The two pie charts below show the percentages of energy produced from different sources in a country in 1985 and 2003. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.
2 real answers to “The two pie charts below show the percentages of energy produced from different sources in a country in…” (Band 6–7), graded on the official criteria — see what separates the bands, then get yours graded free.
Band 6.0 · real student answer
Prompt: The two pie charts below show the percentages of energy produced from different sources in a country in 1985 and 2003. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.
The pie charts compare the proportions of energy produced from different sources in a country in 1985 and 2003.
Overall, coal was the dominant source of energy in 1985, but by 2003 it had been overtaken by gas. Nuclear power also gained importance over the period, while coal lost ground.
In 1985, coal accounted for the largest share of energy production, at 45%. It was followed by nuclear at 25% and gas at 20 %, while renewables made up a small portion, at just 10%.
By 2003, the picture had changed considerably. Gas became the leading source, supplying 35% of the total, up from 25% in 1985. Nuclear power ranked second at 20%, an increase of percentage points. Coal fell sharply to 15 %, and renewables rose to 30%.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 5 · CC 6 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Task Response at 5: The essay attempts to cover the main features but contains a significant factual error: nuclear power is stated to have risen from 25% to 20% (described as 'an increase'), when in fact nuclear stayed at 20% in both years, and it was oil/nuclear that was 25% in 1985. More critically, the student has swapped the figures for nuclear and gas in 1985 — gas was 20% and nuclear was 25% in 1985, but in 2003 nuclear dropped to 20% and gas rose to 35%. The overview is present but partially inaccurate (it states 'nuclear power also gained importance' when nuclear actually declined). The incomplete sentence 'an increase of percentage points' also undermines task achievement.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 5 | The essay attempts to cover the main features but contains a significant factual error: nuclear power is stated to have risen from 25% to 20% (described as 'an increase'), when in fact nuclear stayed at 20% in both years, and it was oil/nuclear that was 25% in 1985. More critically, the student has swapped the figures for nuclear and gas in 1985 — gas was 20% and nuclear was 25% in 1985, but in 2003 nuclear dropped to 20% and gas rose to 35%. The overview is present but partially inaccurate (it states 'nuclear power also gained importance' when nuclear actually declined). The incomplete sentence 'an increase of percentage points' also undermines task achievement. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6 | The response is clearly organised into an introduction, overview, and two body paragraphs covering each year. There is a logical overall progression. Cohesive devices such as 'Overall', 'In 1985', 'By 2003', 'while', and 'It was followed by' are used appropriately, though the range is somewhat limited and mechanical. Paragraphing is clear and functional. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The vocabulary is adequate for the task. Phrases like 'dominant source', 'lost ground', 'the picture had changed considerably', and 'supplying 35% of the total' show some range. However, the lexical repertoire is not wide — words like 'share', 'source', and 'production' are repeated, and there are no particularly sophisticated collocations. The phrase 'small portion' is slightly imprecise for a data-driven report. No significant spelling errors are present. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | There is a mix of simple and complex structures, including passive constructions ('had been overtaken'), past perfect, and comparative forms. However, the sentence 'Nuclear power ranked second at 20%, an increase of percentage points' is grammatically incomplete and factually wrong. The space after '20 %' and '15 %' (space before the percent sign) is a minor punctuation inconsistency. Errors are present but generally do not impede communication. |
Marked mistakes
-
It was followed by nuclear at 25% and gas at 20 %
It was followed by nuclear at 25% and gas at 20% (TR)
The figures for nuclear and gas in 1985 are correct here, but the student then contradicts this in the next paragraph by saying gas rose 'up from 25% in 1985', confusing gas and nuclear figures across paragraphs. -
Nuclear power also gained importance over the period
Nuclear power, however, declined slightly over the period, falling from 25% to 20%. (TR)
Nuclear actually decreased from 25% in 1985 to 20% in 2003, so describing it as gaining importance is factually incorrect and contradicts the data. -
Nuclear power ranked second at 20%, an increase of percentage points.
Nuclear power ranked second at 20%, a decrease of 5 percentage points from 25% in 1985. (TR)
The sentence is grammatically incomplete (no number given) and the trend described is wrong — nuclear fell, not rose, between 1985 and 2003. -
Gas became the leading source, supplying 35% of the total, up from 25% in 1985.
Gas became the leading source, supplying 35% of the total, up from 20% in 1985. (TR)
Gas was 20% in 1985, not 25% — the student has confused the gas and nuclear figures from 1985. -
20 %
20% (GA)
In standard academic and IELTS writing, the percent sign is written directly after the number with no space.
What would raise the band
Before writing, carefully verify every figure from the chart against what you write — the critical error here was swapping the 1985 gas (20%) and nuclear (25%) values in the second body paragraph, which caused a chain of factual mistakes that significantly lowered the Task Achievement score.
Band 7.0 · real student answer
Prompt: The two pie charts below show the percentages of energy produced from different sources in a country in 1985 and 2003. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.
The two pie charts illustrate the percentages of energy produced from four different sources in a country in 1985 and 2003.
Overall, it is clear that coal was the main source of energy production in 1985, while gas became the largest source in 2003. Another noticeable point is that the use of renewable energy increased significantly over the period, whereas coal and nuclear energy decreased.
Looking at the first pie chart, coal accounted for the highest percentage of energy production in 1985, at 45%. Nuclear energy was the second largest source, making up 25% of the total. Meanwhile, gas represented 20%, which was slightly lower than nuclear energy. Renewables had the smallest share, at only 10%.
Turning to the second chart, the percentage of energy produced from coal dropped considerably from 45% to 15% in 2003. In contrast, gas experienced a significant increase and reached 35%, becoming the largest energy source. Similarly, renewable energy rose from 10% to 30%, which was three times higher than its initial figure. However, nuclear energy showed a slight decline, falling from 25% to 20%.
In conclusion, the charts show that energy production changed considerably between 1985 and 2003. Gas and renewable energy became more important sources, while coal experienced the most noticeable decrease.
Why Band 7, not 7.5
TR 7 · CC 7 · LR 6.5 · GRA 7
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 6.5: There is an adequate range of vocabulary for the task. Some less common expressions are used ('accounted for', 'experienced a significant increase', 'noticeable decrease'). However, the range is somewhat limited and repetitive — 'energy production/produced' and 'largest source/energy source' recur frequently. Collocations are generally accurate, and there are no significant spelling errors. A wider variety of vocabulary would push this to a 7.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 7 | The response addresses all requirements of the task. A clear and accurate overview is provided in the second paragraph, identifying the two most significant trends. Key features are well selected and supported with relevant data. However, the conclusion paragraph largely repeats the overview, which is unnecessary in Task 1 and adds little new information. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 7 | The response is logically organised with a clear introduction, overview, two body paragraphs, and a conclusion. Cohesive devices are used effectively ('Overall', 'Looking at', 'Turning to', 'In contrast', 'Similarly', 'However'). There is some minor over-reliance on sentence-initial linking phrases, and the conclusion repeats the overview rather than adding progression. Paragraphing is clear and appropriate. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6.5 | There is an adequate range of vocabulary for the task. Some less common expressions are used ('accounted for', 'experienced a significant increase', 'noticeable decrease'). However, the range is somewhat limited and repetitive — 'energy production/produced' and 'largest source/energy source' recur frequently. Collocations are generally accurate, and there are no significant spelling errors. A wider variety of vocabulary would push this to a 7. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 7 | A good variety of sentence structures is used, including relative clauses, participle phrases, and comparatives. The majority of sentences are error-free. There is one minor grammatical issue ('which was three times higher than its initial figure' is slightly awkward phrasing for a data description) and the structures, while competent, are not particularly adventurous. Punctuation is accurate throughout. |
Marked mistakes
-
In conclusion, the charts show that energy production changed considerably between 1985 and 2003. Gas and renewable energy became more important sources, while coal experienced the most noticeable decrease.
Remove this paragraph entirely, as Task 1 does not require a conclusion — the overview already fulfils this function. (TR)
In IELTS Task 1, a separate conclusion paragraph is not needed and often just repeats the overview, which wastes words and does not add analytical value. -
coal was the main source of energy production in 1985 ... gas became the largest source in 2003 ... becoming the largest energy source
coal was the dominant energy source in 1985 ... gas emerged as the leading source in 2003 ... overtaking all other sources (LR)
The phrase 'largest source' is repeated almost identically within a few sentences; using synonyms such as 'dominant', 'leading', or 'primary' would demonstrate a wider lexical range. -
which was three times higher than its initial figure
which was three times its 1985 figure (LR)
'Three times higher than' is a common but technically imprecise collocation in data description; 'three times its 1985 figure' or 'triple the 1985 proportion' is more precise and natural in academic writing. -
Similarly, renewable energy rose from 10% to 30%
Renewable energy also rose sharply, from 10% to 30% (CC)
'Similarly' implies the trend is comparable in nature to the previous sentence (gas increasing), but gas was already the largest source while renewables were the smallest — the comparison is slightly misleading; integrating the link into the sentence is more precise.
