IELTS Task 2: TV and films as information — Band 6 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people believe that television and films are the main source of information about the world. Others think books are more reliable. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people believe that television and films are the main source of information about the world. Others…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Some people believe that television and films are the main source of information about the world. Others think books are more reliable. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Today people can get information from many sources. Some people believe that television and films are the main source of knowledge about the world, but others think that books are more reliable. I will discuss both views and give my own opinion.

On the one hand, television and films have some big advantages. They show real pictures and videos, so it is easier to understand things and remember them. For example, a documentary about the oceans can show animals that we will never see in our life, and it is more interesting than reading a description. Moreover, news programmes inform people about events immediately, when they are happening. Also, watching TV does not need much effort, so even children and old people who dislike reading can learn something from it.

On the other hand, books are considered more reliable by many people. Before a book is published, the author and the editors usually check the facts carefully, and it take a long time to write it. In contrast, television programmes are made quickly and they sometimes show only one side of the story, because the owners of the channels want to get more viewers or support some political party. Films are mostly made for entertainment, so the history in them is often changed to make it more dramatic. Another advantage of books is that they give deeper and more detailed information about a subject than a one-hour programme.

In my opinion, books are the more trustworthy source, especially for education and serious topics. But I think that television is very useful as a starting point which can make people interested in a subject. After that, they can read books to find out more.

In conclusion, both television and books are important for getting information. However, I believe that books are more reliable and people should not depend only on the screen.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6 · CC 6.5 · LR 5.5 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 5.5: The range is limited and repeats words like 'show' and 'information'. There are some good items, for example 'reliable', 'trustworthy' and 'dramatic', but 'in our life' shows imprecise phrasing.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6 Both views are discussed and the writer states that books are 'the more trustworthy source', with television as a 'starting point'. Ideas like the ocean documentary are relevant, but claims such as 'television programmes are made quickly' are asserted without explanation or support.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The essay has a clear overall shape, with 'On the one hand', 'On the other hand' and 'In contrast' signalling the contrast. Linkers such as 'Moreover', 'Also' and 'Another advantage' are used somewhat mechanically, and 'Also' is a weak sentence opener in a formal essay.
Lexical Resource Band 5.5 The range is limited and repeats words like 'show' and 'information'. There are some good items, for example 'reliable', 'trustworthy' and 'dramatic', but 'in our life' shows imprecise phrasing.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 The writer manages relative clauses and 'because'/'so' structures, but accuracy slips in places, for example 'it take a long time to write it'. Most errors are small and rarely impede understanding.

Marked mistakes

  1. it take a long time to write it
    it takes a long time to write (GA)
    'It' requires 'takes', and the repeated object 'it' is unnecessary.
  2. animals that we will never see in our life
    animals that we will never see in our lives (LR)
    With the plural subject 'we', 'in our lives' is the more natural form.
  3. television programmes are made quickly
    television programmes are often produced under tight deadlines, so fewer checks are made (TR)
    The claim is stated as fact but needs an explanation of why speed leads to unreliability.

What would raise the band

Replace repeated 'show/information' with more precise words and develop the claim that TV is made quickly with a specific consequence. Also proofread for small agreement errors.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Some people believe that television and films are the main source of information about the world. Others think books are more reliable. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

A century ago, most people learned about distant places and events from newspapers and books. Today, screens have taken over much of that role, which has led some to claim that television and film are now our primary window on the world, while others maintain that books remain the more dependable source. In my view, each serves a different purpose, but books are better for accurate understanding.

Visual media have clear strengths. Footage of a flood, an election or a rainforest conveys scale and emotion in a way text cannot, and it reaches audiences who may be unable or unwilling to read long texts. News channels can broadcast events as they unfold, and documentaries such as those on the natural world have introduced millions of people to subjects they would never have chosen to study. For many, especially in countries with lower literacy rates, television is the only practical channel of information.

Books, nevertheless, tend to be more reliable and more thorough. A non-fiction title usually goes through months of research, expert review and editing, and its sources can be traced in footnotes. Broadcasters, on the other hand, work under commercial and time pressure; a news item may last ninety seconds and favour dramatic images over context, while fictional films routinely alter history for entertainment, as seen in many historical dramas. A reader can also pause, reread and reflect, which allows complex arguments to be absorbed rather than simply watched.

Given these differences, I believe books should be the foundation of anyone's understanding of the world, with television and film acting as supplements that capture current events and stimulate curiosity. A documentary may spark an interest in, say, the Roman Empire, but only a good history book can explain why it declined.

In conclusion, television and film are the most accessible sources, but books provide greater accuracy and depth. A well-informed person will use both, giving priority to the written word when the truth matters most.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource at 8: Both views are developed with concrete support (flood footage, the literacy argument, footnotes, a ninety-second news item) and the position that books are better for accurate understanding is clear from the introduction. A few assertions such as 'only a good history book can explain why it declined' are generalised.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 Both views are developed with concrete support (flood footage, the literacy argument, footnotes, a ninety-second news item) and the position that books are better for accurate understanding is clear from the introduction. A few assertions such as 'only a good history book can explain why it declined' are generalised.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 The historical hook, then 'Visual media have clear strengths', 'Books, nevertheless' and 'Given these differences' give a clear, logical sequence. Referencing like 'its sources can be traced' is neat, though the essay relies on a fairly predictable contrast pattern.
Lexical Resource Band 8 Vocabulary is flexible and precise: 'conveys scale and emotion', 'dependable', 'foundation', 'supplements', 'stimulate curiosity'. There is a small repetition of 'read'.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 Complex structures are used with ease, for example participial phrases, relative clauses and the semicolon in 'work under commercial and time pressure; a news item may last ninety seconds'. The vast majority of sentences are error-free.

Marked mistakes

  1. only a good history book can explain why it declined
    a good history book is better placed to explain why it declined (TR)
    'Only' excludes all other sources, which is too absolute.

What would raise the band

Keep hedging on sweeping statements ('only', 'cannot') and add one fully worked example in the body paragraph about books to reach the very top of the band.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 essay contrasts the two media with concrete features such as the traceable sources in footnotes, a ninety-second news item, and altered history in fiction films, and ends with an illustrative example of a documentary sparking interest versus a book explaining causes. The 6.0 essay gives acceptable but more general contrasts ('more interesting', 'the owners of the channels want to get more viewers'). The 8.0 text is also more accurate and varied grammatically, whereas the 6.0 text includes errors like 'it take a long time' and 'in our life' alongside repeated 'also/moreover' linking.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people believe that television and films are the main source of information about the world. Others think books are more reliable. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →