IELTS Task 2: Hiring local workers only — Band 6.5 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people believe that international companies should hire local workers only. Others think they should be free to hire from anywhere. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people believe that international companies should hire local workers only. Others think they should…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: Some people believe that international companies should hire local workers only. Others think they should be free to hire from anywhere. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Nowadays many international companies open offices in different countries. Some people believe that these companies should employ only local workers, but others think they should be free to hire people from any place. I will discuss both views in this essay.

Firstly, there are some reasons why companies should hire local people. In many countries the unemployment is high, and foreign companies, which earn money in that country, should give jobs to its citizens. Also, local workers know the language, culture and the market very well, so they can communicate with customers easier. For example, a company that sells food in India need to understand local tastes, and an Indian employee will do this better than a foreigner. Moreover, hiring local workers is cheaper because the company don't need to pay for the visa, flights and housing.

On the other hand, companies need freedom to find the best employees. Sometimes the local people do not have the skills or experience which the company needs, especially in new technologies. In this case, the company must bring specialists from abroad, and they can also train the local workers and share their knowledge. Furthermore, if the law force the companies to hire only locals, they can decide not to open business in that country at all, and the country will lose investments and new jobs. Another advantage of the freedom is that a mix of nationalities in the team brings different ideas and makes the company more creative.

In my opinion, companies should hire mostly local people, but they should also have right to bring foreign experts for the positions which cannot be filled locally. The government can set a rule that the majority of the employees must be local.

To conclude, I think that the best way is a balance between local and foreign workers.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The writer uses reasonable topical vocabulary ('investments', 'specialists', 'unemployment') and tries to vary 'hire' with 'employ'. Precision is limited by phrases like 'the unemployment is high' and 'communicate with customers easier'.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 Both views are discussed and the opinion (mostly local, with experts allowed where skills are missing) is consistent. Ideas like the Indian food company and the threat of investors leaving are relevant, but 'hiring local workers is cheaper' is only partly explained and the opinion paragraph is brief.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The essay has clear introduction, two body paragraphs, opinion and conclusion. Linkers such as 'Moreover', 'Furthermore' and 'In this case' work, although 'Firstly' appears without a 'Secondly' and 'Also' is used as a mechanical starter.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The writer uses reasonable topical vocabulary ('investments', 'specialists', 'unemployment') and tries to vary 'hire' with 'employ'. Precision is limited by phrases like 'the unemployment is high' and 'communicate with customers easier'.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 A reasonable range of sentence forms is used, with subordinate clauses ('which earn money in that country') and conditionals. Agreement errors recur ('the company don't need', 'the law force', 'a company ... need to understand'), plus missing articles, but they rarely obscure meaning.

Marked mistakes

  1. a company that sells food in India need to understand local tastes
    a company that sells food in India needs to understand local tastes (GA)
    The singular subject 'a company' requires 'needs'.
  2. because the company don't need to pay for the visa
    because the company doesn't need to pay for the visa (GA)
    'Company' is singular, so the auxiliary must be 'doesn't'.
  3. if the law force the companies to hire only locals
    if the law forces companies to hire only locals (GA)
    The singular 'law' needs the -s form of the verb.
  4. In many countries the unemployment is high
    In many countries unemployment is high (LR)
    An abstract uncountable noun used generally takes no article.
  5. they can communicate with customers easier
    they can communicate with customers more easily (GA)
    An adverb is needed to modify the verb 'communicate'.

What would raise the band

Do a dedicated agreement check: find each singular noun like 'company' or 'law' and confirm the verb ends in -s, since this error is the main factor holding back your grammar score.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Some people believe that international companies should hire local workers only. Others think they should be free to hire from anywhere. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

When a multinational company sets up operations abroad, it often faces expectations that it will create jobs for local people. Some argue that hiring should be restricted to residents, while others say firms must be free to recruit wherever the best candidates live. I believe that companies should be encouraged, but not legally forced, to employ locally, because strict quotas often harm the very economies they aim to help.