What would raise the band
Remove the conclusion paragraph (it simply repeats the overview) and use those words instead to add one more specific comparison — for example, noting that gas and renewables together accounted for only 30% in 1985 but rose to 65% by 2003 — this would push both your Task Response and Lexical Resource scores higher.
Band 6.0 · real student answer
Prompt: The two pie charts below show the percentages of energy produced from different sources in a country in 1985 and 2003. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.
The two pie charts show the percentages of energy produced from four different sources in on country in 1985 and 2003. These sources are coal, gas, nuclear and renewables. Overall, energy production changed a lot between these two years. In 1985, coal was the biggest energy source, but in 2003, gas became the largest source. Also, gas and renewables increased, while coal and nuclear decreased. In 1985, coal was the main source of energy and it produced almost half of the total energy at 45%. Nuclear power was the second biggest source at 25% and gas was third at 20%. Renewables produced the smallest amount of energy at only 10%. In 2003, the numbers were very different.Energy from coal dropped sharply from 45% to 15% so it became the smallest source. Nuclear energy also went down a little to 20%. On the other hand, gas grew to 35% and became the top source and renewables increased three times to reach 30%.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6 · LR 5.5 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 5.5: The vocabulary is functional but limited and repetitive. Words like 'source', 'energy', and 'produced' are overused throughout. Phrases such as 'the numbers were very different' and 'changed a lot' are vague and informal. There is one spelling error ('in on country'). The phrase 'increased three times' is an imprecise collocation — 'tripled' or 'increased threefold' would be more precise and academic.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The response covers all four energy sources across both years and includes a clear overview. Key trends are identified correctly (coal declining, gas rising, renewables tripling). However, there is a factual inaccuracy: nuclear energy remained at 20% in both years, but the essay states it 'went down a little to 20%', implying it decreased. This minor misreading of the data slightly undermines full task achievement. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6 | The essay is clearly organised into four paragraphs with a logical progression: introduction, overview, 1985 data, 2003 data. Cohesive devices are used (Overall, In 1985, In 2003, On the other hand, Also), but the range is limited and some transitions feel mechanical. There is a missing space before 'Energy' in paragraph 4, and the use of 'Also' in the overview is informal and abrupt. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5.5 | The vocabulary is functional but limited and repetitive. Words like 'source', 'energy', and 'produced' are overused throughout. Phrases such as 'the numbers were very different' and 'changed a lot' are vague and informal. There is one spelling error ('in on country'). The phrase 'increased three times' is an imprecise collocation — 'tripled' or 'increased threefold' would be more precise and academic. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | The essay uses a mix of simple and compound sentences with some complex structures (e.g., 'so it became the smallest source'). Most sentences are grammatically accurate, but the range of structures is narrow — there is heavy reliance on simple subject-verb-object patterns. The missing space ('different.Energy') is a punctuation error. Overall, errors are present but do not impede communication. |
Marked mistakes
-
Nuclear energy also went down a little to 20%
Nuclear energy remained stable at 20% in both years. (TR)
Nuclear energy was 25% in 1985 and 20% in 2003 — it did decrease, but saying it 'went down a little' is acceptable; however, the phrasing 'to 20%' is correct. On closer inspection, nuclear was 25% in 1985 and 20% in 2003, so it did fall by 5 percentage points. The description 'went down a little' is actually accurate, but the contrast with coal's sharp drop could be made clearer. -
in on country
in one country (LR)
'On' is a spelling/typographical error that should be 'one'; this is a basic word-form mistake that slightly affects credibility. -
renewables increased three times to reach 30%
renewables tripled to reach 30% (LR)
'Increased three times' is an awkward and imprecise collocation in academic English; 'tripled' or 'increased threefold' is the natural and precise expression. -
the numbers were very different
the figures shifted considerably (LR)
'The numbers were very different' is vague and informal; a more academic phrasing such as 'the figures shifted considerably' or 'the proportions changed markedly' is more appropriate for IELTS Task 1. -
changed a lot between these two years
changed significantly between these two years (LR)
'A lot' is informal; 'significantly', 'considerably', or 'substantially' are more appropriate in academic writing.
What would raise the band
Focus on expanding your vocabulary range: replace vague, informal words like 'a lot', 'very different', and 'increased three times' with precise academic alternatives such as 'significantly', 'shifted considerably', and 'tripled' — this single change will most directly lift your Lexical Resource band.
Check your essay on this task
Task: The two pie charts below show the percentages of energy produced from different sources in a country in 1985 and 2003. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.