natural. Using 'they' after 'the offender' is acceptable, but naming 'Offenders' makes the general reference clearer.

What would raise the band

Check every singular subject for verb agreement, and replace general claims with a precise reason or source so that each point is fully developed.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Prison is not an effective punishment, and criminals should do community work instead. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

I agree that prison is overused, particularly for minor offences, but I do not accept that it can be replaced altogether by community work.

Imprisonment is usually justified by four aims: protecting the public, deterring others, punishing wrongdoing and reforming the offender. On the last two, the record is poor. Short sentences in particular tend to be counterproductive: they remove people from their jobs and housing, and expose petty offenders to hardened criminals, so many leave in a worse position than they entered. Reoffending rates in some countries exceed fifty per cent within two years. By contrast, a well-supervised community sentence, such as unpaid work for a local charity, keeps offenders in employment and close to their families, and forces them to make visible amends. It is also far cheaper, which matters when prison budgets compete with schools and hospitals.

Evidence suggests that the way custody is organised matters as much as its use. Norway's prisons concentrate on education and vocational training, and the country has one of the lowest reoffending rates in the world. That suggests that where prison does exist, its purpose should be rehabilitation rather than simply confinement.

Nonetheless, prison cannot be dispensed with for people who pose a danger to others. A violent offender or a serial burglar cannot safely be left in the community, and the public rightly expects the state to protect it. There is also a moral argument that very serious crimes require a serious response, which community work, however useful, would not convey to the victims.

The best approach, therefore, is to reserve custody for dangerous and persistent offenders and to expand community sentences for non-violent and first-time offenders, supported by proper supervision so that they are not seen as a soft option.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 7.5 · GRA 8

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 7.5: Vocabulary is wide and mostly precise: 'counterproductive', 'petty offenders', 'make visible amends', 'dispensed with'. A few phrases such as 'hardened criminals' and 'a soft option' rely on stock collocations, and the repeated verb 'suggest' and the word 'serious' show small lapses in variety.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The first sentence gives a nuanced position (prison overused but not replaceable) and the essay fully addresses both sides. The Norway example and the four aims of imprisonment give depth, though the statistic 'exceed fifty per cent within two years' is not sourced and the 'serial burglar' claim is asserted.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Paragraphs follow a logical order of aims, evidence from Norway, limits of community work and recommendation, and 'By contrast' and 'Nonetheless' mark the shifts clearly. 'That suggests that' repeats 'Evidence suggests' from the preceding sentence, which is mildly repetitive.
Lexical Resource Band 7.5 Vocabulary is wide and mostly precise: 'counterproductive', 'petty offenders', 'make visible amends', 'dispensed with'. A few phrases such as 'hardened criminals' and 'a soft option' rely on stock collocations, and the repeated verb 'suggest' and the word 'serious' show small lapses in variety.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8 There is a variety of complex structures, including colon-introduced explanation, 'where prison does exist' and nominal clauses, with most sentences error-free. The use of 'so many leave in a worse position than they entered' is slightly clipped but correct, and punctuation is secure.

Marked mistakes

  1. Reoffending rates in some countries exceed fifty per cent within two years.
    In England and Wales, for example, around half of short-sentence prisoners reoffend within a year. (TR)
    Naming a country gives the figure real force instead of the vague 'some countries'.
  2. That suggests that where prison does exist
    This implies that where prison does exist (LR)
    The previous sentence already begins with 'Evidence suggests', so a synonym avoids repetition.
  3. A violent offender or a serial burglar cannot safely be left in the community
    A violent offender or a persistent burglar poses too great a risk to be left in the community (TR)
    The absolute 'cannot' is too strong for burglars, whose risk is of a different kind from violence.

What would raise the band

Name the source or country for each statistic and vary reporting verbs such as 'suggest' to reach the top lexical bands.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 answer analyses the purposes of punishment (protection, deterrence, retribution, reform) and shows which of them prison fails to meet, while the 6.5 answer states its pros and cons without a framework. It also adds the Norwegian example to show that the type of prison matters, and suggests supervision to prevent community work being seen as a soft option. The 6.5 text has errors such as "the offender have", "the criminal receive" and "dangerous for the society", and it repeats "prison", "punishment" and "crime".

Check your essay on this task

Task: Prison is not an effective punishment, and criminals should do community work instead. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →