Animal testing is acceptable if it leads to the development of life-saving medicines for humans. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Animal testing is acceptable if it leads to the development of life-saving medicines for humans. To what…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: Animal testing is acceptable if it leads to the development of life-saving medicines for humans. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Animal testing is a controversial topic. Some people think it is acceptable if it helps scientists to develop medicines that save human lives. I agree with this opinion, but only in certain conditions.
The main reason is that new medicines must be tested before they are given to people. If a drug is not tested, it could be dangerous and kill the patients. Animals like mice and monkeys have a body similar to humans, so scientists can see the side effects and decide whether the medicine is safe. For example, the vaccines against Covid-19 were tested on animals first, and thanks to this million of people were saved. In my opinion, human life is more valuable than animal life, so it is acceptable to use animals for such a important purpose.
However, I think that animal testing should not be used for everything. Many companies test cosmetics, shampoo and perfumes on rabbits and it causes them great pain, which is not necessary because these products do not save anybody's life. This kind of testing should be banned completely by the law. Also, scientists must treat animals in a humane way, and they should use as few animals as possible and avoid the pain.
Another point is that today there are some alternatives, such as computer models and tests on human cells. If these methods are developed, the need for animals will decrease in future. Therefore, governments should give more money for such research.
In conclusion, I believe that animal testing is acceptable when it leads to life-saving medicine, because human lives are more important, but it must be limited, controlled and replaced by other methods when it is possible.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: Vocabulary is adequate and topic-appropriate ('side effects', 'humane way', 'alternatives'), but repeated words like 'medicine', 'people' and 'pain' show limited range. 'such a important purpose' and 'million of people' are word-form slips, and 'give more money for such research' is an imprecise collocation.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The position 'I agree ... but only in certain conditions' is stated at once and kept to the end, and the cosmetics-on-rabbits point is a good limiting condition. Support is thin in places: the Covid-19 vaccine example is only asserted, and the idea that alternatives will reduce animal use is not developed beyond one sentence. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | Paragraphs are clear and each has a topic, moving from medicine safety to cosmetics to alternatives. Linkers such as 'However', 'Also', 'Another point is that' and 'Therefore' are correct but basic, and 'Also,' at the start of a sentence in paragraph three is mechanical. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | Vocabulary is adequate and topic-appropriate ('side effects', 'humane way', 'alternatives'), but repeated words like 'medicine', 'people' and 'pain' show limited range. 'such a important purpose' and 'million of people' are word-form slips, and 'give more money for such research' is an imprecise collocation. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | There is a good mix of simple and complex sentences, including conditionals ('If a drug is not tested, it could be dangerous') and relative clauses. Errors recur in articles, plurals and prepositions, for example 'such a important purpose' and 'in future', but meaning stays clear. |
Marked mistakes
-
thanks to this million of people were saved
thanks to this, millions of people were saved (LR)
'Million' needs the plural 'millions' before 'of', and a comma is needed after 'this'. -
for such a important purpose
for such an important purpose (GA)
Use 'an' before a vowel sound; the pattern is 'such an + adjective + noun'. -
the need for animals will decrease in future
the need for animals will decrease in the future (GA)
'In the future' needs the article in this meaning. -
governments should give more money for such research
governments should allocate more funding to such research (LR)
'Give money for' is awkward; 'allocate funding to' or 'invest more in' is the natural collocation. -
avoid the pain
avoid causing unnecessary pain (LR)
Scientists avoid causing pain; the bare phrase does not say who suffers it or why it matters.
What would raise the band
Replace general claims like 'vaccines against Covid-19 were tested on animals' with a short explained example (what was tested and what it showed), and proofread for articles and plural forms.
Band 8.0
Prompt: Animal testing is acceptable if it leads to the development of life-saving medicines for humans. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
I agree with this statement, with the proviso that it applies only to research with a real prospect of saving lives and only where no workable alternative exists.
The justification is that, at present, there is no complete substitute for a living organism. A drug affects the immune system, the liver, the heart and the nervous system at the same time, and these interactions cannot yet be reproduced reliably in a test tube. Before a new treatment reaches humans, regulators require evidence from animal studies about toxicity and dosage, precisely because the cost of getting it wrong is measured in human lives. The development of insulin for diabetics and of vaccines against polio and Covid-19 all depended on such research, and it is difficult to argue that the suffering of laboratory animals outweighs the survival of millions of people.
Acceptance should not be unconditional, though. Animals can feel pain and fear, and this places a duty on researchers to minimise harm. The widely adopted principle of the three Rs, which stands for replacing animals where possible, reducing the numbers used and refining procedures to reduce suffering, is a reasonable framework, and it should be enforced through inspections and legal penalties. Experiments for cosmetics or household products fail the test altogether, since a new lipstick does not justify an animal's pain, and many countries have been right to ban them.
It is also worth recognising that animal models are far from perfect, as many drugs that look safe in mice fail in human trials. This is a reason to invest in alternatives such as organ-on-a-chip technology and computer simulations, which may eventually replace much of the current testing and produce more reliable results.
Overall, animal testing is ethically defensible when it is necessary, tightly regulated and aimed at serious medical need, but the long-term aim should be to make it unnecessary.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource at 8: The opening gives a precise, conditional position ('with the proviso that it applies only to research with a real prospect of saving lives') and the essay holds it throughout. Ideas are well supported by insulin, polio vaccines and the three Rs principle, though the concession that animal models are 'far from perfect' is introduced somewhat briefly.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The opening gives a precise, conditional position ('with the proviso that it applies only to research with a real prospect of saving lives') and the essay holds it throughout. Ideas are well supported by insulin, polio vaccines and the three Rs principle, though the concession that animal models are 'far from perfect' is introduced somewhat briefly. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | The argument progresses logically from justification to limits to the imperfection of animal models, with 'though', 'also' and 'Overall' used naturally. Each paragraph has one clear central topic, and 'this places a duty' refers back cleanly, though the first sentence does not restate the question. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8 | Precise, less common vocabulary is used with good collocation: 'no complete substitute', 'toxicity and dosage', 'ethically defensible', 'tightly regulated'. A few phrases such as 'fail the test altogether' are slightly loose, but errors are rare. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | A wide range of structures appears, including a non-defining relative clause carrying a list of gerund phrases ('which stands for replacing animals where possible, reducing...'), causal clauses ('since a new lipstick does not justify an animal's pain') and complex relative clauses, and most sentences are error-free. Punctuation is controlled, with only a very long sentence about the three Rs that comes close to overloading. |
Marked mistakes
-
I agree with this statement, with the proviso that
I agree that animal testing is acceptable when it produces life-saving medicines, with the proviso that (TR)
The reader needs the topic named, since 'this statement' only makes sense if the prompt is in view. -
Experiments for cosmetics or household products fail the test altogether
Experiments for cosmetics or household products cannot be justified at all (LR)
'Fail the test' is vague here and echoes the earlier 'test tube' and 'testing' in a confusing way.
What would raise the band
Restate the question in your own words in the opening sentence, and split very long sentences such as the one on the three Rs so that each carries a single idea.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 answer explains why animals are still needed (interactions between organs cannot be reproduced in a test tube) and introduces a recognised ethical framework, the three Rs, with an enforcement mechanism. It also notes that animal models are imperfect, which adds a layer the 6.5 answer lacks. The 6.5 answer makes the same basic points about cosmetics and alternatives but in general terms, and has errors such as "million of people", "such a important purpose" and "give more money for".
Check your essay on this task
Task: Animal testing is acceptable if it leads to the development of life-saving medicines for humans. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.