The argument for local hiring is persuasive on social grounds. A foreign firm benefits from the host country's infrastructure, market and tax incentives, so it is reasonable for residents to expect a share of the employment it generates. Local employees understand language, consumer behaviour and business etiquette, which can be decisive in sales or customer service. Employing residents also keeps wages circulating in the local economy and avoids resentment, which can make a company's position uncomfortable if people feel they are treated as outsiders.

However, compulsion has costs. Specialised industries, such as semiconductor design or offshore engineering, sometimes need skills that a country has not yet developed, and a rule preventing recruitment from abroad could make a project impossible. Faced with such limits, investors may simply choose another country, taking jobs and tax revenue with them. Foreign professionals can also transfer knowledge; Vietnam's electronics sector, for instance, grew partly because expatriate managers trained local technicians who later moved to domestic firms. Diverse teams can also generate fresh ideas through combining different experience.

Considering both sides, I think governments should offer incentives, such as tax breaks, to companies that train and promote local staff, and should require that foreign hires are temporary where local alternatives could be developed. This encourages the transfer of skills without scaring away investment.

In conclusion, hiring local workers has social and practical advantages, but rigid quotas risk deterring investment and restricting expertise. Incentives, rather than prohibitions, offer a more effective route to balanced employment.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 7.5 · GRA 8

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 7.5: Vocabulary such as 'quotas', 'expatriate managers', 'transfer of skills', 'tax incentives' and 'deterring investment' is precise and flexible. A few phrases are slightly off, for example 'through combining different experience', and 'avoids resentment, which can make a company's position uncomfortable' is a little awkward.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The thesis ('encouraged, but not legally forced, to employ locally') is stated up front and delivered through incentives and temporary foreign hires. The Vietnamese electronics example and the semiconductor and offshore engineering cases extend the argument, though the Vietnam claim is asserted rather than evidenced.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8.5 The essay flows from the social case to the costs of compulsion and then to a solution, with signposts like 'However', 'Faced with such limits' and 'Considering both sides'. Referencing ('such limits', 'This encourages') is seamless and each paragraph has an obvious topic.
Lexical Resource Band 7.5 Vocabulary such as 'quotas', 'expatriate managers', 'transfer of skills', 'tax incentives' and 'deterring investment' is precise and flexible. A few phrases are slightly off, for example 'through combining different experience', and 'avoids resentment, which can make a company's position uncomfortable' is a little awkward.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8 Sentence variety is strong, with participial openings ('Faced with such limits'), relative clauses and a semicolon. Accuracy is high; slips are limited to a gerund-plus-preposition choice and the count noun 'experience'.

Marked mistakes

  1. through combining different experience
    by combining different experiences (LR)
    After 'different', the countable plural 'experiences' is needed to mean varied backgrounds; 'by combining' is also the more usual way to express means.
  2. Vietnam's electronics sector, for instance, grew partly because expatriate managers trained local technicians who later moved to domestic firms
    Vietnam's electronics sector, for instance, is often said to have grown partly because expatriate managers trained local technicians who later moved to domestic firms (TR)
    Hedging this specific causal claim would keep the example accurate without a source.
  3. which can make a company's position uncomfortable
    which can damage a company's reputation (LR)
    'Position uncomfortable' is vague; 'reputation' states the consequence precisely.

What would raise the band

Make your lexis fully natural by proofreading for small preposition and countable-noun choices ('by combining', 'experiences'), and hedge specific factual claims.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 essay argues for a specific policy (incentives and temporary foreign hires rather than quotas) and supports both sides with sector-specific reasoning such as semiconductor design, the loss of investment and Vietnam's expatriate trainers. The 6.5 essay proposes a general majority-local rule, with supporting points that are valid but less specific. It also contains grammatical errors that the 8.0 text avoids, for example 'the unemployment is high', 'need to understand', 'the company don't need', 'if the law force' and 'have right'.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people believe that international companies should hire local workers only. Others think they should be free to hire from anywhere. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →